Thursday, April 16, 2015

Preview Round 3: Collingwood v St Kilda

SportMatt

Collingwood v St Kilda
Friday April 17, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 18
Chance of rain 70%: 5-10mm
Wind: E 12kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.37
St Kilda $3.10
“They won’t win a game all season”, that was the rather blunt prediction from Fox Sports commentator David King when assessing St Kilda’s chances in 2015. Two rounds in, and they’ve won a game. The Saints shocked many in the AFL world when on Saturday they travelled to the Gold Coast and dominated the media loved Suns. King wasn’t alone in his thinking though, most good judges had the Saints as wooden spoon favourites leading into 2015, but after two games it’s clear to see St Kilda is on the right track. This Friday night the Saints will look to notch yet another unexpected win when they face Collingwood at the M.C.G. The Magpies themselves weren’t expected to reach any great heights this season, although with one impressive win and one very unimpressive loss, the jury is still out on the biggest club in the land.
Of course these two clubs have some rather important recent history, playing off in two grand finals in one season. The drawn decider of 2010 will go down as one of the greatest AFL Grand Finals of all time, and while the replay the week after was one sided, the two will forever be linked due to the 3 Grand Finals they have played in against each other (1966 being the first). Since then however Collingwood and St Kilda have taken a gradual decline down the ladder, with the Saints bottoming out last season just 4 years removed from that epic 2010 final series. There are good signs though with plenty of youngsters and potential stars on the lists of the respective sides.

PREVIOUS FORM
Collingwood started the season really well with a 12 point win over Brisbane at the Gabba, but last weekend at Etihad Stadium in Melbourne they came crashing down to earth with a 27 point loss to the Adelaide Crows. The Pies were never really in the contest and despite the efforts of captain Scott Pendlebury, Taylor Adams and Dane Swan in the midfield, Collingwood were smashed in the clearances when it counted. The final margin flattered the Magpies too, as they trailed by 56 points at three quarter time before the Crows tired noticeably. It was a wake up call for the Pies after a good first up win, and they’ll have to improve their midfield depth at selection this week.
The Saints headed up to the Gold Coast to play the Suns and started the game as massive under dogs. The second quarter was stunning from the visiting team though as St Kilda stacked on eight goals to the Suns one to all but seal a morale lifting win for the club. The 28 point win came after a competitive loss to the Giants in round one and shows that this Saints team isn’t as bad as most thought it would be. The star from the win over the Suns was Josh Bruce, an ex Giants player who was recruited as a defender but is definitely a forward now. Bruce kicked 6 goals and took plenty of strong marks and with youngster Patrick McCartin soon to debut the St Kilda forward line will be dangerous even when Nick Riewoldt inevitably retires.

COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
After two rounds of the season once again injuries are cruelling the Magpies chances of showing just how good they can be. For three quarters up in Brisbane they looked like a top 8 side, only to lose Steele Sidebottom to a broken thumb and fade poorly. Last weekend against the Crows the absence of Sidebottom and Levi Greenwood (as well as the suspended Josh Thomas) meant that Adelaide just ran rampant through the middle of the ground. There aren’t too many short term fixes either, with Sam Dwyer the only experienced midfield player available for selection from the VFL. The rest are kids, with De Goey, Freeman, Goodyear and Maynard all chances to come in this weekend. Then there’s the injuries that the Pies suffered in the loss to the Crows. Ben Sinclair’s hamstring injury is quite severe, and he’ll be out for at least 4 weeks, while captain Scott Pendlebury, tough midfielder Taylor Adams and new recruit Travis Varcoe all suffered leg injuries on the night. It’s unlikely that all 3 of those players will miss, but with obvious injury concerns it’s likely that at least one will miss, weakening the Pies even more.
There are positives for Magpies fans though, the performances of Tim Broomhead, Adam Oxley and Tom Langdon stood out on a bad night for the club. The 22 year old Oxley, in only his 4th senior game, was one of the best for the Magpies with 33 disposals and 12 rebounds out of defensive 50. In partnership with Langdon and the experienced Alan Toovey they provided Collingwood with some drive off half back at least, although the number of forward 50 entries was overwhelming at times. That’s where Collingwood is at too, they have to rely on their youngsters now to improve, and while many are still running around in the VFL, it’s a good bet that by the latter part of season 2015 the Magpies line-up will look different to what it does now.
At selection Jarrod Witts, Sam Dwyer, Nathan Freeman, Patrick Karnezis and Corey Gault will come into contention with the injury concerns ultimately deciding how many changes need to be made. Witts will be a welcome addition with Brodie Grundy having to ruck almost solo over the first two weeks. The Pies should still be able to win this game, but the Saints won’t be an easy opponent to over come.

OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
St Kilda came into season 2015 not expected to do anything at all really. It was seen as a season where they’d play the plethora of young talent they had on the list, have their good moments but ultimately end up right near, or on, the bottom of the ladder. The win over the Suns on Saturday has changed all that, the Saints now must be looking at that as their standard of performance, something they will seek to recreate in each game from now on. The best players versus the Suns show why St Kilda won, with the only experienced player in the list being Sam Fisher. The Saints, not unlike the Magpies know that overall improvement will come mainly from the first to fourth year players if they are to out perform most expectations of them.
St Kilda’s midfield really struggled last season, in fact it was ranked close to the bottom of the league for contested possessions and clearances among the 18 clubs. Already in 2015 there’s been signs of improvement though, even if they lost in those two categories to the Suns and Giants. Most wouldn’t recognise the Saints midfield now, with names like Newnes, Steven, Armitage, Geary and Shenton, Savage and Sinclair rotating through the middle. The absence of Leigh Montagna last week didn’t even hurt too much although he is expected to miss again this week against the Pies. The Saints ruckman Billy Longer has been a nice recruit too, a high draft pick by the Lions he was a steal for the Saints and is just starting to perform at a top level. They come up against a mightily weakened Magpies central grouping and this is an area the Saints have to break even in to have any chance of winning.
On face value the Saints forward line had a poor season in 2014 with only Melbourne scoring less total points then St Kilda. Their midfield was as much to blame as the forward line though, and with the addition of Josh Bruce and Nick Riewoldt still trying his heart out, the Saints attack looks better already. Ahmed Saad and Tim Membrey also add options up forward although the Magpies defense is their strength area at the moment. St Kilda will rely on Riewoldt and Bruce a lot against the Pies but will also need assistance from the midfield or face wasting a probable advantage in inside forward 50’s.
In season 2014 St Kilda had the most total points scored against them in the entire AFL, showing that their defense was in a transition period much like the rest of their team. The Saints still rely on Sam Fisher as their stalwart down back and Luke Delaney offers able support to top off the key position stocks. They do possess decent run and attack out of defense with Roberton, Savage, Geary and Dempster all providing some drive. Whether or not Collingwood decides to add a third tall to the mix to stretch St Kilda’s defense this is the area of the ground that will be of most concern for the Saints going into this game.
St Kilda came into this season with no external expectations and have played a brand of football that is both exciting and without the burden of pressure. The Saints are definitely headed in the right direction with their youngsters ready to take over from the experienced players at the club and move them forward. This Friday night is a great opportunity for them to really capitalise on a weakened Magpies outfit. The Saints will go into the game with a far healthier list and although they are playing the Pies on their home ground you would expect them to push Collingwood to the limit.

TIP
Collingwood will start short favourites for this game with the bookies yet it’s difficult to see why. The Saints are coming off a morale boosting win while the Pies have been decimated by injuries yet again. If the Magpies had their full list to choose from those odds would make perfect sense but under the circumstances it’s hard to see anything other then a competitive game here.
Collingwood’s chances may well come down to final selection. If Pendlebury, Adams and Varcoe take their place in the side that would make them very hard to beat, but if 2 or even all 3 of don’t pass fitness tests the Saints can win this game. I’m going on faith that at least two of those players take their place in the side and the return of number 1 ruckman Jarrod Witts just getting the Pies over the line.

MAGPIES BY 14 POINTS.

Preview Round 3: Collingwood v St Kilda

AFL

Collingwood v St Kilda
Friday April 17, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 18
Chance of rain 70%: 5 - 10mm
Wind: E 12kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.37
St Kilda $3.10
SUMMARY
When the 2015 fixture was released last October, Collingwood fans would have pencilled in this game against the reigning wooden spooner as a percentage-boosting exercise, just like it was in their round 11 encounter last year.
Suddenly it's a danger game for the Magpies, who were completely outplayed by Adelaide last week. Both teams are 1-1 and the Saints are in the eight for the first time in a while after upsetting finals aspirant Gold Coast.
And while a lot of pre-season excitement at St Kilda centred on No.1 draft pick Paddy McCartin, the club might well have unearthed another promising key forward after Josh Bruce's six-goal effort against the Suns.

LAST FIVE TIMES
  1. R11, 2014, Collingwood 21.14 (140) d St Kilda 8.6 (54) at Etihad Stadium
  2. R6, 2013, Collingwood 15.13 (103) d St Kilda 11.11 (77) at Etihad Stadium
  3. R19, 2012, Collingwood 12.19 (91) d St Kilda 13.7 (85) at the MCG
  4. R21, 2011, Collingwood 14.5 (89) d St Kilda 10.10 (70) at Etihad Stadium
  5. R11, 2011, Collingwood 16.12 (108) d St Kilda 7.9 (51) at the MCG
THE SIX POINTS
  1. UPDATE: Injury List
    Taylor Adams Lower leg Test
    Levi Greenwood* Fractured ankle 8-10 weeks
    Brent Macaffer* Knee 6-8 weeks
    Scott Pendlebury Ankle Test
    Matt Scharenberg Knee 2-3 weeks
    Steele Sidebottom Broken thumb 8-10 weeks
    Ben Sinclair Hamstring 4-6 weeks
    Clinton Young Hamstring 3-5 weeks
    *Placed on the club's long-term injury list
    These teams haven’t played on a Friday night at the MCG since round 15, 2000. This is the 26th time they have met there, with the Pies leading 15-9. There has also been a draw.
  2. The Magpies were smashed by the Crows all over Etihad Stadium last week: in disposals (426-352), marks (126-61), inside 50s (58-44) and scoring shots (30-18).
  3. Saints skipper Nick Riewoldt continues to be a leading markologist, ranking equal-second for marks this season with 22. Collingwood’s best is Jesse White with 14.
  4. Pies champions Dane Swan and Scott Pendlebury have started the season well, ranked fourth (35) and equal-seventh (34) respectively for kicks. Best for the Saints is Shane Savage, who is also equal-seventh (34).
  5. Collingwood’s 86-point win over St Kilda at Etihad Stadium in round 11 last year was the result of domination in inside 50s (63-41), disposals (394-339), tackles (77-61) and scoring shots (35-14). Ex-Pie Dayne Beams was best afield with 33 touches.
  6. Collingwood's three top-ranked players in the Official AFL Player Ratings are all clear of the Saints' best, but only two of these Pies are playing – Scott Pendlebury (No. 2) and Dane Swan (39). Steele Sidebottom (14) is injured. Meanwhile, the Saints' best is Jack Steven (51).
IT'S A BIG WEEK FOR …
Jesse White … The big, athletic key forward has shown some promising signs this season, and was far from the Pies' worst player in the loss to the Crows, and now is the time for him to take a game apart as he has threatened to do for several years. The ex-Swan has been leaping and generally marking well, and should prove a handful. Can the 27-year-old add to his Brownlow Medal tally of one career vote?

PREDICTION: Collingwood by 35 points.

Tuesday, April 14, 2015

Injury List

Injuries
Collingwood v St Kilda
Friday April 17, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 18
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: SE 16kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.37
St Kilda $3.05
Player
Injury
Status
Levi Greenwood Fractured ankle 10-12 weeks
Brent Macaffer Knee 6-8 weeks
Ben Reid Soft-tissue issues Test
Matt Scharenberg Knee 4-6 weeks
Steele Sidebottom Broken thumb 6-8 weeks
Jarrod Witts General soreness Test
Clinton Young Hamstring 3-5 weeks
Ben Sinclair Hamstring 4 weeks


Collingwood has confirmed it will be without the services of Ben Sinclair in the weeks to come.
The small defender tore his hamstring late in the first quarter during Saturday’s loss to Adelaide at Etihad Stadium.
Director of Football Neil Balme addressed the setback in Collingwood Media’s Blackmores Injury Update.
“Sadly, Benny, who’s been going very well, hurt his hamstring. We were a little bit concerned about it and he couldn’t re-join the game,” Balme said.
“We’re not quite sure how bad it is but it’s certainly not good news.”
The injury is a blow for Sinclair who began the year well with 16 disposals against Brisbane in round one.
Hamstring injuries limited his 2014 campaign to just four games, but three consecutive games to round out the year and a strong pre-season saw the 23-year-old establish himself as a clear round one starter.
While the extent of the injury is yet to be determined, Balme classed the Sinclair’s injury status as “medium term”.
Better news emanated from Victoria Park, where Ben Reid and Jarrod Witts got through their returns from injury unscathed in the club’s 26-point win over North Ballarat in the final VFL practice match of the pre-season.
Both will seek to press their claims for AFL selection in the coming weeks and may soon be joined in the state league by another pair of returning Pies.
Matthew Scharenberg (knee) and Clinton Young (hamstring) haven’t pulled on a Collingwood jumper yet in 2015, though Balme believes both are fully recovered and will be on the radar for a return in the near future.
“Matthew Scharenberg is continuing his full training and will play reasonably soon. It’s just a matter of when we pull the trigger on that… probably a couple of weeks,” Balme said.
“Clinton Young is going very well. He probably won’t play this weekend, but the weekend after he should, having overcome that hamstring problem.”
Other players to note on this week’s edition of the Blackmores Injury Update are Steele Sidebottom, Levi Greenwood and Brent Macaffer, who Balme believes fall in the medium-to-long-term injury bracket.

ON THE BLOCK
 Ben Sinclair’s terrible record with injuries continued after suffering a hamstring injury in Collingwood’s 27-point loss to Adelaide.
The club believes the young defender could miss four weeks.
It was a game in which a number of players failed to impress, with the scoreline ultimately flattering the Pies.

ON THE CUSP
There are positives for Collingwood, despite the poor showing last weekend.
Ben Reid played all but 15 minutes in a VFL practice match against North Ballarat on Saturday, while father-son recruit Darcy Moore was named best on ground playing in defence.
Both should soon be pushing for senior selection.

FORECAST
 Collingwood got outworked in the midfield on Saturday and were lucky Adelaide shut down in the final quarter and allowed the margin to be made respectable.
But, with a host of key players still to return from injury, the Pies should improve as the season goes on.
Expect them to be 2-1 after playing St Kilda on Friday night.

Sunday, April 12, 2015

2015 LADDER: ROUND 2

Pos Position    C Change from last round    P Played    W Won    L Lost    D Drawn    F Points for    A Points against
% Percentage    Form Past five results    Next Next opponent    Pts Points

Round 2: Adelaide 90 Collingwood 63


COLLINGWOOD   0.2.2     2.4.16        3.7.25       9.9.63
ADELAIDE           3.6.24   7.11.53   11.15.81    12.18.90

SCORERS - Collingwood:
Blair (3.0), White (2.1), Broomhead (1.1), Fasolo (1.1), Swan (1.1), Cloke (1.0), Crisp (0.2), Langdon (0.1), Pendlebury (0.1)

BEST - Collingwood: Pendlebury, Blair, Oxley, Frost

INJURIES - Collingwood: Ben Sinclair (hamstring)

SUBSTITUTES - Collingwood: Ben Sinclair (hamstring) replaced by Paul Seedsman in the first quarter

REPORTS: Nil

OFFICIAL CROWD: 33,771 at Etihad Stadium



1. Phil's path to respect
ADELAIDE coach Phil Walsh said during the week it was imperative the Crows won games away from home, so the rest of the "Melbourne-centric" competition took them seriously. Just two games into the season, not only has Walsh shown the 17 other teams that the Crows will be a physically tough team to play against, but he's taken the players to Melobourne and returned with a hearty 27-point win over a traditional Victorian power. There was black and white everywhere you looked at Etihad Stadium on Saturday evening but even the blinding flashes of Magpie "theming" around the LED fencing didn't distract the Crows, as they recorded their second win from as many games. 
2. Black and white scoring drought
In the first quarter, the Magpies simply didn't have opportunity to make an impact on the scoreboard, with the Crows dominating inside 50s 19 to eight, and racking up nine scoring shots to the Pies' three, which included Travis Varcoe's after-the-siren set shot that fell short. It took nine minutes into the second term for Collingwood's first goal – a set shot by Jarryd Blair – and they were only able to add one more before half-time as the Crows raced to a 37-point lead. The Pies added just one more in the third quarter as the Crows cut them up in open space, before Buckley's men stepped up to at least fight the game out with six goals in the final term. While it was a nice win for the Crows, it could have been by a lot more given their wasted opportunities (18 behinds) and the way they let the Pies have more of a say in the final term, particularly after best-on-ground Brodie Smith was stretchered off following a nasty incident where Taylor Adams swung him head-first into Varcoe's shin.
                                
"In the first quarter, the Magpies simply didn't have opportunity to make an impact on the scoreboard, with the Crows dominating inside 50s 19 to eight, and racking up nine scoring shots to the Pies' three, which included Travis Varcoe's after-the-siren set shot that fell short."
3. Sharing is caring
As barren as the Pies' scoreline was for three quarters, the Crows' was a healthy representation of a team not reliant on a few players. For the second week running, they shared things around in attack, which was also an indictment on the Pies' defence given the way the visitors were able to flick the ball between multiple options. In the third quarter, Taylor Walker selflessly passed off a goal to Charlie Cameron before Eddie Betts allowed Patrick Dangerfield to get in on the action with a major late in the term. The team-first style is certainly working for the Crows so far and could see them become a contender if they can develop a killer instinct that turns easy wins into landslide results.
4. Convincing Crows?
Former Adelaide captain and current board member Mark Ricciuto said this week he believed Patrick Dangerfield was a "50-50" chance of staying a Crow when his contract ended this season. With Geelong circling for Dangerfield's services, given he grew up on the Victorian surf coast, a comparison between the 2015 Crows and Cats is sure to start creeping into the midfielder's mind. The Cats were sorely beaten by Hawthorn last weekend while the Crows are playing an exciting brand of football that will land them in the finals if they keep it up. Could the ledger tip in the Crows' favour and convince Dangerfield to put pen to paper if they continue to rise?
5. Shocker for Sinclair
After hamstring problems on both sides restricted his output to five senior games in 2014, 23-year-old Ben Sinclair would have entered this year ready for a change of luck. He'd had a decent summer and had 16 touches against the Brisbane Lions last week, before picking up Patrick Dangerfield when the star Crow drifted forward on Saturday. However, as he chased a loose ball near the interchange bench late in the first quarter, Sinclair pulled up sharply and limped straight off the field – he looked the picture of a man who knew exactly what he'd done to the back of his leg, and resigned to another frustrating spell on the sidelines.

THE MEDIA

Adelaide is announcing itself as the real deal under new coach Phil Walsh, beating Collingwood by 27 points at Etihad Stadium on Saturday evening to make a perfect start to the season.
After Walsh told his club to take a cold shower and not get carried away by a big round one win over North Melbourne, the Crows turned up the heat and dominated the Magpies for three quarters to win 12.18 (90) to 9.9 (63).
The win didn't come without a cost, however, with the Crows' best player on the day, Brodie Smith, taken from the ground on a stretcher with concussion early in the fourth quarter.
Smith, who recovered sufficiently to join his teammates for the song in the rooms after the game, was slung in a tackle and his head crashed into Travis Varcoe's knee before hitting the turf.
The All-Australian half-back had been the best player on the ground, racking up 30 possessions, eight inside 50s and a goal, and using the ball with precision by foot.
Led by the classy 23-year-old, the Crows built a 56-point lead at the final change and appeared to be cruising to a big win but inaccuracy in front of goal and a late rally from the Magpies prevented a blowout.
Walsh had this week spoken about the importance of winning in Melbourne for the Crows to gain respect as a team, and they achieved that mission on Saturday.
"Unless you win here, I don't think you get rated," Walsh said post-match.
"The competition is very Melbourne-centric and this is where nine of the 18 teams are, this is where the majority of the media are going to report on footy.
"I don't think they would have thought it was a great performance but we were tough in the contest and I thought we competed really well."
Ricky Henderson (22 possessions and nine inside 50s) gave the Crows their outside class, while Rory Sloane (23 and nine clearances) and Patrick Dangerfield (27 and eight, plus two goals) controlled the stoppages, with Adelaide winning the clearances 45-29.
The Crows' tackling pressure around the ground and ability to have numbers at every contest meant they largely had the game on their terms, enjoying a 58-44 advantage in inside 50s.
In contrast to Smith's elite kicking, the Magpies largely struggled to hit targets by foot for the first three quarters, but they did manage six of the game's last seven goals.
Their tall forwards struggled because of the poor ball use, with Travis Cloke goalless against Daniel Talia, and Jesse White managing just one.
"(Adelaide's) intensity and pressure was excellent, especially early, and we didn't handle that particularly well," Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley said.
"They definitely edged us for wont to go and win that footy and you only have to be off half a step and that's enough. I think that's what we saw.
"That's potentially why you're not clean enough when you get your chances and we weren't clean enough. They for the most part were."
The Magpies were able to withstand Adelaide's pressure for the first 12 minutes of the match, but it was only a matter of time before the Crows took control.
Three goals in 13 minutes – including a gem from the boundary line by Eddie Betts – got the run started in the first quarter, and all with relatively limited output from star forward Taylor Walker, who finished with 2.3.
Already on the back foot, the Magpies were forced to substitute Ben Sinclair late in the opening term after he suffered a hamstring injury right next to the interchange bench.
A second-quarter push from the Magpies was quickly snuffed out, with four goals in seven minutes from the visitors blowing the margin out to 44 points.
Captain Scott Pendlebury (29 possessions) and young half-back Adam Oxley (29 and nine rebound 50s) battled hard, and Jarryd Blair finished with three goals.
                           

This game confirmed some of the findings of the pre-season and round one. One is that Adelaide are playing strong and purposeful football under Phil Walsh. The other is that Collingwood is a team with serious skill deficiencies.
The upper limits of Adelaide's capacities are unclear, but the limits of Collingwood – certainly the 22 that took the field against Adelaide – are all too clear. The Pies are a team that tries, battles, scraps – choose whatever word describing plucky effort that you wish – but they struggle to move the ball, and therefore, to score.
The Pies' mild upset over the Lions was founded upon their longstanding ability to apply pressure and win contests – traits that were paramount at the slippery Gabba.
Alas for the deflating Collingwood masses, Adelaide represented a major step in class compared with the lamentable Lions. The Crows were untroubled in putting the Pies away – the game was really done in about 20 minutes, and only Adelaide's wastefulness kept it from an early blow-out.
To put the skill disparity in context, consider that at three-quarter-time, Collingwood actually led the Crows in contested ball by 17 and had laid the same number of tackles. Yet, the black and white scrappers trailed by 56 points, in what was an entirely accurate measure of what was happening.
Collingwood had lost Steele Sidebottom to a broken thumb for a number of weeks, which means that they entered this match – and will enter the next several – without the players who finished second (Sidebottom), third (departed Dayne Beams) and fourth (discarded Heritier Lumumba) in the club's best and fairest. Levi Greenwood, who would have compensated with further grunt and at least a seasoned body, also has been grounded.
The upshot is that the Crows could – and can – maintain possession of the football. Collingwood couldn't. In today's game, when every team aspires to pressure frenetically, it is the ability to move the ball that differentiates teams.
So, while the Crows were shaded in contested ball, this was completely irrelevant against the sloppy Pies, who, whatever is said about them, didn't give up at any stage. They just couldn't string possession chains together.
The game had few moments to thrill, and most belonged to the Crows, who also had the game's worst moment, when Brodie Smith was slung in a tackle and his head connected with Travis Varcoe's seldom utilised leg. Smith did not move for a while before he was removed on a stretcher late in the last term.
Smith had excelled for the Crows, and while his midfield teammates didn't have massive numbers, it was their superior efficiency and cleanliness that stood out.
Adelaide had complete ownership of the first half, at one point leading an impotent Collingwood 7.10 to 1.2, the quarter-time margin of 22 having flattered Collingwood.
The first quarter was the game writ small – the contested ball numbers were equal, yet the game had been played almost entirely in Adelaide's forward half – the inside 50m entries, to this point, were 19-8.
As the game went on, Collingwood gained more territory, but remained unable to score freely. It was only in junk time – the final quarter – that the Pies found the goals and gave the crowd some small solace for their suffering.
Smith was prominent early, Richard Douglas was effective around the ball, along with a fierce Rory Sloane, who was the game's supreme clearance force in the formative period, helping the Crows to clean up in stoppages (46-29). Paddy Dangerfield's high possession rate wasn't matched by efficiency, but he won important balls. Youngster Cam Ellis-Yolmen was productive. Tex Walker, supreme last week, was profligate this time with 2.3.
While Collingwood's Brodie Grundy was competitive in the ruck, Sam Jacobs – one of Carlton's most egregious list management errors – was a far greater force in general play. Daniel Talia subdued Travis Cloke, whose task was compounded by his team's garbage disposal.
After 12 minutes of unsightly congestion and rugby, another ex-Blue Eddie Betts slotted one of his trademark goals from near the fence to open Adelaide's account.
Collingwood, to this point, had been a holding operation, surviving on pressure acts and the sheer mill of players around the ball.
Play evened up to some extent in the second quarter; Collingwood had the ball in their half often enough to score, except that it couldn't.
Time and again, opportunities were fluffed by errant handballs, wayward kicks and a complete lack of vision.
For the Pies, Adam Oxley's workrate was among the few positive findings. Tom Langdon was steady, Tim Broomhead showed glimpses of class.
Scott Pendlebury, naturally, found the ball, but his team was incapable of maintaining possession for long enough for him to cause any meaningful damage.
Dane Swan's scrappy disposal — not an issue in his Brownlow pomp — is a major concern now, though he fared better as a forward — as his team did — in the game's belated twilight.

ADELAIDE completely outplayed Collingwood for much of its 27-point win, but that might just be a reflection on the Crows’ quality, according to Pies coach Nathan Buckley.
“I was encouraged by our fight, by our want to keep fighting but we were out-structured, outclassed in that first half and outhunted,’’ Buckley said. “They were harder than us.’’
Buckley said it became glaringly obvious during a goal-less first quarter that the Magpies “were off our best, but “how much of that is attributable to them and how much is us I think it’s too early in the season to say.’’
Adelaide got out to a 56-point lead early in the last quarter before the Pies kicked five unanswered goals to make the margin respectable.
Buckley conceded that the Pies “weren’t aggressive enough’’.
“They definitely edged us for want to go and get that footy and you only need to be off by half a step and that’s enough,’’ he said.
Collingwood’s disposal was terrible at times, but Buckley suggested that was largely a function of Adelaide’s pressing style as well as the inability of the Pies forwards to present as targets.
“(Adelaide’s) intensity and pressure was excellent, especially early, and we didn’t handle that particularly well,’’ he said.
But he conceded the Pies used the ball poorly, and whether it was just an off-day, or a sign of a more deep-rooted problem with the playing list was “the age-old question’’.
“We didn’t think we did the basics well enough to give ourselves a chance for our game style to stand up, offensively or defensively,’’ Buckley said.
“Some of it was just basics: missing easy targets or missing easy handball options or not handling the ball cleanly at ground level, but for the most part they (the Crows) made it hard for us to get through and we felt that and we weren’t able to get through often enough.
“I thought we tried to find extra handballs, especially early when the game was hot, when we should have just trusted our forwards to be in position and gone forward.
“And then we did have an yard or two of space that we’d created, the next possession that would have put us out into more space, we just didn’t hit often enough.
“I’d like to suggest it’s (just poor disposal) on the day, but if it happens too consistently then it comes back on the basics of the game.’’
The Pies injury woes worsened when they lost Ben Sinclair to a hamstring strain in the first quarter. But Buckley said the unavailability of several starting-22 players was creating opportunities for the club’s younger footballers, and he was excited that several were getting the chance to rotate through the midfield. “But there’s going to be some ups and downs along the way,’’ he said.
                               


Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley is hopeful the Magpies' poor ball use on Saturday night will not become a trend that sets in for a second straight season.
The Pies had a disposal efficiency of 69 per cent in their 27-point loss to Adelaide, but it was their erratic kicking in particular that took the game out of their grasp in the first half.
Buckley's team ranked last in the AFL for kicking efficiency last season (62.6 per cent) and there were repeated examples of the Magpies handing the ball back to their opponents under the Etihad Stadium roof.
Asked if Saturday night's performance was an accurate reflection of his players' ability or a one-off, the coach was hopeful it was the latter.
"That's the age-old (question) isn't it? I'd like to suggest it's on the day," Buckley said.
"But if it happens too consistently, then it comes back on the basics of the game.
"As the game wore on we put some good passages together, but early in the game everything was so hard for us."
Some of the Magpies' main ball-winners were major culprits on Saturday night, with Dane Swan (56 per cent), Taylor Adams (48 per cent) and Tom Langdon (56 per cent) all using the ball inefficiently.
Scott Pendlebury (78 per cent) and Adam Oxley (79 per cent) often fought a lone hand in the midfield.
"I thought we tried to find extra handballs, especially early when the game was hot and we should have trusted our forwards to be in position and gone forward," Buckley said.
"Then when we did have a yard or two of space that we'd created, the next position that would have put us out into more space we didn't hit often enough.
"We don't think we played anywhere near our best, we don't think we did the basics well enough to give ourselves a chance for our game style to stand up."
Buckley praised the Crows' disciplined game style under new coach Phil Walsh, with the visitors putting relentless pressure on the Magpies when they were in possession.
"For the most part they made it hard for us to get through and we felt that," he said.
"They're playing some good footy and we spoke about it up in the box.
"We were off our best early, but how much of that is attributed to them and how much is us? I think it's too early in the season to say."
With Steele Sidebottom and Levi Greenwood sidelined, the Magpies used Jamie Elliott and Marley Williams through the midfield at times, as well as inclusion Tim Broomhead.
Buckley said he would continue to rotate players through the midfield, with Greenwood (ankle) and Sidebottom (thumb) both facing long stints on the sidelines.
"It gives us an opportunity to play some of our young players through there that have earned those opportunities through their VFL form and through their preparation," he said.
"I'm excited by that possibility and that opportunity, but there's going to be some ups and down along the way."
Defender Ben Sinclair faces time on the sidelines after suffering another hamstring injury, which forced him to be substituted in the first quarter.
Meanwhile, Collingwood's Ben Sinclair looks set for a stint on the sidelines after injuring his right hamstring during his side's loss to Adelaide on Saturday.
The small defender pulled up sore during a sprint to the ball alongside Adelaide's Charlie Cameron with less than three minutes remaining in the first quarter.
                               

  • Ranked 5th in Tackles Per Game
  • Ranked 15th in Kicks Per Game
  • Ranked 18th in Marks Per Game
  • Ranked 12th in Points Per Game
  • Ranked 12th in Hitouts Per Game
  • Ranked 17th in least Opponent Kicks Per Game
  • Ranked 12th in least Opponent Handballs Per Game
  • Ranked 18th in least Opponent Disposals Per Game
  • Ranked 15th in least Opponent Marks Per Game
  • Ranked 14th in least Opponent Tackles Per Game
  • Ranked 13th in least Opponent Hitouts Per Game
  • Ranked 16th in Team to Opponent Kicks Per Game Diff.
  • Ranked 17th in Team to Opponent Disposals Per Game Diff.
  • Ranked 17th in Team to Opponent Marks Per Game Diff.
  • Ranked 12th in Team to Opponent Hitouts Per Game Diff.
Leading player averages
  • Kicks Per Game Dane Swan 17.50
  • Handballs Per Game Taylor Adams 15.50
  • Disposals Per Game Scott Pendlebury 28.50
  • Marks Per Game Jesse White 7.00
  • Goals Per Game Jarryd Blair 2.50
  • Hitouts Per Game Brodie Grundy 31.00
                               
"We didn’t think we did the basics well enough to give ourselves a chance for our game style to stand up, offensively or defensively.
Some of it was just basics: missing easy targets or missing easy handball options or not handling the ball cleanly at ground level, but for the most part they (the Crows) made it hard for us to get through and we felt that and we weren’t able to get through often enough. I thought we tried to find extra handballs, especially early when the game was hot, when we should have just trusted our forwards to be in position and gone forward."
 Nathan Buckley

Thursday, April 09, 2015

Round 2: The Team

Collingwood v Adelaide
Saturday April 11, 4.35pm
Etihad
Fox Footy 4.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 19
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: S 22kph

Betting:
Collingwood $2.60
Adelaide $1.50
B: Alan Toovey, Nathan Brown, Ben Sinclair
HB: Tom Langdon, Jack Frost, Jackson Ramsay
C: Travis Varcoe, Dane Swan, Jack Crisp
HF: Jamie Elliott, Jesse White, Tim Broomhead
F: Alex Fasolo, Travis Cloke, Jarryd Blair
Foll: Brodie Grundy, Taylor Adams, Scott Pendlebury
Int: Tyson Goldsack, Marley Williams, Paul Seedsman, Adam Oxley
Emg: Sam Dwyer, Patrick Karnezis, Corey Gault

IN: Tim Broomhead, Paul Seedsman
OUT: Steele Sidebottom (thumb), Jordan De Goey (omitted)

Fast Facts
Collingwood first met Adelaide at the Docklands Stadium in the 2003 Wizard Cup Grand Final. Despite a bright start, the Magpies let the game slip in the second quarter and ended the night 31-point short. Rhyce Shaw and Tarkyn Lockyer were named their side’s best in front of a crowd of 43,571.
The Magpies hold a 3-3 record in games against the Crows at the Docklands Stadium. In their most recent meeting at the venue, the Pies stormed home with an 11-goal final quarter to romp to a 43-point win. Remarkably, they had been 12-points adrift at the final break.
Saturday’s match will be Collingwood’s 72nd at the Docklands Stadium. Since 2000, the Pies have registered 42 wins and 29 losses in front of an average crowd of 41,309.




Collingwood has turned to leg speed as it looks to record its second win of the home and away season against Adelaide at Etihad Stadium this Saturday.
Youngsters Tim Broomhead and Paul Seedsman will slot into a side that returned from the Gabba with a two-goal win over Brisbane safely in its keeping.
The pair replaces the injured Steele Sidebottom (thumb) and Jordan De Goey, who has been omitted.
Broomhead’s promotion comes off the back of a string of strong performances in the club’s recent VFL practice matches.
He kicked two goals against Richmond at Punt Road Oval a fortnight ago before turning in another encouraging display against the Casey Scorpions last Saturday.
The South Australian is no stranger to the Magpie Army who enjoyed watching the first eight games of his fledgling career during his debut season last year.
Broomhead averaged 12.8 disposals in 2014 but finished the year strongly, kicking three goals in the disastrous loss to Brisbane in round 21 and following it up with another two goals and 21 disposals against Greater Western Sydney.
He averaged 10.0 disposals in his two NAB Challenge outings earlier this year.
“I expect I’ll get a bit of a run through the midfield and up forward a bit,” Broomhead told CollingwoodTV.
“Hopefully I’ll get my hands on the footy as much as I can.”
Seedsman, meanwhile, has not been sighted in the senior side all year after undergoing minor hip surgery in January.
The 23-year-old’s rehabilitation program saw him make a gradual return via the VFL, ramping up his efforts with a fine display against the Scorpions at Olympic Park last Saturday.
“I have a feeling I’ll be playing across the wing and half back,” Seedsman told CollingwoodTV.
“With Sidey (Steele Sidebottom) going down a spot opened up there for me so hopefully I take the opportunity this week and stay in there.”
Seedsman’s run and carry from the back half and through the wings leaves him poised to play a key role against an Adelaide side that helped itself to 35 scoring shots in last week’s 77-point win over North Melbourne.
The Crows enjoyed a bevy of inside 50s (63 to North’s 47), which, compared with Brisbane’s 49 last Saturday night, means the Magpie defence will need to be ready to absorb and repel at will across the four quarters.
Forwards Corey Gault and Patrick Karnezis will again be on stand by, as will Sam Dwyer, who was one of the VFL team’s best in the loss to the Scorpions.

Preview Round 2: Collingwood v Adelaide

AFL

SUMMARY
Collingwood v Adelaide
Saturday April 11, 4.35pm
Etihad
Fox Footy 4.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 19
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: S 22kph

Betting:
Collingwood $2.60
Adelaide $1.50
The Crows' new guard, under coach Phil Walsh and skipper Taylor Walker, enjoyed immediate success last week with a demolition of premiership aspirant North Melbourne, with superstars Walker and Patrick Dangerfield unstoppable, and will be strongly favoured here. The Magpies, meanwhile, were dominant for most of their clash with the Brisbane Lions but can't afford a late fadeout this time against a primed opponent. The Pies will also miss injured star Steele Sidebottom against a deepening Crows' midfield. The winner will complete an impressive opening fortnight.

LAST FIVE TIMES
R18, 2014, Adelaide 14.14 (98) d Collingwood 12.10 (82) at the MCG
R9, 2014, Adelaide 10.16 (76) d Collingwood 7.13 (55) at Adelaide Oval
R16, 2013, Collingwood 17.9 (111) d Adelaide 12.12 (84) at the MCG
R9, 2012, Collingwood 10.15 (75) d Adelaide 6.13 (49) at AAMI Stadium
R9, 2011, Collingwood 20.15 (135) d Adelaide 14.8 (92) at Etihad Stadium

IN THE MIX: COLLINGWOOD
The Magpies will be forced to make at least one change with star midfielder Steele Sidebottom to be sidelined for six to eight weeks after sustaining a broken thumb in the last quarter of their season-opening win over the Brisbane Lions. Left-footer Ben Kennedy, an emergency last week, will come under strong consideration for promotion, as will Nathan Freeman, Tim Broomhead, Paul Seedsman and Sam Dwyer – the latter three performing strongly in Collingwood’s VFL practice match against Casey. Darcy Moore and Jonathon Marsh also impressed in the match, while coach Nathan Buckley has already confirmed Ben Reid will play VFL football this weekend.

IN THE MIX: ADELAIDE
Veteran midfielder Scott Thompson excelled in his first three quarters for the year, playing against West Adelaide in a trial last Saturday. He had 23 possessions and six clearances, while Matt Crouch – who played a full game – collected 34 possessions, seven marks and a goal. James Podsiadly was a rock in defence, which is where coach Phil Walsh sees his role in 2015. However, Walsh added that after such an emphatic AFL win it would be harsh for any player to fall out of last Sunday's 22 before the clash against Collingwood on Saturday. Luke Brown could be the exception if he can't overcome a corked thigh.

THE SIX POINTS
  1. The Crows can thank Patrick Dangerfield for their two wins over the Magpies in 2014. The powerful midfielder picked up three Brownlow votes in both wins after gathering 32 and 26 possessions respectively.
  2. Adelaide skipper Taylor Walker was superb in round one against North Melbourne, with a scoring tally of 6.5 after amassing 21 kicks and 15 marks. Collingwood defeated the Lions after taking only 52 marks for the match in greasy conditions.
  3. Collingwood was strong in close last week, with 165 of their total of 346 possessions coming in contested situations. In better conditions at Adelaide Oval the Crows' 366 possessions included 142 contested.
  4. No team kicked the ball more in round one than the Crows, whose 241 kicks achieved 74.3 per cent efficiency. Collingwood had 197 kicks at 66.8 per cent efficiency.
  5. Collingwood and Adelaide have met six times at Etihad Stadium for three wins apiece.
  6. The Crows boast a distinct advantage over Collingwood in the Official AFL Player Ratings, with Patrick Dangerfield (No. 4), Rory Sloane (No. 5), Brodie Smith (No. 23), Sam Jacobs (No. 40) and Richard Douglas (No. 46) holding sway over Scott Pendlebury (No. 2) and Dane Swan (No. 36). Steele Sidebottom is ranked No. 14 but is injured.
PREDICTION: Adelaide by 15 points.

Preview Round 2: Collingwood v Adelaide

Collingwood News

At selection
Collingwood v Adelaide
Saturday April 11, 4.35pm
Etihad
Fox Footy 4.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 19
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: S 22kph

Betting:
Collingwood $2.60
Adelaide $1.50
Attention at the selection table this week will largely focus on the replacement for Steele Sidebottom.
Sidebottom’s outstanding game against the Lions ended on a sour note when he broke his thumb in the final quarter.
The injury is a blow for the Magpies, for Sidebottom played 19 games and ran second in the Copeland Trophy last season.
Despite the setback, the replacements are queuing up to take Sidebottom’s spot in the midfield.
Sam Dwyer, Paul Seedsman and Tim Broomhead were all amongst the best players list in the VFL practice match against Casey on Saturday, while Nathan Freeman and AFL emergency Ben Kennedy were also impressive.
“We believe in our midfield depth, and the players that we can run through there are actually a strong point, and that will be tested,” Nathan Buckley told the media on Tuesday.
“We'll be looking to introduce fresh legs through there, whether that be forwards who play more midfield time or whether we bring some young players into the mix that have been thereabouts in the VFL.”
Across the border, it will be tough for the Adelaide coaching panel to find negatives from the team’s 77-point win over North Melbourne.
Even away from the Adelaide Oval, the Crows were firing.
Midfielder Scott Thompson had 23 possessions in three quarters against West Adelaide while Matt Crouch dominated 34 disposals and a goal.
Both will be hoping to replace Luke Brown if the defender fails to overcome the corked thigh he sustained against North Melbourne.

Breaking out
A new season gives opportunities for players desperate to prove themselves after a long, gruelling pre-season.
Twenty-one-year-old Taylor Adams is in his fourth year of football and second at Collingwood.
Against Brisbane, Adams showed signs that suggested this could be his best season yet. He collected a career-high 31 disposals, including 13 kicks, 18 handballs and eight clearances.
Many have raised Adams’ name as a replacement for the retired Luke Ball in 2015, and he more than proved his worth in the NAB Challenge, averaging 27.5 disposals in two outings.
With this form and Sidebottom on the sidelines, Adams’ numbers could remain in the 30s for some time to come.

Who takes Tex?
The public image of Adelaide spearhead Taylor Walker is improving in leaps and bounds this year. He’s leading the team, has kicked a bag of goals and is also finding time to comfort nervous children before the game.
The Collingwood defence will be under the pump on Saturday afternoon and will need to band together to keep Walker quiet.
The fitness of Nathan Brown is a great place to start. Brown and Jack Frost have only played alongside each other in the Black and White on six occasions.
Both have played on Walker in the past and have done an impressive job. The 24-year-old has only kicked six goals in his five games against Collingwood.

We meet again, Phil
In round one, 1983, a flashy wingman from Hamilton in rural Victoria debuted for the Collingwood Football Club.
Fast-forward 32 years and this man is the coach of the Adelaide Crows.
Phillip Walsh started his VFL career at Victoria Park and enjoyed an exceptional debut season in 1983, when he played all 22 games and was awarded the Harry Collier Trophy as the club’s Best First Year Player.
The 1983 season was Walsh’s first and only season in the Black and White. He has since worn a number of other colours – first as a player for Richmond and the Brisbane Bears, and then as an assistant coach at Geelong, Port Adelaide and West Coast.
Whether there will be time for Walsh to feel sentiment for his old side on Saturday remains unsure, but keen observers will cast their mind back fondly to the Walsh that ran out for the Pies 32 years ago.

Home away from home
It may not be the fortress that is the MCG, but Collingwood is more than capable of making itself at home at Etihad Stadium.
The Magpies have won 12 of their last 15 games at the venue, with an eight-point loss to the Western Bulldogs last year a rare blemish.
The last time Collingwood met Adelaide at Etihad Stadium was a success for the Magpies who ran out 43-point victors.
Andrew Krakouer and Sharrod Wellingham kicked three goals each in the 2011 clash, while Dale Thomas collected three votes for a 24-disposal game.

Overall record (since 1991)
Collingwood v Adelaide       
Played: 38
Won: 25
Lost: 13
Drawn: 0

Highest score
Collingwood 23.22 (160) def. Adelaide 5.7 (37) in round 15, 1991.

Lowest score
Collingwood 5.9 (39) def. by Adelaide 6.12 (48) in round 21, 1997.

Largest crowd
88,960 in the 2002 Preliminary Final at the MCG.

Smallest crowd
24,663 in round 6, 1997, at Victoria Park.

Did you know?
Adelaide supporters won’t remember Tony Francis fondly.
The South Australian won a career-high 40 disposals in Collingwood’s first meeting with Adelaide in round 15, 1991. The Magpies left Victoria Park 123 points to the good.
This winning margin has never been surpassed by either of the two teams, with the next closest a 110-point Adelaide victory in round 21, 2005.

Preview Round 2: Collingwood v Adelaide

SportMatt

Collingwood v Adelaide
Saturday April 11, 4.35pm
Etihad
Fox Footy 4.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 19
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: S 22kph

Betting:
Collingwood $2.60
Adelaide $1.50
After such a long wait, round 1 of the 2015 AFL premiership season has been completed. After the nine games had been played it became apparent that once again Hawthorn stood out from the pack, with several other teams clambering to be in a group behind them. After just one round of games the most impressive performance was from the Adelaide Crows, who on Sunday absolutely destroyed North Melbourne in the statement performance of the opening weekend. The Crows, a side that missed the finals the past two seasons, jumped out of the blocks with a 12 goal to 3 first half to all but secure the win by the long break. Under new coach Phillip Walsh it was an impressive performance that really put the Crows name up there as a finals contender.
This Saturday, the Crows travel to Melbourne to play another round one winner, Collingwood, at Etihad Stadium in the twilight time slot. The Magpies win may not have been as impressive as the Crows opener, but an interstate win against the Brisbane Lions, by 12 points, gave the biggest club in the land a nice start to the season also. Like the Crows the Pies led by a large margin just after half time, until the home team came roaring home in one of the games of the round. With both clubs having a win under their belts already, a win here is more of an opportunity then a necessity, with the winner certain to find themselves in the upper echelon of the ladder.
Adelaide and Collingwood clashed twice last season with the Crows coming away victors in both games. The first was a 21 point win at the fortress that is Adelaide Oval early in the season, a game that had some controversy regarding the volume of the siren. The second clash, later in the season, resulted in a 16 point win for the Crows at the M.C.G. when superstar Patrick Dangerfield took over late and ensured an away win. This weekend’s game is a real opportunity for two sides who weren’t rated that highly to start the season on a perfect note with a 2-0 record.

PREVIOUS FORM
With only one proper round completed there’s not much form to go on but what there is seems impressive from both teams. The Crows big win at home against North Melbourne was the perfect way to start the season under their new senior coach. After an initial period of jousting the Crows took the game over half way through the first quarter and never looked back. The speed and accuracy of the ball movement from the home team was as proficient as any teams’ throughout round 1. The most promising sign for Adelaide though was how the forward line functioned, with Taylor Walker booting 6 goals, Eddie Betts getting 4 goals and Josh Jenkins putting 3v majors on the board. Of course the poor effort from the Kangaroos made it a little easier for the Crows but the domination could not be ignored by any future opponents.
Collingwood ventured up to Brisbane as under dogs last Saturday night and started the season on fire, at one point holding a 53 point lead. The Lions charged late as the Pies tired in the humidity but they couldn’t get within single figures as Collingwood notched a 12 point win. The loss of Steele Sidebottom (broken thumb) in game was the only negative for the Magpies on the night as they showed quicker ball movement and better accuracy, something which was similar to the Crows. Pendlebury, Swan and Sidebottom lead from the front although the 31 possession game from Taylor Adams showed he is ready to take that next step and dominate at this level. It wasn’t a perfect night for tall forwards yet Travis Cloke and Jesse White had 10 shots at goal between them, something that shows this Pies forward line will be dangerous in 2015. It was a great start to the season for a club under a lot of media pressure.

COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
The Magpies came into 2015 with a lot of external pressure on them. The media had already placed senior coach Nathan Buckley high on the ladder of coaches in danger of getting the sack, yet half way through the third quarter last week all was going rosy for the Pies. The loss of Steele Sidebottom with a broken thumb put a dampener on the win, as did the 30 minute period where the Lions kicked 7 goals in a row. The final 8-10 minutes would have pleased Buckley as the Pies repelled attack after attack from the home team and held on for the two goal win. Young ruckman Brodie Grundy was one of the Pies best in those first 3 quarters, but with little support he tired late and he may need more support this week against the Crows. The midfield won the battle in those first 2 and ½ quarters with the usual suspects leading the way. The increase in output from Adams and Blair also added to that early midfield dominance with Blair named by the club as their best contributor on the night. It was a performance that most media judges didn’t expect and one that raised the hopes of the Magpies returning to the finals in 2015.
The loss of Sidebottom and the unavailability of Greenwood and Reid means that Collingwood go into this game nowhere near full strength. Their is capable back up though with Sam Dwyer, Tim Broomhead, Ben Kennedy, Paul Seedsman, Nathan Freeman and Jonathon Marsh all impressing in the VFL on Saturday. The coaching staff will look at the midfield as the area that needs assistance against the Crows so Dwyer, Broomhead, Kennedy and Freeman will come into contention. Watching the VFL is an experience itself these days at Collingwood with so many future stars running around, with Darcy Moore obviously the biggest interest for most. This weekend should see the experienced duo of Ben Reid and Jarrod Witts return with Matt Scharenberg and Clinton Young close to returning too. It shows the young talent the Magpies have on their list and the improvement that lays within. Against the Crows though the Pies will have to make do, and although they will go in under full strength if they apply that intense pressure that is their trademark they can push the Crows and even pull of an upset.

OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
The Crows entered season 2015 with a new found sense of hope after switching senior coaches in the off season. Out went Brenton Sanderson, who only 2 seasons back had got them within a kick of a grand final, and in came Phillip Walsh, who had worked with the juggernaut that is Port Adelaide for the past few seasons. Adelaide started last season with a 4-7 win loss record, and despite flying home to only miss the finals by one game a coaching change came. Straight away it’s given the playing group a boost with Walsh wanting the group to play a fast flowing, aggressive form of football. The size of the Adelaide Oval playing field was used to full effect versus the Kangaroos as the Crows ran wild for the best part of four quarters. The Crows really do look like a team that will return to the finals after 2 seasons out.
The Crows midfield is stacked with talent and is an obvious area of strength. Contract disputes with stars Dangerfield and Sloane may be some distraction later in the year but early on those two were as good as anyone against North. Their midfield really is deep with Dangerfield, Sloane, Douglas (a game high 31 possessions last week), McKay, Henderson and Eliis-Yeoman making it a really strong group. Add the returning Nathan Van Berlo and the small forwards who play as mids when the ball comes forward and this is a formidable central core. They are well serviced in the ruck too by Sam Jacobs with Josh Jenkins helping the man they call “Sauce” out. The Pies midfield will be weakened this week due to injury so this is the area the Crows will look to dominate in.
The Adelaide forward line is starting to come together nicely, as show by the fact that James Podsiadly can’t get a game. Taylor Walker started the season on fire last week, and with the likes of Betts, Jenkins, Lynch and Cameron helping him out scoring once they get the ball forward won’t be a problem for the Crows. They meet a Collingwood backline this week that is also weakened by injury with Ben Reid the real missing piece for the Magpies The Crows will look to stretch the Pies relatively young defense and with Walker fit and firing it’s going to be a real test for the Magpies for sure.
The Crows backline on paper may appear to be a weakness as shown by being the 11th ranked defense in 2014. They do possess one of the best young defenders in the AFL though in Daniel Talia who is likely to face off with Travis Cloke on Saturday. Other youngsters Luke Brown and Kyle Hartigan make up the key defenders for Adelaide and will have to be on their game against a dangerous Magpies forward line. Where the Crows will try and exploit Collingwood is with their ball movement and run out of the defensive zone, and teams in the past have dominated the Magpies in that area. This may well be the one part of the ground though that the Pies will look to get on top and pressure the Crows into mistakes.
The Adelaide Crows are still a work in process but if round 1 was anything to go by that work is coming along quite well. Of course they have to travel this week but surely they would see it as a real opportunity to test their new found confidence. The Crows won’t make many changes to the 22 that played against the Kangaroos because as they say “it it ain’t broke don’t fix it”. Adelaide will start this game as favourite but know that beating Collingwood in Melbourne won’t be easy, and they will have to play near their best to start the season with a 2-0 record.

TIP
Adelaide will enter this game as clear favourites and most so called experts will tip them to get over the line on Saturday. Collingwood though seem to have developed a game plan that relies more on attack and pressure of the ball carrier then the personnel named on the field. The Crows ability to win the midfield battle will decide this game, if they can get on top for longer periods then the Lions were able to, they will win.
However if Collingwood is able to break even, or even dominate as they did against the Lions for almost 3 quarters, their forward line is good enough to put a score on the board. Being under the roof at Etihad conditions don’t suit or hinder either team but being at home for the first time should be a distinct advantage for the Pies. Ultimately it comes down to who will play at a higher intensity for longer and with a confidence boosting win under their belts, I believe Collingwood can get the win here.
MAGPIES BY 5 POINTS.

Keeffe and Thomas to face ASADA

SUPERFOOTY

Collingwood v Adelaide
Saturday April 11, 4.35pm
Etihad
Fox Footy 4.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 19
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: S 22kph

Betting:
Collingwood $2.60
Adelaide $1.50
COLLINGWOOD players Lachie Keeffe and Josh Thomas will plead their case with ASADA on Monday ahead of the testing of their B samples the following day.
The provisionally banned pair continue to undertake some fitness training as they confront the reality of two-year bans.
They have been summoned by ASADA to discuss their positions and could know the result of the B sample by the following week.
But sports drug experts say the banned drug Clenbuterol rarely deteriorates in a sample — meaning the A and B samples are likely to be identical.
Even if they were able to convince the anti-doping body they took an illicit drug laced with a banned substance, they would receive little or no discount.
If ASADA was to heavily discount bans based on that defence it would become the default position for every athlete who took a banned substance.
If a player was to suggest they took an illicit substance laced with a banned drug they would need proof, possibly including testing of the illicit substance.
An admission of illegal drug use would open up other legal avenues against the players, which is why some players simply argue “no defence” and accept bans.
If the B sample proves positive the players will plan strategies for an anti-doping tribunal in May or June at the earliest.
It is likely the players would have limited options to argue for a reduced ban.
A “no fault or negligence” defence provides for a discounted penalty, but a player would need to prove he had no role in the drugs entering his body.
Collingwood says it has audited its supplements and dietary program and players do not take any other supplements independently.
The sole positive is that they tested positive for the banned drug before the AFL Commission rubber-stamped the 2015 WADA code.
It means they would have strong grounds to argue the league could not retrospectively apply the code, which features four-year maximum bans instead of two years.
The pair are said to be in good spirits despite the circumstances and have been offered counselling from the AFL Players Association.
The absence of the midfielder Thomas will begin to bite hard at Collingwood this week given the club’s injured midfield.
Steele Sidebottom will miss 6-8 weeks with a thumb injury and will be missed against a dominant Adelaide midfield.

Tuesday, April 07, 2015

Injury List

AFL

Collingwood v Adelaide
Saturday April 11, 4.35pm
Etihad
Fox Footy 4.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 21
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: S 17kph

Betting:
Collingwood $2.40
Adelaide $1.55
THE LONG-TERM injuries to Steele Sidebottom and Levi Greenwood will test Collingwood's midfield depth like never before, coach Nathan Buckley concedes.
Sidebottom is due to have an operation on his broken thumb later on Tuesday, sidelining him for up to two months, while Greenwood is looking at the same time out with a hairline fracture of his ankle, suffered in the final NAB Challenge game on March 21.
The Magpies will confront Adelaide at Etihad Stadium on Saturday afternoon, the Crows fresh off a 77-point annihilation of North Melbourne at Adelaide Oval.
"We've got two of our first-choice midfielders who won't play for a period of time so it's a challenge for us," Buckley said on Tuesday.
"We believe in our midfield depth, and the players that we can run through there are actually a strong point, and that will be tested.
"We'll be looking to introduce fresh legs through there, whether that be forwards who play more midfield time or whether we bring some young players into the mix that have been thereabouts in the VFL."
Buckley named Sam Dwyer, Tim Broomhead and Paul Seedsman as those in the running to replace Sidebottom, while he also singled out Darcy Moore and Jonathon Marsh for their efforts in defence for the Magpies' VFL team in a practice match against Casey Scorpions on Saturday afternoon.
Injuries
Player
Injury
Estimated Return
Levi Greenwood Fractured ankle 10-12 weeks
Brent Macaffer Knee 6-8 weeks
Ben Reid Soft-tissue issues Test
Matt Scharenberg Knee 4-6 weeks
Steele Sidebottom Broken thumb 6-8 weeks
Jarrod Witts General soreness Test
Clinton Young Hamstring 3-5 weeks
Buckley will have noted that the Crows' dominance against North was borne out of their midfielders' ability to win the ball in tight, smashing the Kangaroos in contested possessions (142-115), and allowing star forward Taylor Walker to take full toll with six goals.
"He moves really well. He just looks like a big midfielder," Buckley said of Walker.
"He's got great agility. He's got an understanding of the game and where to put himself and he can impact aerially.
"Their forwards are all dangerous – (Eddie) Betts, (Taylor) Walker, (Tom) Lynch, (Josh) Jenkins, (Charlie) Cameron.
"They've got quite a few scoring avenues."
In positive news for the Magpies, Ben Reid will play in the VFL this weekend as he builds his way back up from a series of soft-tissue injuries which limited his pre-season.
"Ben will play this week and continue to increase his game load," Buckley said.
"We think we're managing him really well. Externally, there's an impatience to see him up and about.
"But we've said all along that ‘Reidy’ will play when he's ready, and he's still got some more game load to get in.
Buckley wouldn’t be drawn on the situations of Lachlan Keeffe and Josh Thomas after the pair returned a positive A-sample test to the performance-enhancing drug clenbuterol.
"There won't be any change in their status until the 'B' sample gets tested (on April 14)," Buckley said.

The Collingwood Bugle is a wholly owned subsidiary of Madame Fifi's House of Earthly Pleasures, Smith Street, Collingwood