Tuesday, September 29, 2015
For The Record: 2015 Brownlow
Collingwood
Midfielder Dane Swan, the 2011 Brownlow medallist, took the honours for the Magpies with 17 votes and was followed closely by captain Scott Pendlebury on 15 votes. Fellow onballer Steele Sidebottom (nine votes) was the third-highest Magpie despite missing six rounds in the early part of the season with a broken thumb. Midfielder Taylor Adams (eight votes) was ineligible after being suspended for two games. The Pies polled 66 votes in total.
Sunday, September 27, 2015
Sunday, September 20, 2015
Friday, September 18, 2015
Collingwood 2015 Season Review
SUPERFOOTY
SNAPSHOT
Wins: 10
Losses: 12
Draws: 0
Ladder position: 12
%: 106.3
Last year: 11th (down one)
WHAT WENT RIGHT
The Pies got off to another good start, winning eight of its first 11 matches and playing one of the league’s most exciting brands of footy. After losing Dayne Beams to Brisbane during last year’s trade period, Collingwood showed they managed to make the best of a bad situation by picking up Jack Crisp (former Lion) and Jordan De Goey (pick No. 5), who played key roles for the team this season, plus Levi Greenwood (pick No. 25). Travis Varcoe also proved why the Pies were so keen to get him, playing a key role off halfback and at times half forward, with his tackling pressure a highlight. Taylor Adams was a rock in the midfield and Brodie Grundy took another step. Got games into highly-rated youngsters Darcy Moore, Jackson Ramsay, Jonathon Marsh, Brayden Maynard, Matthew Scharenberg and Adam Oxley who all impressed at various stages and didn’t look out of place at senior level.
WHAT WENT WRONG
Buckley and the Pies hope they won’t have to hear the phrase “honourable loss” much in the future after having their fair share this season against Fremantle, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, Sydney, Western Bulldogs and even Essendon in the final round. Key swingman Ben Reid had another frustrating and injury-ruined year, managing only five games, while injuries to key players Travis Cloke, Jamie Elliott, Steele Sidebottom and Levi Greenwood happened at the worst possible time and meant Buckley never had his best team on the park. Lachie Keeffe and Josh Thomas also tested positive to a banned drug in the pre-season and threw some of Buckley’s pre-season plans out the window.
SUPERCOACH STUD
Scott Pendlebury enjoyed another fine season, averaging over 116 SuperCoach points per game but it was Dane Swan that provided Collingwood and SuperCoach players with heart-warming moments. With injuries now behind him, Swan got back to some vintage form, averaging over 105 points per game.
SUPERCOACH DUD
Former top 10 draft pick Nathan Freeman was one of the most selected rookies in the pre-season only to not play a senior game courtesy of more hamstring issues. After being one of the most popular picks last year, Steele Sidebottom had an inconsistent season after breaking his thumb in Round 1 and missing six weeks. Dropped $94,900 in value and became a “could go big or could bust” player.
THE LIST
Elite: Scott Pendlebury, Dane Swan, Travis Cloke
Big improvers: Nathan Brown, Taylor Adams, Travis Varcoe, Jack Crisp, Marley Williams
Gone: Clinton Young (delisted), Sam Dwyer (delisted), Tony Armstrong (delisted), Lachlan Keeffe (suspended/delisted), Josh Thomas (suspended/delisted), Michael Manteit (delisted)
Trade bait: Paul Seedsman
WHAT THEY NEED
The Pies are still crying out for a proven key forward to partner Travis Cloke after Jesse White struggled again and found himself dropped between Rounds 18 and 21 and Ben Reid looks better in defence. Buckley’s team was also found out for a lack of midfield depth and experience following the departure of Beams and Heritier Lumumba last year. Too much was left to Pendlebury, Swan and Sidebottom with Greenwood out injured for most of the season. GWS young gun Adam Treloar fits the bill perfectly to add some class to a hard-working engine room and luckily wants to come, now the Pies need to go and get him. Chasing Brisbane’s James Aish who’d also fit the bill.
PREMIERSHIP CLOCK
About 7.30pm. Despite missing the finals, the Pies are well placed to challenge in the near future with stars like Pendlebury, Cloke and Swan now teaming with genuine young guns in Adams, Crisp, De Goey and Moore among others. Another year of development into those players, plus the likes of Jack Frost and Tom Langdon has Collingwood well placed after just falling short against the top sides this season. Should at the very least push up into finals next year and knock off one or two of the top teams during the season.
BEST AND FAIREST?
Skipper Scott Pendlebury would surely be the favourite to take home another Copeland Trophy from Dane Swan but don’t be surprised if young gun Taylor Adams features heavily in the voting after averaging 27.4 disposals in his 18 games. Full back Nathan Brown was also a consistent performer and one of the league’s most stingiest defenders, while Travis Varcoe should poll well in his first season as a Magpie.
CHAMPION DATA SAYS
SNAPSHOT
Wins: 10
Losses: 12
Draws: 0
Ladder position: 12
%: 106.3
Last year: 11th (down one)
WHAT WENT RIGHT
The Pies got off to another good start, winning eight of its first 11 matches and playing one of the league’s most exciting brands of footy. After losing Dayne Beams to Brisbane during last year’s trade period, Collingwood showed they managed to make the best of a bad situation by picking up Jack Crisp (former Lion) and Jordan De Goey (pick No. 5), who played key roles for the team this season, plus Levi Greenwood (pick No. 25). Travis Varcoe also proved why the Pies were so keen to get him, playing a key role off halfback and at times half forward, with his tackling pressure a highlight. Taylor Adams was a rock in the midfield and Brodie Grundy took another step. Got games into highly-rated youngsters Darcy Moore, Jackson Ramsay, Jonathon Marsh, Brayden Maynard, Matthew Scharenberg and Adam Oxley who all impressed at various stages and didn’t look out of place at senior level.
Dane Swan put an injury-wrecked 2014 behind him and was outstanding for the Pies in 2015. Picture: Tim Carrafa |
WHAT WENT WRONG
Buckley and the Pies hope they won’t have to hear the phrase “honourable loss” much in the future after having their fair share this season against Fremantle, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, Sydney, Western Bulldogs and even Essendon in the final round. Key swingman Ben Reid had another frustrating and injury-ruined year, managing only five games, while injuries to key players Travis Cloke, Jamie Elliott, Steele Sidebottom and Levi Greenwood happened at the worst possible time and meant Buckley never had his best team on the park. Lachie Keeffe and Josh Thomas also tested positive to a banned drug in the pre-season and threw some of Buckley’s pre-season plans out the window.
SUPERCOACH STUD
Scott Pendlebury enjoyed another fine season, averaging over 116 SuperCoach points per game but it was Dane Swan that provided Collingwood and SuperCoach players with heart-warming moments. With injuries now behind him, Swan got back to some vintage form, averaging over 105 points per game.
SUPERCOACH DUD
Former top 10 draft pick Nathan Freeman was one of the most selected rookies in the pre-season only to not play a senior game courtesy of more hamstring issues. After being one of the most popular picks last year, Steele Sidebottom had an inconsistent season after breaking his thumb in Round 1 and missing six weeks. Dropped $94,900 in value and became a “could go big or could bust” player.
THE LIST
Elite: Scott Pendlebury, Dane Swan, Travis Cloke
Big improvers: Nathan Brown, Taylor Adams, Travis Varcoe, Jack Crisp, Marley Williams
Gone: Clinton Young (delisted), Sam Dwyer (delisted), Tony Armstrong (delisted), Lachlan Keeffe (suspended/delisted), Josh Thomas (suspended/delisted), Michael Manteit (delisted)
Trade bait: Paul Seedsman
WHAT THEY NEED
The Pies are still crying out for a proven key forward to partner Travis Cloke after Jesse White struggled again and found himself dropped between Rounds 18 and 21 and Ben Reid looks better in defence. Buckley’s team was also found out for a lack of midfield depth and experience following the departure of Beams and Heritier Lumumba last year. Too much was left to Pendlebury, Swan and Sidebottom with Greenwood out injured for most of the season. GWS young gun Adam Treloar fits the bill perfectly to add some class to a hard-working engine room and luckily wants to come, now the Pies need to go and get him. Chasing Brisbane’s James Aish who’d also fit the bill.
Adam Treloar has requested a trade to Collingwood. Picture: Getty |
PREMIERSHIP CLOCK
About 7.30pm. Despite missing the finals, the Pies are well placed to challenge in the near future with stars like Pendlebury, Cloke and Swan now teaming with genuine young guns in Adams, Crisp, De Goey and Moore among others. Another year of development into those players, plus the likes of Jack Frost and Tom Langdon has Collingwood well placed after just falling short against the top sides this season. Should at the very least push up into finals next year and knock off one or two of the top teams during the season.
BEST AND FAIREST?
Skipper Scott Pendlebury would surely be the favourite to take home another Copeland Trophy from Dane Swan but don’t be surprised if young gun Taylor Adams features heavily in the voting after averaging 27.4 disposals in his 18 games. Full back Nathan Brown was also a consistent performer and one of the league’s most stingiest defenders, while Travis Varcoe should poll well in his first season as a Magpie.
CHAMPION DATA SAYS
Tuesday, September 15, 2015
Thursday, September 10, 2015
Wednesday, September 09, 2015
Collingwood 2015 Season Review
REAL FOOTY
Finished: 12th Last season: 11th
Players used: 36
Personnel changes
The three key pillars – president Eddie McGuire, chief executive Gary Pert and senior coach Nathan Buckley have remained a solid team for several years now, confident in the list regeneration and changing culture under Buckley despite the fact the club has shifted down, or at best maintained their position, on the ladder every year since parting ways with Mick Malthouse. "Bullish" is the term regularly used by the club and good industry judges in relation to the Pies' premiership charge. Next year is the time to start running back up the ladder. Assistant coach Scott Burns could yet be a candidate for the Essendon, or maybe even Adelaide, senior coaching jobs.
Out the door
The two big names that won't be available next year are Lachlan Keeffe and Josh Thomas, although the club have committed to re-signing the pair for 2017 once they have served their suspensions for consuming performance-enhancing drugs. What happens to Clinton Young? The former Hawk did not play a senior game this year and will be 30 next year.
What went right
The first half of the season. As it turned out, the club's 8-3 start wasn't as good as it appeared, for seven of those wins came against non-finals teams. But it certainly looked impressive at the time, as Buckley's team found itself inside the top four halfway through the year. In a most unpredictable year, the Pies have actually bucked the trend by basically beating all the teams below them and losing to those above them. That in itself is an achievement. The only exceptions (as at round 22) were the surprise loss to Melbourne in round 18 (it is too harsh to put the three-point away loss to Port Adelaide in the same category) and the early win over North Melbourne and late one over Geelong. In reference to the bright start, Buckley concluded midway through the year that it was an "old-school mentality" to tell his players they had not achieved anything. "The fact is, we have achieved something," he said. Presumably, he will still feels the same way.
What went wrong
The second half of the year. The week after Buckley uttered those words, the Pies went on a six-game losing streak – their longest since 2005 – and eventually missed the finals. The 8-3 start turned the corner into a 2-8 finish (as at round 22) and included a stretch that defined the season: close, but not close enough. The Pies lost to premiership contenders Fremantle, Hawthorn, West Coast and the Western Bulldogs in games they were right in. But when it counted most in the last quarter, they "failed to step up to the plate", as Buckley would later surmise. Finding the forward line balance has improved late in the year, but remains a concern given Jesse White wasn't able to perform, and Ben Reid only started playing late.
Shining lights
Dane Swan has rebounded strongly from a down year in 2014, Taylor Adams has taken the "next step" the club hoped he would, while Scott Pendlebury has done what he always does. The Pies knew they were getting more than a "set of steak knives" in Jack Crisp, but he's probably surprised even himself with the level of impact he's had. Travis Varcoe has proved another handy pick-up, while No.5 draft pick Jordan De Goey lived up to his reputation as a ready-made player, contributing most of the season. Speaking of bright futures, how good does Darcy Moore look?
What's required to improve in 2016
One of Reid or Moore needs to step up and spread the load in the forward half, Levi Greenwood should have a greater output next year and we could start to see something from a couple of top 10 draft picks – Matt Scharenberg, provided he stays, and Nathan Freeman, provided he gets fit. Brent Macaffer could also become a factor.
Who'd have believed it
The words "Travis Cloke" and "trade" would come up in the same sentence.
Finished: 12th Last season: 11th
Players used: 36
Personnel changes
The three key pillars – president Eddie McGuire, chief executive Gary Pert and senior coach Nathan Buckley have remained a solid team for several years now, confident in the list regeneration and changing culture under Buckley despite the fact the club has shifted down, or at best maintained their position, on the ladder every year since parting ways with Mick Malthouse. "Bullish" is the term regularly used by the club and good industry judges in relation to the Pies' premiership charge. Next year is the time to start running back up the ladder. Assistant coach Scott Burns could yet be a candidate for the Essendon, or maybe even Adelaide, senior coaching jobs.
Out the door
The two big names that won't be available next year are Lachlan Keeffe and Josh Thomas, although the club have committed to re-signing the pair for 2017 once they have served their suspensions for consuming performance-enhancing drugs. What happens to Clinton Young? The former Hawk did not play a senior game this year and will be 30 next year.
What went right
The first half of the season. As it turned out, the club's 8-3 start wasn't as good as it appeared, for seven of those wins came against non-finals teams. But it certainly looked impressive at the time, as Buckley's team found itself inside the top four halfway through the year. In a most unpredictable year, the Pies have actually bucked the trend by basically beating all the teams below them and losing to those above them. That in itself is an achievement. The only exceptions (as at round 22) were the surprise loss to Melbourne in round 18 (it is too harsh to put the three-point away loss to Port Adelaide in the same category) and the early win over North Melbourne and late one over Geelong. In reference to the bright start, Buckley concluded midway through the year that it was an "old-school mentality" to tell his players they had not achieved anything. "The fact is, we have achieved something," he said. Presumably, he will still feels the same way.
What went wrong
The second half of the year. The week after Buckley uttered those words, the Pies went on a six-game losing streak – their longest since 2005 – and eventually missed the finals. The 8-3 start turned the corner into a 2-8 finish (as at round 22) and included a stretch that defined the season: close, but not close enough. The Pies lost to premiership contenders Fremantle, Hawthorn, West Coast and the Western Bulldogs in games they were right in. But when it counted most in the last quarter, they "failed to step up to the plate", as Buckley would later surmise. Finding the forward line balance has improved late in the year, but remains a concern given Jesse White wasn't able to perform, and Ben Reid only started playing late.
Shining lights
Dane Swan has rebounded strongly from a down year in 2014, Taylor Adams has taken the "next step" the club hoped he would, while Scott Pendlebury has done what he always does. The Pies knew they were getting more than a "set of steak knives" in Jack Crisp, but he's probably surprised even himself with the level of impact he's had. Travis Varcoe has proved another handy pick-up, while No.5 draft pick Jordan De Goey lived up to his reputation as a ready-made player, contributing most of the season. Speaking of bright futures, how good does Darcy Moore look?
What's required to improve in 2016
One of Reid or Moore needs to step up and spread the load in the forward half, Levi Greenwood should have a greater output next year and we could start to see something from a couple of top 10 draft picks – Matt Scharenberg, provided he stays, and Nathan Freeman, provided he gets fit. Brent Macaffer could also become a factor.
Who'd have believed it
The words "Travis Cloke" and "trade" would come up in the same sentence.
Collingwood 2015 Season Review
AFL - Ben Collins
What worked
We were pretty much spot on, predicting an 11th placing for the Pies as they went through a rebuilding phase.
Overall rating
5.5/10. After 14 rounds – following narrow losses to Hawthorn and Freo – the Pies peaked at about 8.5/10, given the consensus view that they wouldn't figure in the finals. But almost from that moment, they went into freefall.
The coach
When you coach Collingwood, and your name is Nathan Buckley, external pressure is everywhere. So don't expect Buckley to be daunted by the fact that his contract expires at the end of next season. Most gave the Pies Buckley's hope of making the finals this year, so to have them around the top four for two-thirds of the season was some effort. However, late-season losses have many questioning his abilities.
Most Valuable Player
A tie between Scott Pendlebury and Dane Swan Hard to split the prolific Pies pair, with skipper Pendlebury producing another high-quality season, despite battling a calf issue and spending more time forward, and Swan overcoming an injury-hampered 2014 to perform superbly. They amassed remarkably similar stats, with Pendlebury perhaps more consistent and Swan enjoying more standout games. Fellow midfielder Taylor Adams deserves an honourable mention.
Surprise packet
Jack Crisp When superstar midfielder Dayne Beams was traded to the Brisbane Lions in exchange for picks No.5 and 25 and Crisp, not even the Pies could have envisaged the impact the former rookie would have in his first season in black and white. After playing 18 games in three seasons with the Lions, the 21-year-old played every game and was a consistent, goalkicking run-with player.
Get excited
Darcy Moore There is always hype around the son of a gun, and in this case, it's entirely justified. Due largely to injury, we had to wait until round 14 to get our first glimpse of Moore, but in just his second game he bagged a game-high five goals in a loss to the Western Bulldogs, and as a forward/ruckman he continued to display smarts and supreme athleticism reminiscent of his father, dual Brownlow medallist Peter Moore.
Disappointment
Levi Greenwood Not through any fault of his own, though. It was extremely disappointing for the Pies that the former Kangaroo missed the bulk of the season with a broken ankle, and his value was best exemplified by his superb run-with efforts on Richmond captain Trent Cotchin and Geelong skipper Joel Selwood in rounds 21 and 22, nullifying both while winning plenty of the ball himself and even kicking goals. Takes inside heat off Pendlebury, Swan and co.
Best win: 17-point win over North Melbourne, round nine, MCG
The Pies recorded their third-biggest second half comeback, coming from 39 points down to win by 17 points. They piled on 10 successive goals and, after being headed again when they conceded four successive majors, kicked the last three goals.
Low point
If a 37-point loss to battling Melbourne in round 18 wasn't rock-bottom, then a 91-point hiding from Richmond three weeks later certainly was. Surrendered 9.0 to nothing in a horror 18-minute patch in the last quarter.
The big questions
Free Fallin' – Tom Petty
Who's done?
A viable second key forward and a key defender who can take the game on. The not-so-simple solution would be to clone swingman Reid. In attack, Jesse White hasn't grabbed his opportunity but it seems only a matter of time before Moore makes the role his own while providing handy ruck support. At the other end, Brown and Jack Frost are solid, percentage players but ideally they wouldn't play together because neither is a natural playmaker. Reid needs to go back.
Premiership clock
The Pies are young but any side that boasts been-there-done-that types like Pendlebury, Swan, Travis Cloke and Steele Sidebottom can never be discounted. If their classy kids make big gains simultaneously, they might just prise open the premiership window.
Early call
Looks can be deceiving. The Pies could be anything next year. With a bit more composure and luck, they might well have been anything this year. Another pre-season into this young, talented list could have it primed for a top-eight tilt.
What worked
- The Pies showed they can challenge the AFL's best teams and probably should have beaten Hawthorn (at the MCG), Fremantle (Domain Stadium) and the Sydney Swans (SCG), but went down by a combined tally of just 28 points.
- Although it dropped off considerably late in the season, Collingwood's defensive pressure and general team defence continued to be a cornerstone of its game. Finished second in the AFL in tackles, averaging 71.9 a game (just 0.1, or four tackles overall, behind Port Adelaide).
- Debutants Darcy Moore, Jordan De Goey, Matt Scharenberg, Jonathon Marsh and Brayden Maynard provided plenty of cause for optimism, as did the development of ex-Lion Jack Crisp, ruckman Brodie Grundy and former rookies Marley Williams and Adam Oxley.
- After sitting fourth with an 8-3 record – in the identical position they occupied last year – the Pies won just two of their next 11 games to miss the finals for the second year running.
- Inaccuracy and an inability to gain satisfactory reward for their quality field play cost the Pies dearly in close games, most glaringly in contests with last year's grand finalists, Hawthorn and the Sydney Swans, when they tallied 22.35 to their opponents' 28.20.
- Doping suspensions to big man Lachlan Keeffe and midfielder Josh Thomas robbed the Pies of two players who, at the very least, would have provided welcome relief at various stages.
We were pretty much spot on, predicting an 11th placing for the Pies as they went through a rebuilding phase.
Overall rating
5.5/10. After 14 rounds – following narrow losses to Hawthorn and Freo – the Pies peaked at about 8.5/10, given the consensus view that they wouldn't figure in the finals. But almost from that moment, they went into freefall.
The coach
When you coach Collingwood, and your name is Nathan Buckley, external pressure is everywhere. So don't expect Buckley to be daunted by the fact that his contract expires at the end of next season. Most gave the Pies Buckley's hope of making the finals this year, so to have them around the top four for two-thirds of the season was some effort. However, late-season losses have many questioning his abilities.
Most Valuable Player
A tie between Scott Pendlebury and Dane Swan Hard to split the prolific Pies pair, with skipper Pendlebury producing another high-quality season, despite battling a calf issue and spending more time forward, and Swan overcoming an injury-hampered 2014 to perform superbly. They amassed remarkably similar stats, with Pendlebury perhaps more consistent and Swan enjoying more standout games. Fellow midfielder Taylor Adams deserves an honourable mention.
Surprise packet
Jack Crisp When superstar midfielder Dayne Beams was traded to the Brisbane Lions in exchange for picks No.5 and 25 and Crisp, not even the Pies could have envisaged the impact the former rookie would have in his first season in black and white. After playing 18 games in three seasons with the Lions, the 21-year-old played every game and was a consistent, goalkicking run-with player.
Get excited
Darcy Moore There is always hype around the son of a gun, and in this case, it's entirely justified. Due largely to injury, we had to wait until round 14 to get our first glimpse of Moore, but in just his second game he bagged a game-high five goals in a loss to the Western Bulldogs, and as a forward/ruckman he continued to display smarts and supreme athleticism reminiscent of his father, dual Brownlow medallist Peter Moore.
Disappointment
Levi Greenwood Not through any fault of his own, though. It was extremely disappointing for the Pies that the former Kangaroo missed the bulk of the season with a broken ankle, and his value was best exemplified by his superb run-with efforts on Richmond captain Trent Cotchin and Geelong skipper Joel Selwood in rounds 21 and 22, nullifying both while winning plenty of the ball himself and even kicking goals. Takes inside heat off Pendlebury, Swan and co.
Best win: 17-point win over North Melbourne, round nine, MCG
The Pies recorded their third-biggest second half comeback, coming from 39 points down to win by 17 points. They piled on 10 successive goals and, after being headed again when they conceded four successive majors, kicked the last three goals.
Low point
If a 37-point loss to battling Melbourne in round 18 wasn't rock-bottom, then a 91-point hiding from Richmond three weeks later certainly was. Surrendered 9.0 to nothing in a horror 18-minute patch in the last quarter.
The big questions
- Will they secure a prized midfielder – or perhaps two – in the trade period?
The Pies are apparently keen on Adelaide superstar Patrick Dangerfield, the Giants' Adam Treloar and the Lions' James Aish. One would be a great result, two amazing, and all three would be the greatest coup of all time. - Should Ben Reid play forward or back?
Presuming he remains free of soft-tissue problems, the Pies have the luxury of playing him at either end. He's a good forward but a better defender and adds much-needed class to the back six. - Can they fill their leadership void?
After losing more than 3000 games of experience and much leadership over the past three years, the Pies are crying out for young leaders to emerge. Pendlebury and the likes of Nathan Brown and Steele Sidebottom desperately need help.
Free Fallin' – Tom Petty
Who's done?
- Retirements: At 31, Dane Swan is easily the oldest player on the list but looks like he could play on for at least another couple of seasons. However, others might be forced into retirement if delisted and little interest is shown by rival clubs.
- Delistings: The off-contract quartet of Clinton Young, Sam Dwyer, Patrick Karnezis, Tony Armstrong appears certain to be axed, given Young (29) has endured frustration with injury and form, Dwyer (29) is usually overlooked for younger midfield options, Karnezis didn't play at AFL level after round seven despite strong VFL form, and Armstrong made just one appearance this year.
- Trades/free agents: Anzac medallist Paul Seedsman's name has been mentioned as part of a possible trade deal that could land Brisbane Lions youngster James Aish. If the Pies snare Aish and/or Giants midfielder Adam Treloar, Ben Kennedy could decide to seek more opportunities elsewhere, despite being contracted to the end of next year. Top draft pick Matt Scharenberg could ask to be traded back to his native South Australia.
A viable second key forward and a key defender who can take the game on. The not-so-simple solution would be to clone swingman Reid. In attack, Jesse White hasn't grabbed his opportunity but it seems only a matter of time before Moore makes the role his own while providing handy ruck support. At the other end, Brown and Jack Frost are solid, percentage players but ideally they wouldn't play together because neither is a natural playmaker. Reid needs to go back.
Premiership clock
The Pies are young but any side that boasts been-there-done-that types like Pendlebury, Swan, Travis Cloke and Steele Sidebottom can never be discounted. If their classy kids make big gains simultaneously, they might just prise open the premiership window.
Early call
Looks can be deceiving. The Pies could be anything next year. With a bit more composure and luck, they might well have been anything this year. Another pre-season into this young, talented list could have it primed for a top-eight tilt.
Monday, September 07, 2015
2015 LADDER: ROUND 23
Pos Position C Change from last round P Played W Won L Lost D Drawn F Points for
A Points against % Percentage Form Past five results Next Next opponent Pts Points |
Round 23: Essendon 95 Collingwood 92
COLLINGWOOD 4.2.26 8.3.51 12.5.77 14.8.92
ESSENDON 3.2.20 9.5.59 11.7.73 14.11.95
SCORERS - Collingwood: Fasolo (2.1), Blair (2.0), Kennedy (2.0), White (2.0), Moore (1.1), Adams (1.0), Crisp (1.0), Elliott (1.0), Greenwood (1.0), Reid (1.0), Pendlebury (0.2), Scharenberg (0.1), Sidebottom (0.1)
BEST - Collingwood: Adams, Sidebottom, White, Fasolo, Marsh, Reid
INJURIES - Collingwood: Brown (cut head)
SUBSTITUTES - Collingwood: Alan Toovey replaced Brodie Grundy in the third quarter
REPORTS: Nil
OFFICIAL CROWD: 42,270 at the MCG
1.Hocking the hero With the Bombers pressing in the tense final stages of the game, it was Heath Hocking to deliver the killer blow that sealed Essendon's seventh victory of the season. After Orazio Fantasia took the game on through the middle of the ground, the ball was swung down to an unopposed Hocking who marked the ball inside 50. He took the bit between the teeth and drilled the ball from 40m to nail the match-clinching goal. He then backed it up and won the all-important clearance to allow the Bombers to milk the clock in the final stages of the match. It capped a terrific game for the negating midfielder (23 touches), who ended the season on a high after a frustrating year due to injury. 2. Bombs away? Was the final game of the year against the Pies also Jake Carlisle's final game at Essendon? The out-of-contract utility has garnered plenty of interest from opposition clubs, with North Melbourne, Carlton and the Western Bulldogs reportedly leading the pack for his signature. After spending much of the year as a forward, Carlisle seems to have enjoyed his shift to the backline in recent weeks. The 23-year-old looked assured across half-back, where he can see the play developing in front of him. Carlisle will be a big loss if he decides to test the market in this year's trade period. 3. Adams finishes the season full of running Much has been made of the changing face of Collingwood's midfield group in 2015, with Levi Greenwood and Jack Crisp among those to step up and assist Scott Pendlebury and Steele Sidebottom. But it has been the continual development, highlighted by an end-of-season purple patch, of Taylor Adams that has been most impressive. After notching 36 disposals in a best afield performance against Geelong last week, Adams backed it up against Essendon with 33 touches and seven clearances. In his second season at the Magpies, Adams has become one of the elite inside midfielders in the competition. |
4.Fasolo's radar off-target Alex Fasolo did not have any issues finding the football – in fact he was dangerous up forward for much of the game. But his ability to finish in front of goal, which was once a key asset, appears to have deserted him. Criticised for missing a couple of clutch goals in the loss to Hawthorn earlier in the season, Fasolo was again inaccurate against the Bombers. The small forward kicked 2.1 but sprayed a number of shots wide of the mark as he operated at 40 per cent goal accuracy. It will be something he and the Magpies will be hoping to clean up in the off-season. 5.Stanton fires as he seeks new contract Bombers veteran Brent Stanton is in discussion with the club about a new contract and his form against Collingwood was certainly a huge boost in that pursuit. Stanton worked overtime to provide an option forward of the ball, booting three goals in the second quarter alone. Renowned for his aerobic capacity since making his debut in 2004, the 29-year-old collected 30 disposals at 73.3 per cent efficiency. A favourite of former coach James Hird, Stanton proved he is far from a spent force with a superb game against the Magpies. .... it has been the continual development, highlighted by an end-of-season purple patch, of Taylor Adams that has been most impressive. After notching 36 disposals in a best afield performance against Geelong last week, Adams backed it up against Essendon with 33 touches and seven clearances. In his second season at the Magpies, Adams has become one of the elite inside midfielders in the competition. |
THE MEDIA | |
Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley says while the Magpies could have taken "a bigger step" in 2015, he's been able to learn which players are capable of standing up on the AFL stage throughout their up and down season. The Pies lost their seventh contest by three goals or less on Sunday when they went down to Essendon by three points at the MCG. It was an inexperienced Collingwood side, with Alan Toovey's status as the substitute meaning the starting 21 was the youngest line-up the Pies have produced this year. Buckley said while it was disappointing they were unable to close out so many tight contests, overall they'd found "more pieces of the puzzle" when looking ahead to the future. "I think in the end '15 was always a step towards where we wanted to get to, it was always going to be – how big a step that was, was going to be our challenge," Buckley said. "We could have taken a bigger step, there's no doubt, but I think we've learned about the players who can and who can't, about our capacity and the fact we've competed against the best sides but we just haven't been able to get over the top of them. "Where we settle in the ladder for 2015 will be an accurate reflection, and it's a pretty competitive environment. "On any given day, you need to be at your best to win them and we've shown our best is good enough to win them and we need to be able to produce it consistently, and that's going to be the challenge through the next couple of season." Buckley believes the abolishment of the sub rule and reduction of interchange cap to 90 rotations a game will have a "significant impact" on personnel and strategy employed for games. The Pies will look at how best to attack those changes over the off-season, while looking to stock up on players who can help connect their offence and defence, with their "grunt" in good shape. They've been linked heavily to Adam Treloar and James Aish, with Buckley expecting the club to be aggressive in securing such talent to increase their depth. "The large part of our improvement is going to come from within the playing list," he said. "We've invested heavily in youth in the last two or three drafts but what the last 12 months has given us is a greater understanding of our depths in certain areas, and maybe some areas we need to be stronger. "We'll keep chasing players we think are going to make us better in the long term and fit the profile we're looking at, which is to be competitive from next year for the next five, six. "Most of our recruiting drives will be around that." First though, they need to work on securing the signatures of young guns Matthew Scharenberg and Nathan Freeman, who are coming out of their initial two-year draftee contracts. Buckley said the only concern was that "they haven't signed yet" but felt the signs were positive." All indications are really strong they're keen to remain at the club," he said."It's just a matter of coming to the right number." ESSENDON have finished their AFL year to forget on a high, downing traditional rivals Collingwood by three points in barnstorming finish to the home and away season. Heath Hocking kicked the last two goals of the match to push the Bombers to a 14.11 (95) to 14.8 (92) victory at the MCG. The thrilling finish handed caretaker coach Matthew Egan a winning finish to his tenure, snapping a seven-game losing streak and promising better things to come for the Bombers. After spending much of the second half behind, Hocking put the Bombers ahead with less than 90 seconds to play. There was an end-of-school feel to the match with just 40,270 in attendance - the lowest crowd to this fixture since it was last played at Windy Hill in 1988. With neither playing finals in 2015, it was being played for skittles rather than sheep stations. But in the last quarter it didn’t feel that way, with the Bombers holding on to condemn their rivals to a 10-12 season record. The Magpies were 10 points ahead when Alex Fasolo found an early major, and looked home when he had another shot at goal. But the West Australian blazed his shot out on the full and the Bombers surged back into the contest. Set shot majors from Cale Hooker and Hocking either side of Darcy Moore’s reply set up the show-stopping finish. Shaun Edwards and Joe Daniher, who was concussed earlier in the match, missed chances to steal back the lead in the frenetic circumstances. Up stepped Hocking, who found space in the pocket and kicked truly to ensure that, for at least one day in September, the Bombers were winners. KEY STATS
As Taylor Adams reflects on his second year in black and white, he must finally feel like a vital member of Collingwood's midfield.
After having to cement his place in the middle in 2014, this year Adams has become one of the Magpies most prolific ball winners. He capped off a fine season with a team-high 33 disposals against the Bombers, including 13 contested possessions and seven clearances. It marks the sixth time this season Adams has totalled 30 possessions or more. Only club stalwarts Scott Pendlebury and Dane Swan done so more times. Sunday's three-point loss to Essendon also held statistical value for midfielder Ben Kennedy. Having played just four AFL games this season, Kennedy's 15 disposals was his highest tally of the year. He also kicked his first two goals of 2015 and equalled the second highest goalkicking tally of his career. As the most-subbed player in Collingwood history, Kennedy will no doubt be happy to see the back of the substitutes rule at the end of this season. However after Sunday's form, the fact that he will no longer be forced to wear the green vest may not be the only reason he may face extended going forward. "I think in the end '15 was always a step towards where we wanted to get to, it was always going to be – how big a step that was, was going to be our challenge. Nathan Buckley |
AFTER a trying season, Essendon fans finally have reason to smile with the Bombers stealing a thrilling three-point victory from Collingwood at the MCG on Sunday afternoon. As the sun set on the 2015 home and away season, a healthy crowd of 40,270 watched as Heath Hocking sealed the Bombers' first win since round 15 - 14.11 (95) to 14.8 (92) Hocking kicked a goal with less than a minute-and-a-half on the clock to give the Dons the match-winning lead, before the ball was pushed to the Pies' attacking end as the siren approached. But a free kick was awarded to Cale Hooker in a marking contest as the Pies went inside 50 with 23 seconds left, which saw the ball end up on the city side wing as the siren rang. It was welcome relief for the Bombers, who hadn't tasted victory under interim coach Matt Egan and have endured a rough season dogged by the on-going ASADA and WADA situation, and the resignation of coach James Hird. Their sixth win for the season was led by Brent Stanton, who collected 30 disposals and kicked three goals, all of which came in the second quarter. Dyson Heppell was also important for the Bombers with 28 and eight clearances, while promoted rookie Shaun McKernan was excellent in the ruck and around the ground. Hocking was influential with three goals, none more important than his second and third – the last two of the game - that stole the win after the Pies led for much of the second half. After the first quarter went goal for goal, the Bombers' first move came early in the second when they kicked three unanswered majors. Stanton put together a terrific term, equalling his career-best goal haul with three; the third of which was set up by Joe Daniher after a remarkable comeback from a first-term head knock in the opening minute. Daniher was on the ground for a few minutes after crashing into both Ben Reid and Taylor Adams, but returned to the field for the second term after serving 20 minutes as the concussion substitute. While Stanton threatened to blow the lacklustre Pies away, Ben Kennedy did well up the other end to boot two goals for the term and keep his team in it. Still, a lack of pressure and the alarming statistic of just 17 tackles to half-time showed the Pies were a long way off the team that surprised Geelong last round. Four Magpie goals in a row in the third quarter turned a 14-point deficit after Hocking nailed the term's opener into a nine-point lead. Adams was influential in the quarter with a hand in the first two goals as the Pies looked to have regained control over the contest. He was their best player with 33 disposals and seven clearances, while Steele Sidebottom was also prolific through the midfield. But they had no answers as the Bombers ground out the win to give themselves something to celebrate as they look towards the pre-season. The best thing about this match might be what it comes to mean, not what actually happened in it. There were plenty of goals, from a lot of open play. There weren't all that many tackles laid, by either side. This wasn't a match that would have caused anyone watching to drool at the skill level. There was nothing much at the end of Collingwood v Essendon at the MCG in round 23, 2015, though it was played with spirit and finished in a dramatic way. And it might not be without meaning forever. There can be a lag in what we see a team doing, and what we will see a side go on to do, with the Western Bulldogs perhaps this year's best example of that. Yes, they have a new coach and have blooded more kids than anyone this year. But Jake Stringer, Marcus Bontempelli and most of the players making them win more games than they lose now were there last year too. So to Essendon and Collingwood, who kept Sunday's game close enough for an entertaining, busy finish, Heath Hocking's third goal putting the Bombers three points in front with just under 90 seconds to go. He and his teammates were able to end a horrible season smiling, with their first win in a while. The Bombers may be a touch further back than Collingwood when it comes to piecing their next side together. For multiple reasons, this year did not turn out to be anything like they believed it would, and were planning for. But Jayden Laverde, Shaun Edwards and Kyle Langford have shown some positive glimpses since being given their chances in recent weeks. Zac Merrett will be around a long time. Irish rookie Conor McKenna plays like he wants to get better, quickly. Orazio Fantasia had his most encouraging game, his 27 possessions including 15 handball receives. He has what his team needs: run. Regardless of whether Jake Carlisle stays or goes, the Bombers have something every new coach would like to start building their team around: a spine that includes Cale Hooker, Michael Hurley and Joe Daniher. Collingwood's season didn't last as long as they wanted, either. But again, Darcy Moore looked exciting, athletic and like a very large part of Collingwood's future. Jordan De Goey was tough. Matthew Scharenberg got a fourth game under his belt and Jonathon Marsh did some more good things in defence. Brodie Grundy is only 21; Jamie Elliott, who spent some time up on a wing, is just 23. If the Pies are able to add Adam Treloar and James Aish to a group of young midfielders that includes Jack Crisp, Taylor Adams, Brayden Maynard and the unseen Nathan Freeman, they will be on their way. Nathan Buckley told his players after the game that it wouldn't simply happen from here, that they have learnt in recent weeks how hard it is to keep backing up every week, and how much it needs to be done. But he started seeing signs, even earlier than that, of what his team could become. "I think this season has shown us that. It mirrors last year in some shape or form, until you delve a little bit deeper and have a look at the analysis of it," Buckley said. "That is that we've been even younger again and we've found a few more pieces of the puzzle that are going to help us going forward. "I think we had low 40 games of experience on average across our side so it's a young side. Essendon were young as well but I think we were younger. "I think in the end 2015 was always a step towards where we want to get to. It was always going to be. How big a step that was was going to be our challenge. "We could have taken a bigger step, no doubt. But I think we've learned about the players - who can and who can't. "We've learnt about our capacity and we've competed against the best sides but we just haven't been able to get over the top of them. "Where we settle in the ladder for season 2015 will be an accurate reflection." In his few weeks in charge, Essendon's interim coach Matthew Egan had told his players that their enjoyment should not be based on whether they won or lost, but whether they played the way they knew they could and did the things they set out to do. But even he found it hard not to enjoy seeing them get to sing the song after such a long season and a seven-week wait for a win. "It's been a tough year for them. Just seeing them at the end, it was great reward for such a tough year," he said. "I think some of our young players really stood up. Jayden Laverde was strong again and He looks like a real man I reckon. He looks like a 25 year old, and he's 18 or 19. "Kyle Langford showed signs. Conor McKenna; I think he had 18 possessions, and he's been playing the game for 10 months. Joe Daniher comes back on and contributes. "There's some positive signs for the club. Those sort of wins just give a little bit of belief. "There's a lot of guys now that we think can play AFL. They just need some consistency to get more games into them, really." |
Thursday, September 03, 2015
Round 23: The Team
Round 23
Collingwood v EssendonMCG Fox Footy (504) 3:20pm Weather: Min 6 Max 17 Chance of rain 80%: 1-5mm Wind: N 28kph Betting: Collingwood $1.30 Essendon $3.50 |
HB: Brayden Maynard, Ben Reid, Adam Oxley
C: Jack Crisp, Taylor Adams, Steele Sidebottom
HF: Travis Varcoe, Darcy Moore, Jordan De Goey
F: Alex Fasolo, Jesse White, Jamie Elliott
Foll: Brodie Grundy, Levi Greenwood, Scott Pendlebury
Int: Ben Kennedy, Matthew Scharenberg, Alan Toovey, Jarryd Blair
Emg: Jarrod Witts, Matthew Goodyear, Paul Seedsman
IN: Ben Kennedy, Adam Oxley, Alan Toovey
OUT: Ben Sinclair (hand), Dane Swan (knee), Marley Williams (hamstring)
NEW: Matthew Goodyear (19, Calder U18)
Fast Fact
The last time Collingwood met Essendon in the final round of the home and away season was in 2012. On that occasion, the Magpies were victorious by 32 points, with Dane Swan earning the three Brownlow Medal votes.
Six inclusions and a debutant. Collingwood’s match committee obviously isn’t going to let 2015 slip away quietly. The men charged with selecting the team have turned to… Experience: In the form of Alan Toovey. Promise: In the guise of Ben Kennedy, Adam Oxley, Paul Seedsman, Jarrod Witts and Paul Seedsman. And youth: As evidenced by the selection of the yet-untried Matthew Goodyear. Goodyear, Kennedy, Seedsman, Toovey and Witts are among an extended seven-man interchange bench that will be trimmed to four at 5pm on Friday. The six additions replace the injured Ben Sinclair (hand), Dane Swan (knee) and Marley Williams (hamstring). Who is Matthew Goodyear? Athleticism is Goodyear’s strong suit, as he has a great turn of foot and elite endurance. The former Calder Cannon averaged 23 disposals in 15 appearances at TAC Cup level last season. Rarely fazed by the occasion, he is a great decision-maker. In sixteen games in the VFL this season, Goodyear has averaged 13.9 disposals and 3.8 tackles while splitting his time between the wing and half back. He enters this weekend’s games in good touch, having backed up a season-high 25 disposals against Richmond with a further 24 against Port Melbourne last Saturday. |
Preview Round 23: Collingwood v Essendon
Collingwood News - David Natoli
Collingwood will face Essendon in a battle for pride this Sunday at the MCG. Neither side remains in finals contention, and therefore this week’s article takes a reflective approach on the seasons of these two sides.
When the Collingwood brains trust sits down post-season to analyse the 2015 season, they will undoubtedly compare this year to a 2014 campaign which followed a similar pattern. However, I think this season should be analysed individually as there are very different reasons why Collingwood will miss the finals this time around. In 2014, I thought injuries and a lack of depth were the main contributing factors. However in 2015, the Collingwood side significantly improved (which is evident by the much higher percentage), but just lacked composure at key moments of the season. After a month of heart-breaking losses between rounds 13-17, eventually the confidence was sapped, and slowly panic begun to creep in as the Magpies continued to slide down the ladder. Despite the fact that Collingwood had performed so admirably against the best sides in the competition, you could just sense the frustration growing from consecutive ‘honourable losses’.
The young Magpies will have learnt a lot from this season, and will continue to improve. The win against Geelong last week showed how talented this side is, and it took a complete release of the pressure to unlock this sort of performance. All five players who debuted for Collingwood this season played valuable roles, and this highlights the excitement which is building amongst the side for what lies ahead.
Essendon on the other hand will look at 2015 as a season to forget. Whilst I do not plan on delving into the WADA situation, there is no doubt the Bombers’ season fell off the rails at the same time that WADA announced its appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport. It was finally the tipping point for a group of players which has had to deal with so much mentally and physically for so long. Injuries to key players compounded the problem, and eventually the growing pressure finally claimed the coach as well.
Whilst I believe a lot of Essendon’s woes in 2015 were mental, we have also seen a number of deficiencies exploited as well. The lack of a key ruckman, midfield pace and a properly balanced forward line will be areas the Bombers will need to address if this side is to bounce back in 2016. The draft penalties which Essendon has faced in the last two years means that there is also a lack of quality young depth to call upon. It has been such a rapid fall, considering this was a side in round two which beat the reigning premier Hawthorn and one many thought would be successful in 2015.
These ‘dead rubber’ games at the end of the season have a habit of turning into very entertaining spectacles, as both coaches release the shackles and allow the match to open up. Both these clubs have proud histories and will be keen to finish the season on a positive note. The Bombers will look at this as an opportunity to put a full stop on 2015 and look forward, whilst Collingwood will use this game as a chance to build confidence ahead of the pre-season and pump more game time into the young players.
Recent History
These sides last met in round four on ANZAC Day, where it was the Magpies who were eventually comfortable 20-point winners in a very low scoring affair. It was a breakout game for Paul Seedsman who won the ANZAC medal with 31 possessions and a lovely long goal. Scott Pendlebury and Taylor Adams led the way through the midfield with 30 and 29 disposals respectively. For the Bombers, Dyson Heppell was the standout with 33 disposals, whilst Brent Stanton was also very damaging with 30 disposals and 2 goals.
At the Selection Table
It will be an interesting week for both sides at the selection table considering both have VFL teams playing elimination finals. Whilst priority should always be to the AFL side, neither coach will want to deplete the VFL affiliate and deprive it of an opportunity to go deep into the finals.
At Collingwood, Nathan Buckley will need to make at least two forced changes this week with Dane Swan and Ben Sinclairboth sustaining injuries last week against Geelong. Alan Toovey is a logical replacement for Sinclair after he was rested last week while Adam Oxley was declared best on ground last week in the VFL and looks set to return. Travis Cloke looks unlikely to return from his hamstring complaint, which means Jesse White will most likely get another opportunity at AFL level. The usual suspects in Ben Kennedy, Sam Dwyer, Patrick Karnezis, Clinton Young, Paul Seedsman and Jarrod Witts also continue to impress at VFL level but may be left untouched as the VFL Magpies look to extend their finals campaign.
Essendon has two forced changes this week with Courtney Dempsey suspended for his tackle on Brett Deledio, while Paul Chapman played his final game last week. All focus will be on Dustin Fletcher as he attempts to prove his fitness so he can play a farewell match. If he is unable take the field, he will likely retire on 400 AFL games. Fletcher is far from 100 per cent fit, however the Bombers will give him every opportunity to pull on the jumper one last time. At VFL level, Kyle Langford has impressed, as has Ariel Steinberg and Jason Ashby.
Focus on Collingwood
There are a lot of areas for Collingwood to work on over the off-season, however there is a lot of improvement which should be highlighted. Collingwood is the number one contested football side in the competition, and is also highly rated in tackling statistics as well. In the first half of the year, Collingwood was also the best side at marking inside 50, and preventing opposition marks inside 50. These are two areas which dropped off in the second half of the year and should be highlighted as Nathan Buckley looks to improve further next year.
It was interesting last week to see Buckley restructure his midfield. Pendlebury played a defensive role and floated off the back of the contest, whilst Jordan De Goey, Adams and Jack Crisp took over the reins and performed strongly. Buckley will continue to mix things up this round as he continues to throw new experiences to his younger players.
Collingwood played with complete freedom last week and got back to playing the sort of football which had it placed in the top four leading into the bye. The tackling pressure was enormous, the ball movement slick, the defenders were willing to work for each other, and the forward line made the most of its opportunities and took a lot of marks inside 50. Following the terrible loss to Richmond the week prior, it was an indication to me of this team’s pride and heart.
Player Focus
Jack Crisp – Crisp played a career-high best game statistically last week. After spending the last few games playing a more outside role, the former Brisbane Lion was thrust back into the midfield where he picked up 31 disposals, seven tackles and nine inside 50’s. To think that Crisp was originally thought of as just the steak knives as part of the Dayne Beams deal shows how far he has come this year. This is highlighted by the fact he has jumped from 626th in the Official AFL player ratings to 184. If he maintains this form, his rise will only continue. He is one of the real success stories of 2015 for the Magpies.
Travis Varcoe – Varcoe is another recruit who has shone at his new home. Provided ex-Cat plays this week, he will be one of only four Magpies who have played every game this season. He has never been a huge accumulator of the ball, but has still averaged a respectable 17 disposals a game to go with 10 goals. Importantly though, his physical pressure has gone to a new level, and his tackling has been terrific. He has been played in a number of positions, whether it be as a forward, wingmen or attacking defender. Undoubtedly it has been a career-best season for Varcoe, and we all look forward to what he can produce in the years to come.
Darcy Moore – He remains unlucky not to have received a Rising Star nomination, but the good news for Moore is that he will remain eligible in 2016. Whilst we have all seen glimpses of brilliance as a forward (none more so than his five goal effort against Western Bulldogs), what has surprised me has been his ability as a ruckman. His athleticism makes him a real force in the centre bounces in particular, and once he builds his body up he will also be quite a strong stoppage ruckman as well. It adds a new dimension to the Collingwood side if Moore can become the forward/ruck that it has been screaming out for. What impresses me most about Moore is his enthusiasm. He cheers every goal, whether it be he or a team-mate that kicks it.
Focus on Essendon
It has been a completely different look Bombers in the second half of this season as the club has looked to blood as many new players as possible. It has resulted in some massive losses, but Essendon has been more competitive in recent weeks, and has challenged the Gold Coast and Richmond.
However, the biggest problem for Essendon all season has been scoring. It is averaging only 70 points a game, and just simply has run out of ideas. Too much reliance has been placed on young Joe Daniher to hold up the forward line, and whilst he has performed admirably, he just isn’t ready for this heavy burden yet. It has meant players like Jake Carlisle and Cale Hookerhave had to play as makeshift forwards, which has only depleted the backline. The absence of Jobe Watson at such a difficult time of the year has also hurt.
There have been some positives though. A few youngsters have emerged, such as Jayden Laverdewho many considered a real bargain selection at last year’s draft. Nick O’Brien has also been solid, whilst Shaun McKernan has shown a lot of heart.
Player Focus
Cale Hooker – One man who can hold his head up high has been Cale Hooker. At one point this year, Hooker was the favourite to be named the All-Australian centre half back. However, he has had to sacrifice his role to help fill the void up forward. At the other end of the ground his nature of a fierce competitor and ability to take a strong contested mark has been vital. He kicked three goals last week, which takes his season tally to 19. Preferably, the Bombers will love Hooker to slot back into defence, but until they can find other options he will likely continue to plug the hole up forward.
Shaun McKernan – After being delisted by Adelaide, McKernan was thrown a lifeline by Essendon as a rookie. It took a while for him to get his opportunity due to the fact he needed a spot to open up on the senior list first. When it finally did, he was thrown into the ruck against the monsters of the competition. At 196cm, he is very undersized for this role, but he has competed valiantly. He has used his athleticism to become an attacking option around the ground, which has seen him average 17 disposals a game. He is also averaging a respectable 22 hitouts. Whilst he has struggled to compete against the best ruckmen in the competition, he has shown real heart and has cemented a spot in this Essendon side.
Dyson Heppell – Heppell has had to lead the club in the absence of Jobe Watson, and he has done a fine job. Statistically, Heppell is well down on last year’s averages, and at times has looked a bit worn-out. He lacks pace, but he has a huge heart and is definitely a captain in waiting. He always plays well against Collingwood, but will likely get the Levi Greenwood tag (Greenwood has taken the scalps of Cotchin and Selwood in the last two weeks).
The Final Word
As we embark on the final round of the AFL home and away season, I would like to take this opportunity to thank all those who have read my articles throughout the year, and also the Collingwood Football Club for providing me with the platform to share my thoughts with the Magpie Army.
This is the final game of the AFL Premiership Season. While it’s a dead-rubber, it also has the makings of quite an open and free-flowing affair, which could lead to some very entertaining footy. Supporters of both sides will be disappointed with how the season has turned out, but it is an opportunity to go to a game without nerves and just enjoy the afternoon. Despite last week’s game against Geelong counting for nothing, it was good to just to sit down, watch the next generation on display, and see my club play with pride. I would prefer to be playing finals of course, but it was a timely reminder of why we love this game and why we support our club. I’m looking forward to a similar afternoon this Sunday.
Also remember to support the respective VFL sides this week in the elimination finals. With the AFL sides finishing up, let’s hope that both Essendon and Collingwood can still have a presence at VFL level.
Whilst Essendon have been better over the last fortnight, Collingwood should be far too good, especially through the midfield.
Collingwood by 35 points.
Round 23
Collingwood v EssendonMCG Fox Footy (504) 3:20pm Weather: Min 6 Max 17 Chance of rain 80%: 1-5mm Wind: N 28kph Betting: Collingwood $1.30 Essendon $3.50 |
When the Collingwood brains trust sits down post-season to analyse the 2015 season, they will undoubtedly compare this year to a 2014 campaign which followed a similar pattern. However, I think this season should be analysed individually as there are very different reasons why Collingwood will miss the finals this time around. In 2014, I thought injuries and a lack of depth were the main contributing factors. However in 2015, the Collingwood side significantly improved (which is evident by the much higher percentage), but just lacked composure at key moments of the season. After a month of heart-breaking losses between rounds 13-17, eventually the confidence was sapped, and slowly panic begun to creep in as the Magpies continued to slide down the ladder. Despite the fact that Collingwood had performed so admirably against the best sides in the competition, you could just sense the frustration growing from consecutive ‘honourable losses’.
The young Magpies will have learnt a lot from this season, and will continue to improve. The win against Geelong last week showed how talented this side is, and it took a complete release of the pressure to unlock this sort of performance. All five players who debuted for Collingwood this season played valuable roles, and this highlights the excitement which is building amongst the side for what lies ahead.
Essendon on the other hand will look at 2015 as a season to forget. Whilst I do not plan on delving into the WADA situation, there is no doubt the Bombers’ season fell off the rails at the same time that WADA announced its appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport. It was finally the tipping point for a group of players which has had to deal with so much mentally and physically for so long. Injuries to key players compounded the problem, and eventually the growing pressure finally claimed the coach as well.
Whilst I believe a lot of Essendon’s woes in 2015 were mental, we have also seen a number of deficiencies exploited as well. The lack of a key ruckman, midfield pace and a properly balanced forward line will be areas the Bombers will need to address if this side is to bounce back in 2016. The draft penalties which Essendon has faced in the last two years means that there is also a lack of quality young depth to call upon. It has been such a rapid fall, considering this was a side in round two which beat the reigning premier Hawthorn and one many thought would be successful in 2015.
These ‘dead rubber’ games at the end of the season have a habit of turning into very entertaining spectacles, as both coaches release the shackles and allow the match to open up. Both these clubs have proud histories and will be keen to finish the season on a positive note. The Bombers will look at this as an opportunity to put a full stop on 2015 and look forward, whilst Collingwood will use this game as a chance to build confidence ahead of the pre-season and pump more game time into the young players.
Recent History
These sides last met in round four on ANZAC Day, where it was the Magpies who were eventually comfortable 20-point winners in a very low scoring affair. It was a breakout game for Paul Seedsman who won the ANZAC medal with 31 possessions and a lovely long goal. Scott Pendlebury and Taylor Adams led the way through the midfield with 30 and 29 disposals respectively. For the Bombers, Dyson Heppell was the standout with 33 disposals, whilst Brent Stanton was also very damaging with 30 disposals and 2 goals.
At the Selection Table
It will be an interesting week for both sides at the selection table considering both have VFL teams playing elimination finals. Whilst priority should always be to the AFL side, neither coach will want to deplete the VFL affiliate and deprive it of an opportunity to go deep into the finals.
At Collingwood, Nathan Buckley will need to make at least two forced changes this week with Dane Swan and Ben Sinclairboth sustaining injuries last week against Geelong. Alan Toovey is a logical replacement for Sinclair after he was rested last week while Adam Oxley was declared best on ground last week in the VFL and looks set to return. Travis Cloke looks unlikely to return from his hamstring complaint, which means Jesse White will most likely get another opportunity at AFL level. The usual suspects in Ben Kennedy, Sam Dwyer, Patrick Karnezis, Clinton Young, Paul Seedsman and Jarrod Witts also continue to impress at VFL level but may be left untouched as the VFL Magpies look to extend their finals campaign.
Essendon has two forced changes this week with Courtney Dempsey suspended for his tackle on Brett Deledio, while Paul Chapman played his final game last week. All focus will be on Dustin Fletcher as he attempts to prove his fitness so he can play a farewell match. If he is unable take the field, he will likely retire on 400 AFL games. Fletcher is far from 100 per cent fit, however the Bombers will give him every opportunity to pull on the jumper one last time. At VFL level, Kyle Langford has impressed, as has Ariel Steinberg and Jason Ashby.
Focus on Collingwood
There are a lot of areas for Collingwood to work on over the off-season, however there is a lot of improvement which should be highlighted. Collingwood is the number one contested football side in the competition, and is also highly rated in tackling statistics as well. In the first half of the year, Collingwood was also the best side at marking inside 50, and preventing opposition marks inside 50. These are two areas which dropped off in the second half of the year and should be highlighted as Nathan Buckley looks to improve further next year.
It was interesting last week to see Buckley restructure his midfield. Pendlebury played a defensive role and floated off the back of the contest, whilst Jordan De Goey, Adams and Jack Crisp took over the reins and performed strongly. Buckley will continue to mix things up this round as he continues to throw new experiences to his younger players.
Collingwood played with complete freedom last week and got back to playing the sort of football which had it placed in the top four leading into the bye. The tackling pressure was enormous, the ball movement slick, the defenders were willing to work for each other, and the forward line made the most of its opportunities and took a lot of marks inside 50. Following the terrible loss to Richmond the week prior, it was an indication to me of this team’s pride and heart.
Player Focus
Jack Crisp – Crisp played a career-high best game statistically last week. After spending the last few games playing a more outside role, the former Brisbane Lion was thrust back into the midfield where he picked up 31 disposals, seven tackles and nine inside 50’s. To think that Crisp was originally thought of as just the steak knives as part of the Dayne Beams deal shows how far he has come this year. This is highlighted by the fact he has jumped from 626th in the Official AFL player ratings to 184. If he maintains this form, his rise will only continue. He is one of the real success stories of 2015 for the Magpies.
Travis Varcoe – Varcoe is another recruit who has shone at his new home. Provided ex-Cat plays this week, he will be one of only four Magpies who have played every game this season. He has never been a huge accumulator of the ball, but has still averaged a respectable 17 disposals a game to go with 10 goals. Importantly though, his physical pressure has gone to a new level, and his tackling has been terrific. He has been played in a number of positions, whether it be as a forward, wingmen or attacking defender. Undoubtedly it has been a career-best season for Varcoe, and we all look forward to what he can produce in the years to come.
Darcy Moore – He remains unlucky not to have received a Rising Star nomination, but the good news for Moore is that he will remain eligible in 2016. Whilst we have all seen glimpses of brilliance as a forward (none more so than his five goal effort against Western Bulldogs), what has surprised me has been his ability as a ruckman. His athleticism makes him a real force in the centre bounces in particular, and once he builds his body up he will also be quite a strong stoppage ruckman as well. It adds a new dimension to the Collingwood side if Moore can become the forward/ruck that it has been screaming out for. What impresses me most about Moore is his enthusiasm. He cheers every goal, whether it be he or a team-mate that kicks it.
Focus on Essendon
It has been a completely different look Bombers in the second half of this season as the club has looked to blood as many new players as possible. It has resulted in some massive losses, but Essendon has been more competitive in recent weeks, and has challenged the Gold Coast and Richmond.
However, the biggest problem for Essendon all season has been scoring. It is averaging only 70 points a game, and just simply has run out of ideas. Too much reliance has been placed on young Joe Daniher to hold up the forward line, and whilst he has performed admirably, he just isn’t ready for this heavy burden yet. It has meant players like Jake Carlisle and Cale Hookerhave had to play as makeshift forwards, which has only depleted the backline. The absence of Jobe Watson at such a difficult time of the year has also hurt.
There have been some positives though. A few youngsters have emerged, such as Jayden Laverdewho many considered a real bargain selection at last year’s draft. Nick O’Brien has also been solid, whilst Shaun McKernan has shown a lot of heart.
Player Focus
Cale Hooker – One man who can hold his head up high has been Cale Hooker. At one point this year, Hooker was the favourite to be named the All-Australian centre half back. However, he has had to sacrifice his role to help fill the void up forward. At the other end of the ground his nature of a fierce competitor and ability to take a strong contested mark has been vital. He kicked three goals last week, which takes his season tally to 19. Preferably, the Bombers will love Hooker to slot back into defence, but until they can find other options he will likely continue to plug the hole up forward.
Shaun McKernan – After being delisted by Adelaide, McKernan was thrown a lifeline by Essendon as a rookie. It took a while for him to get his opportunity due to the fact he needed a spot to open up on the senior list first. When it finally did, he was thrown into the ruck against the monsters of the competition. At 196cm, he is very undersized for this role, but he has competed valiantly. He has used his athleticism to become an attacking option around the ground, which has seen him average 17 disposals a game. He is also averaging a respectable 22 hitouts. Whilst he has struggled to compete against the best ruckmen in the competition, he has shown real heart and has cemented a spot in this Essendon side.
Dyson Heppell – Heppell has had to lead the club in the absence of Jobe Watson, and he has done a fine job. Statistically, Heppell is well down on last year’s averages, and at times has looked a bit worn-out. He lacks pace, but he has a huge heart and is definitely a captain in waiting. He always plays well against Collingwood, but will likely get the Levi Greenwood tag (Greenwood has taken the scalps of Cotchin and Selwood in the last two weeks).
The Final Word
As we embark on the final round of the AFL home and away season, I would like to take this opportunity to thank all those who have read my articles throughout the year, and also the Collingwood Football Club for providing me with the platform to share my thoughts with the Magpie Army.
This is the final game of the AFL Premiership Season. While it’s a dead-rubber, it also has the makings of quite an open and free-flowing affair, which could lead to some very entertaining footy. Supporters of both sides will be disappointed with how the season has turned out, but it is an opportunity to go to a game without nerves and just enjoy the afternoon. Despite last week’s game against Geelong counting for nothing, it was good to just to sit down, watch the next generation on display, and see my club play with pride. I would prefer to be playing finals of course, but it was a timely reminder of why we love this game and why we support our club. I’m looking forward to a similar afternoon this Sunday.
Also remember to support the respective VFL sides this week in the elimination finals. With the AFL sides finishing up, let’s hope that both Essendon and Collingwood can still have a presence at VFL level.
Whilst Essendon have been better over the last fortnight, Collingwood should be far too good, especially through the midfield.
Collingwood by 35 points.
Wednesday, September 02, 2015
Preview Round 23: Collingwood v Essendon
SportsMatt
As the 2015 AFL home and away season draws to and end this weekend, it’s hard not to reflect on what might have been for the Collingwood Football Club. After winning eight of their first 11 games it seemed as if finals were a certainty. Fate though intervened, and a mixture of injuries, drops in individual form and a tough draw meant that the Magpies have only won 2 of their last 10 games. They will miss the finals for the second successive season, something that hasn’t occurred since the 2004 and 2005 seasons. Some say the Magpies are too young, others criticize the coaching staff or the players as simply not meeting the standards set for them. Whatever the truth actually is two consecutive failures to play finals means the pressure will be on the Pies from every angle next season.
There’s still one more game to be played though, and it’s against another team that has failed to reach it’s expectations for 2015, Essendon. On Sunday at the MCG, arguably the two biggest drawing teams in the AFL will play out a rather meaningless game in front of a crowd of around 40,000. Of course the Bombers have had their own problems over the past few seasons, mainly off field, that have effected their on field output. While Collingwood at least gave the finals a shake for most of the year, Essendon were never really in contention and now sit in a club equaling worst 15th position. Yep, that’s right a loss this weekend and Essendon will finish as low as they ever have in their club’s history (in 2006 they also finished 15th). So maybe there is something on the line, for the Pies there’s pride, and for Essendon there’s a chance to avoid becoming the equal worst side in their long and storied existence.
PREVIOUS FORM
Collingwood’s form had been woeful up to last week. In the previous 9 games they’d only managed to defeat one team, and that was lowly Carlton. Last week though something clicked and the Magpies played like they hadn’t in a long time. Against Geelong at the MCG the Pies burst out of the blocks and hurt the Cats where it counted, on the scoreboard. To be fair the opposition didn’t give up much of a fight but the men in black and white played at a high intensity for four quarters. It was an impressive performance, more so as star forward Travis Cloke pulled up sore in the pre game warm up and didn’t play. Then Dane Swan was subbed out at half time with a season ending knee injury. It was the best performance Collingwood had produced in at least 6 weeks.
The Bombers’ form looks terrible on face value. They sit in 15th position on the ladder and have lost their last 7 games. Okay it’s bad, it’s very bad, and of course that really bad stretch of form led to the departure of senior coach James Hird. Matthew Egan has taken over and the past few weeks under a new boss have been better, with some competitive performances. The 27 point loss to an in form Richmond wasn’t even that bad, although the wet conditions did keep the scores close. In that game Paul Chapman said his farewells to the football world while young Irishman Conor Mckenna made his debut. A few Bombers performed well with Cale Hooker, Michael Hurley and Dyson Heppell leading the way. It’s been a long season for Essendon and they look as though they’ll be happy that it’s about to end.
COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
Before last week’s win over Geelong the Magpies had been copping a lot of negative heat from the press regarding yet another poor second half to a season. That was well deserved too, for although this Collingwood team seems more advanced then last season’s they aren’t going to win any more games. In fact the Pies have to win this game against Essendon just to match their 2014 win tally of 11 games. There have been plenty of positives in 2015 for Collingwood fans though. The introduction and continued development of a number of young players shows that the future is bright. Jordan De Goey may well be the shining light of the lot so far, with the young Pie showing just how much potential he has with 25 disposals in the win over the Cats. De Goey, along with the likes of Moore, Scharenberg, Maynard, Langdon, Grundy, Broomhead, Marsh and Crisp form the base as to which the next great Collingwood team will be built on. For now though it’s another season past without finals and something that will have to be remedied next year.
Leading into this game the Pies do have a few new injury concerns with Dane Swan and Ben Sinclair certain to miss through injury. Travis Cloke, a late withdrawal last week is also likely to miss with hamstring soreness. Jesse White came in for Cloke last week and will keep his spot. Alan Toovey will be available to return after a week off from all football and should walk straight back into the 22. Of the 22 who played last week other then Swan and Sinclair the Pies may think about dropping Marsh or Scharenberg back to the VFL. Talking about the VFL, the Magpies reserves side booked their place in the finals with a scrappy win over Port Melbourne last week. Ben Kennedy, Adam Oxley, Jarrod Witts and Paul Seedsman will all think they are a chance based on their efforts in that win. It’s the final chance for some of the Magpies players to impress the club and for some their future may well be on the line.
OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
It’s been another tough season for the Essendon Football Club with the ASADA/WADA investigation still hanging over their heads. Whether that’s had an immense effect on the playing group is debatable but in the end it has claimed some victims, with James Hird the latest one. The Bombers legend was unceremoniously dumped as senior coach a few weeks back and plenty of their fans weren’t happy about the way it was handled. On the field it hasn’t been much better with 7 losses in a row and a long injury list. Essendon lead the league for players used this season (41, tied for most with the Gold Coast Suns) which shows just how much turmoil they’ve had in 2015. That may have benefits long term though with plenty of young and promising players getting an opportunity at senior level that they otherwise might not have had.
It’s hard to find a real area of strength for Essendon at the moment but their back line is definitely the closest thing to that at the moment. Michael Hurley and Jake Carlisle have held together a defense that has been under extreme pressure this season. Michael Hibberd and Mark Baguley have also been main stays of a defensive structure that ranks second for rebounds from defensive 50. There is obviously talk around regarding Carlisle and his future but this is one area of the ground that has held up rather well. They match up this week against a Pie forward line almost certain to be without two of their best options, Cloke and Swan.
The Essendon midfield has had a tough time of it this year. The absence of Jobe Watson for most of the season would hurt any central group. In his absence Dyson Heppell has stood up though and is leading the club in both contested possessions and clearances by a long way. Heppell is a star now and will only get better in the future. The problem is after him the only consistent backup has come from Goddard, Howlett and Stanton. David Zaharakis has had a poor season and it’s hurt the effectiveness of this midfield for sure. The Bombers rank in the bottom 4 in most categories in the middle and it’s something that needs fixing for sure.
The Essendon forward line is still a work in progress. Joe Daniher is the future star of which they will build their attack around and in just his third season he will win the club’s goal kicking award easily. Once you look past Daniher though the problems show up straight away. Not one other player on the entire list averages one goal a game, a damning stat for any AFL side. Cale Hooker has shown in patches that he can play well up forward (3 goals last week) but he lacks the consistency at the moment. If there’s an area the Bombers have to improve in the most it has to be their forward line.
The Bombers season is just petering out really, even with the little on field boost they received with a change of senior coach. Nothing would make their fans happier though then to end a miserable season with a win over one of their biggest rivals. It’s not impossible either, with Essendon’s best pushing sides at time and of course defeating the Hawks earlier on in the season. There may be a good news story yet though with Dustin Fletcher a chance to play in what would be a farewell game. How motivated this group is knowing this is the end of their 2015 ride may well determine if they can push, or even defeat Collingwood on Sunday.
TIP
Collingwood go into this game in better shape then the Bombers both in terms of form and available players. The loss of Cloke and Swan does hurt but the Pies forward line found a way to score without either of them last weekend. Essendon may well have one good effort in them yet but if they perform the way they have in most of the last 7 games they will lose by a decent margin here.
I expect this game to be free flowing (weather permitting) as the two proud clubs try to finish off the season with a good show for their fans. Collingwood should win and that’s exactly what I expect them to do. The Pies midfield should dominate this game from start to finish and prove the difference in this dead rubber.
MAGPIES BY 22 POINTS.
Round 23
Collingwood v EssendonMCG Fox Footy (504) 3:20pm Weather: Min 7 Max 17 Chance of rain 90%: 1-5mm Wind: N 29kph Betting: Collingwood $1.25 Essendon $3.90 |
There’s still one more game to be played though, and it’s against another team that has failed to reach it’s expectations for 2015, Essendon. On Sunday at the MCG, arguably the two biggest drawing teams in the AFL will play out a rather meaningless game in front of a crowd of around 40,000. Of course the Bombers have had their own problems over the past few seasons, mainly off field, that have effected their on field output. While Collingwood at least gave the finals a shake for most of the year, Essendon were never really in contention and now sit in a club equaling worst 15th position. Yep, that’s right a loss this weekend and Essendon will finish as low as they ever have in their club’s history (in 2006 they also finished 15th). So maybe there is something on the line, for the Pies there’s pride, and for Essendon there’s a chance to avoid becoming the equal worst side in their long and storied existence.
PREVIOUS FORM
Collingwood’s form had been woeful up to last week. In the previous 9 games they’d only managed to defeat one team, and that was lowly Carlton. Last week though something clicked and the Magpies played like they hadn’t in a long time. Against Geelong at the MCG the Pies burst out of the blocks and hurt the Cats where it counted, on the scoreboard. To be fair the opposition didn’t give up much of a fight but the men in black and white played at a high intensity for four quarters. It was an impressive performance, more so as star forward Travis Cloke pulled up sore in the pre game warm up and didn’t play. Then Dane Swan was subbed out at half time with a season ending knee injury. It was the best performance Collingwood had produced in at least 6 weeks.
The Bombers’ form looks terrible on face value. They sit in 15th position on the ladder and have lost their last 7 games. Okay it’s bad, it’s very bad, and of course that really bad stretch of form led to the departure of senior coach James Hird. Matthew Egan has taken over and the past few weeks under a new boss have been better, with some competitive performances. The 27 point loss to an in form Richmond wasn’t even that bad, although the wet conditions did keep the scores close. In that game Paul Chapman said his farewells to the football world while young Irishman Conor Mckenna made his debut. A few Bombers performed well with Cale Hooker, Michael Hurley and Dyson Heppell leading the way. It’s been a long season for Essendon and they look as though they’ll be happy that it’s about to end.
COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
Before last week’s win over Geelong the Magpies had been copping a lot of negative heat from the press regarding yet another poor second half to a season. That was well deserved too, for although this Collingwood team seems more advanced then last season’s they aren’t going to win any more games. In fact the Pies have to win this game against Essendon just to match their 2014 win tally of 11 games. There have been plenty of positives in 2015 for Collingwood fans though. The introduction and continued development of a number of young players shows that the future is bright. Jordan De Goey may well be the shining light of the lot so far, with the young Pie showing just how much potential he has with 25 disposals in the win over the Cats. De Goey, along with the likes of Moore, Scharenberg, Maynard, Langdon, Grundy, Broomhead, Marsh and Crisp form the base as to which the next great Collingwood team will be built on. For now though it’s another season past without finals and something that will have to be remedied next year.
Leading into this game the Pies do have a few new injury concerns with Dane Swan and Ben Sinclair certain to miss through injury. Travis Cloke, a late withdrawal last week is also likely to miss with hamstring soreness. Jesse White came in for Cloke last week and will keep his spot. Alan Toovey will be available to return after a week off from all football and should walk straight back into the 22. Of the 22 who played last week other then Swan and Sinclair the Pies may think about dropping Marsh or Scharenberg back to the VFL. Talking about the VFL, the Magpies reserves side booked their place in the finals with a scrappy win over Port Melbourne last week. Ben Kennedy, Adam Oxley, Jarrod Witts and Paul Seedsman will all think they are a chance based on their efforts in that win. It’s the final chance for some of the Magpies players to impress the club and for some their future may well be on the line.
OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
It’s been another tough season for the Essendon Football Club with the ASADA/WADA investigation still hanging over their heads. Whether that’s had an immense effect on the playing group is debatable but in the end it has claimed some victims, with James Hird the latest one. The Bombers legend was unceremoniously dumped as senior coach a few weeks back and plenty of their fans weren’t happy about the way it was handled. On the field it hasn’t been much better with 7 losses in a row and a long injury list. Essendon lead the league for players used this season (41, tied for most with the Gold Coast Suns) which shows just how much turmoil they’ve had in 2015. That may have benefits long term though with plenty of young and promising players getting an opportunity at senior level that they otherwise might not have had.
It’s hard to find a real area of strength for Essendon at the moment but their back line is definitely the closest thing to that at the moment. Michael Hurley and Jake Carlisle have held together a defense that has been under extreme pressure this season. Michael Hibberd and Mark Baguley have also been main stays of a defensive structure that ranks second for rebounds from defensive 50. There is obviously talk around regarding Carlisle and his future but this is one area of the ground that has held up rather well. They match up this week against a Pie forward line almost certain to be without two of their best options, Cloke and Swan.
The Essendon midfield has had a tough time of it this year. The absence of Jobe Watson for most of the season would hurt any central group. In his absence Dyson Heppell has stood up though and is leading the club in both contested possessions and clearances by a long way. Heppell is a star now and will only get better in the future. The problem is after him the only consistent backup has come from Goddard, Howlett and Stanton. David Zaharakis has had a poor season and it’s hurt the effectiveness of this midfield for sure. The Bombers rank in the bottom 4 in most categories in the middle and it’s something that needs fixing for sure.
The Essendon forward line is still a work in progress. Joe Daniher is the future star of which they will build their attack around and in just his third season he will win the club’s goal kicking award easily. Once you look past Daniher though the problems show up straight away. Not one other player on the entire list averages one goal a game, a damning stat for any AFL side. Cale Hooker has shown in patches that he can play well up forward (3 goals last week) but he lacks the consistency at the moment. If there’s an area the Bombers have to improve in the most it has to be their forward line.
The Bombers season is just petering out really, even with the little on field boost they received with a change of senior coach. Nothing would make their fans happier though then to end a miserable season with a win over one of their biggest rivals. It’s not impossible either, with Essendon’s best pushing sides at time and of course defeating the Hawks earlier on in the season. There may be a good news story yet though with Dustin Fletcher a chance to play in what would be a farewell game. How motivated this group is knowing this is the end of their 2015 ride may well determine if they can push, or even defeat Collingwood on Sunday.
TIP
Collingwood go into this game in better shape then the Bombers both in terms of form and available players. The loss of Cloke and Swan does hurt but the Pies forward line found a way to score without either of them last weekend. Essendon may well have one good effort in them yet but if they perform the way they have in most of the last 7 games they will lose by a decent margin here.
I expect this game to be free flowing (weather permitting) as the two proud clubs try to finish off the season with a good show for their fans. Collingwood should win and that’s exactly what I expect them to do. The Pies midfield should dominate this game from start to finish and prove the difference in this dead rubber.
MAGPIES BY 22 POINTS.
Tuesday, September 01, 2015
Injury List
Injury Update Tuesday, September 1
|
|
|||
---|---|---|---|---|
Player
|
Injury
|
Status
|
||
Brenden Abbott | Shoulder | Season | ||
Tim Broomhead | Fractured shoulder | Season | ||
Travis Cloke | Leg | Test | ||
Nathan Freeman | Hamstring | Season | ||
Corey Gault | Groin/hip | Season | ||
Tyson Goldsack | Knee | Season | ||
Jackson Ramsay | Shin | Season | ||
Ben Sinclair | Fractured hand | Season | ||
Dane Swan | Knee | Season | ||
Travis Cloke remains some chance of taking his place in the Collingwood line up for its final game of the home and away season. The power forward withdrew from Friday night’s win against Geelong moments before the team ran out after injuring his leg in the pre-game warm up. Director of Football Neil Balme said Cloke will be tested later in the week ahead of Collingwood’s clash with Essendon on Sunday. “He was a bit stiff. It wasn’t specifically a hamstring but he was pretty sore, so we were a bit worried about him this week,” Balme told Collingwood Media’s Blackmores Injury Update. “Whilst we hope he will play this week, there is no absolute guarantee so we will see how he goes.” While Cloke remains a chance to see out the year, Dane Swan’s season is done and dusted. “Dane has unfortunately strained the medial ligament in his knee,” Balme continued. “It’s nothing particularly serious and he will recover fairly well but he won’t play for the rest of the season.” Until his injury, Swan had not missed a game this season. Ben Sinclair is another who will sit out the final game of the home and away season. The 23-year-old has endured a wretched run with injuries during the past two seasons, a theme that continued into his fiftieth game when he broke his hand but still managed to play out the match. “Ben fractured his hand earlier in the game and whilst he was able to play on very courageously, he will need some surgery on it,” Balme said. “He won’t play for the rest of the year either, unfortunately.” Utility Corey Gault has also been ruled out for the remainder of the season after being sent in for surgery on his groin/ hip. |
---|
Preview Round 23: Collingwood v Essendon
AFL
This final-round clash between two of the so-called 'Big Four' clubs will represent the first time in recent memory that they will meet with very little on the line, apart from pride and signs of development. Neither side can make the finals, which is particularly frustrating where the Pies are concerned, and they will be determined to finish off the season in a manner that they hope to start their 2016 campaign. The Bombers have been competitive in the past fortnight in losses to Gold Coast and Richmond, but the young Pies' effort against Geelong last week showed they are a class above Essendon, and should perform accordingly here.
LAST FIVE TIMES
PREDICTION: Collingwood by 29 points
Round 23
Collingwood v EssendonMCG Fox Footy (504) 3:20pm Weather: Min 7 Max 15 Chance of rain 90%: 1-5mm Wind: NNW 24kph Betting: Collingwood $1.25 Essendon $3.90 |
LAST FIVE TIMES
- R4, 2015, Collingwood 9.15 (69) d Essendon 6.13 (49) at the MCG
- R17, 2014, Essendon 16.7 (103) d Collingwood 5.9 (39) at the MCG
- R6, 2014, Collingwood 12.11 (83) d Essendon 8.12 (60) at the MCG
- R19, 2013, Collingwood 20.13 (133) d Essendon 7.12 (54) at the MCG
- R5, 2013, Essendon 18.13 (121) d Collingwood 10.15 (75) at the MCG
- Collingwood has had the better of Essendon in recent seasons, winning three of their past four encounters and nine of 11 since 2010, including four by more than 60 points.
- The Bombers are on track for their lowest-scoring season in 88 years. So far they have averaged 70 points a game. The last time they averaged 70 or under was in 1927, when they averaged just 67.
- If the Bombers remain 15th they will equal their lowest finish in club history. They also finished 15th in 2006. Meanwhile, this is the first time Collingwood has missed finals in consecutive seasons since 2004-05.
- The Pies have been one of the best ball-winning teams this year. They're ranked No.1 in contested-possessions, averaging 144.9 a game. In contrast, they're 11th in uncontested possessions.
- Neither side has finished the home-and-away season on a winning note recently. Both sides have won only one final-round clash since 2009.
- Magpie midfielder Jack Crisp's rise in his first season at Collingwood has been meteoric. In round 17 last year he was ranked 626th in the Official AFL Player Ratings and has since lifted himself to No.184.
PREDICTION: Collingwood by 29 points
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)