Sunday, August 31, 2014
Training Program Injury Link
REAL FOOTY
As coach Nathan Buckley revealed the Magpies' long injury list may have been as a result of training players "to the edge and potentially over the top", the Collingwood faithful will have a chance to question club powerbrokers over why they failed to make the finals at a members forum on Monday night.
The Magpies confirmed on Saturday the members-only forum featuring president Eddie McGuire, chief executive Gary Pert, football department chief Rodney Eade, captain Scott Pendlebury, Buckley and even executives from the commercial side of the business would be held at the MCG on Monday night.
Pert said he wasn't concerned the forum would become rowdy, and suggested it would now be held on an annual basis.
"We have committed as a club to be open and transparent. I think we communicate with our members and supporters better than any club," Pert said.
"If some people are frustrated or upset, if they want to ask some tough questions, line up and come and ask. If there is a little bit of energy in the room at different stages, well, that's because that's where the supporters are at. It gives us a chance to deal with it."
The Magpies opened the season with an impressive 8-3 win-loss record but slipped in the second half of the campaign, when injuries to the likes of Travis Cloke, Nick Maxwell, Dayne Beams and Dane Swan hurt. At one stage, the Magpies were unable to field 11 of their best 22 players.
The program run by high performance manager Bill Davoren, who joined the club in October last year, is expected to be questioned by members, with an internal review into the possible reasons for a plethora of soft-tissue injuries underway. The Magpies have also had seven serious knee injuries in the past two years.
Buckley said on SEN on Saturday the Magpies had "worked our players hard, potentially our injury profile suggests we pushed them to the edge and potentially over the top but that will hold us in good stead going forward".
In terms of training loads, he said the Magpies had been "massive unders" compared to rivals although this had been an effective policy during the latter years under former coach Mick Malthouse and former fitness boss David Buttifant – both are now at Carlton – when transition football was not as frenetic. He said the Magpies had since increased their training loads by up to 15 per cent to meet modern demands.
After their season ended in a 65-point loss to the Hawks on Friday night, Buckley said injuries and a lack of production from the club's senior players had impacted on the side.
"We clearly have got to fix our inner injury status – the last three weeks is a case in point," Buckley said.
"I think for what we put out on the park, [11-11] is probably a fair representation of our season. We'll go through a really thorough review process as we always do, [but] this evolution of Collingwood is pretty exciting."
Pert made it clear over the pre-season that the Magpies could challenge for the flag if the circumstances were right.
"We spoke as a group at the start of the year. I think that list was capable of with the senior players and leaders having a good season like we planned, with the young players coming through and playing a scattering of games and lifting and with a little bit of luck with injuries so we have all of our players out there, I think we were able to actually make the top four, be in the finals and be a real threat," Pert said.
"As it worked out, it's not only about the injuries, it's about who the injuries were to. When you lose a Nick Maxwell, outside of the club, that's completely underestimated the impact of that leadership."
Speaking on 3AW, Pert said a review would determine whether any changes were needed in the football department.
Buckley said the Magpies expected to retain utility Tyson Goldsack, who is off contract and has been linked to Port Adelaide. The Magpies have offered a two-year deal to the free agent.
"We love Goldy, and he is a very popular player within the playing group and the club in general," Buckley said.
"He's a player we hope and expect to retain, and he'll be a big part of what we build. We're pretty confident we'll be able to satisfy his needs."
As coach Nathan Buckley revealed the Magpies' long injury list may have been as a result of training players "to the edge and potentially over the top", the Collingwood faithful will have a chance to question club powerbrokers over why they failed to make the finals at a members forum on Monday night.
The Magpies confirmed on Saturday the members-only forum featuring president Eddie McGuire, chief executive Gary Pert, football department chief Rodney Eade, captain Scott Pendlebury, Buckley and even executives from the commercial side of the business would be held at the MCG on Monday night.
Pert said he wasn't concerned the forum would become rowdy, and suggested it would now be held on an annual basis.
"We have committed as a club to be open and transparent. I think we communicate with our members and supporters better than any club," Pert said.
"If some people are frustrated or upset, if they want to ask some tough questions, line up and come and ask. If there is a little bit of energy in the room at different stages, well, that's because that's where the supporters are at. It gives us a chance to deal with it."
The Magpies opened the season with an impressive 8-3 win-loss record but slipped in the second half of the campaign, when injuries to the likes of Travis Cloke, Nick Maxwell, Dayne Beams and Dane Swan hurt. At one stage, the Magpies were unable to field 11 of their best 22 players.
The program run by high performance manager Bill Davoren, who joined the club in October last year, is expected to be questioned by members, with an internal review into the possible reasons for a plethora of soft-tissue injuries underway. The Magpies have also had seven serious knee injuries in the past two years.
Buckley said on SEN on Saturday the Magpies had "worked our players hard, potentially our injury profile suggests we pushed them to the edge and potentially over the top but that will hold us in good stead going forward".
In terms of training loads, he said the Magpies had been "massive unders" compared to rivals although this had been an effective policy during the latter years under former coach Mick Malthouse and former fitness boss David Buttifant – both are now at Carlton – when transition football was not as frenetic. He said the Magpies had since increased their training loads by up to 15 per cent to meet modern demands.
After their season ended in a 65-point loss to the Hawks on Friday night, Buckley said injuries and a lack of production from the club's senior players had impacted on the side.
"We clearly have got to fix our inner injury status – the last three weeks is a case in point," Buckley said.
"I think for what we put out on the park, [11-11] is probably a fair representation of our season. We'll go through a really thorough review process as we always do, [but] this evolution of Collingwood is pretty exciting."
Pert made it clear over the pre-season that the Magpies could challenge for the flag if the circumstances were right.
"We spoke as a group at the start of the year. I think that list was capable of with the senior players and leaders having a good season like we planned, with the young players coming through and playing a scattering of games and lifting and with a little bit of luck with injuries so we have all of our players out there, I think we were able to actually make the top four, be in the finals and be a real threat," Pert said.
"As it worked out, it's not only about the injuries, it's about who the injuries were to. When you lose a Nick Maxwell, outside of the club, that's completely underestimated the impact of that leadership."
Speaking on 3AW, Pert said a review would determine whether any changes were needed in the football department.
Buckley said the Magpies expected to retain utility Tyson Goldsack, who is off contract and has been linked to Port Adelaide. The Magpies have offered a two-year deal to the free agent.
"We love Goldy, and he is a very popular player within the playing group and the club in general," Buckley said.
"He's a player we hope and expect to retain, and he'll be a big part of what we build. We're pretty confident we'll be able to satisfy his needs."
Saturday, August 30, 2014
Round 23: Collingwood 56 Hawthorn 121
COLLINGWOOD 2.3.15 4.6.30 5.8.38 8.8.56
HAWTHORN 1.4.10 8.8.56 12.9.81 18.13.121
SCORERS - Collingwood: White (2.3), Gault (2.0), Fasolo (1.1), Blair (1.0), Broomhead (1.0), Sidebottom (1.0), Goldsack (0.1), Lumumba (0.1), Williams (0.1)
BEST - Collingwood: Sidebottom, Pendlebury, White, Ball
INJURIES - Collingwood: Dwyer (right ankle)
SUBSTITUTES - Collingwood: Brodie Grundy replaced by Paul Seedsman at half time
REPORTS - Collingwood: Nil
OFFICIAL CROWD: 48,973 at the MCG
| 1. Hawks' slow start Collingwood dominated the first term to such an extent that Hawthorn looked set to register only its second goalless quarter of the year. At the 25-minute mark, the Hawks struck for the first time when Jack Gunston converted a shot from the top of the goal square. But Alastair Clarkson's side still ended the quarter with just one goal – a rarity for the Hawks. Before Friday night, the Hawks had kicked at least two goals in the opening quarter of their past 50 games. 2. Gault's goals Collingwood forward Corey Gault joined an unwanted club when his first kick – an attempt on goal – sailed out of bounds on the full. Fortunately, the debutant made amends only moments later, when he marked on the forward flank and skillfully slotted the shot. Having been with the club for almost three seasons – and demoted to the rookie list at the end of 2013 – Gault was keen to make the most of his chances in attack. In the second term he soccered through a kick at goal from 30 metres, which tumbled across the line. Gault competed hard through the night, jumped at contests and finished with seven disposals and three marks. 3. A friendly forward reminder With little trouble, Hawthorn star Jack Gunston kicked five goals against the Magpies, to take his season tally to 51. Just as quietly, Jarryd Roughead booted four goals and finished the home and away season with 62. Ahead of September, it was the perfect tune-up for the pair, who will go a long way to shaping Hawthorn's back-to-back premiership tilt. Traditionally finals have been dominated and defined by big and strong key forwards, and Roughead and Gunston will have that responsibility this year for the Hawks. |
4. Lake's scare A shudder went through Hawthorn fans midway through the third term when Brian Lake hobbled from the field with a leg injury. Lake looked to receive a corked right thigh in the forward pocket and immediately left the field with the assistance of trainers. He was in pain on the interchange bench before being subbed out of the contest at three-quarter time. After a season ravaged by suspension and soft-tissue injuries, last year's Norm Smith medallist needs to be firing for the Hawks come the finals – particularly as hulking Geelong star Tom Hawkins awaits next week. 5. Taking spots? Having secured their home qualifying final, the Hawks took the chance to rest some of their battle-weary players and give opportunities to those looking to break into the finals-bound side. With Ben Stratton (calf), Luke Hodge (knee) and Matthew Suckling (knee) already missing, speedster Bradley Hill was a late withdrawal with a corked quad. It gave Billy Hartung (who started as the substitute), Taylor Duryea, Angus Litherland and Ryan Schoenmakers the chance to impress and hold their place. Duryea had most impact of that group, finishing with 20 disposals off half-back. Having been with the club for almost three seasons – and demoted to the rookie list at the end of 2013 – Gault was keen to make the most of his chances in attack. In the second term he soccered through a kick at goal from 30 metres, which tumbled across the line. Gault competed hard through the night, jumped at contests and finished with seven disposals and three marks. |
| THE MEDIA | |
|
Hawthorn has tuned up for its premiership defence in brilliant fashion and ended Collingwood's season with a 65-point win at the MCG on Friday night. It was a match that lacked spark and pressure for long periods, but the Hawks did what they needed to before finishing in style to win 18.13 (121) to 8.8 (56). The result all but seals a qualifying final between Hawthorn and Geelong next week, assuming the Cats beat the Brisbane Lions at Skilled Stadium on Saturday night as expected. Hawthorn could still finish on top of the ladder if Richmond beats the Sydney Swans by about five goals at ANZ Stadium on Saturday, dropping the Swans to second while securing the last finals spot. Collingwood's loss keeps the Tigers, Adelaide, West Coast and Gold Coast in the hunt for the final spot in the top eight. In a scare for the Hawks, key defender Brian Lake limped from the ground in the third quarter with an apparent right hip injury, and he was substituted at the final break. The Norm Smith medallist was bumped by Jesse White late in the third quarter, but said post-match the injury was just a corked hip. Midfielder Brad Hill was also a late withdrawal 90 minutes before the match with a corked quad, but Hawthorn otherwise finished the match with a clean bill of health. As they did against Geelong last week, the Hawks made a slow start and appeared to be in trouble, but they pulled themselves together and went on a devastating run after quarter time. By the end of the third quarter, with their spread and pinpoint ball use on full display, the Hawks had kicked 10 of the last 12 goals to lead by 43 points. They raced to the finish line to notch their seventh consecutive win against the Magpies, and their biggest win since round seven. Coach Alastair Clarkson said his side had expected the Magpies to come out strong with their season on the line. "A lot of people in the footy community perhaps forgot that had Collingwood won, they could have still finished in eighth position," he said. "That didn't surprise us, the endeavour that the Collingwood side had early in the game. It was just a matter of trying to withstand that pressure. "We knew that if we could just hang in there they'd be unable to probably go with us for the full four quarters." Hawthorn forward Jack Gunston kicked five goals, while midfielder Sam Mitchell (30 possessions and 10 clearances) and Brownlow Medal hopeful Jordan Lewis (33 and 11 marks) – who could snare a crucial three votes – drove the midfield. Josh Gibson had a career-best 36 possessions for the Hawks and added 11 marks, while Jarryd Roughead showed his class with four goals. The battle to lead the Hawks' ruck division in the finals is probably alive after Jonathon Ceglar finished with 11 possessions, 15 hit-outs and one goal. Ben McEvoy will have the chance to press his claims in Box Hill's VFL final against Port Melbourne on Saturday. For Collingwood, which was already decimated by injuries to key players, it was midfielder Steele Sidebottom (36 possessions and nine clearances) captain Scott Pendlebury (28) who battled hardest. The injury-ravaged Magpies missed the finals for the first time since 2005, and finished the season with an 11-11 record after winning eight of their first 11 matches. In his final AFL game, premiership midfielder Luke Ball (21 possessions) was tireless to the final siren, and the 223-game veteran walked off the ground with a guard of honour from both teams. Debutant Corey Gault showed positive signs in kicking two goals, including a 30-metre effort off the ground in the second quarter. Coach Nathan Buckley saw positives in the performances of his young players, but acknowledged that a gap in class and experience was ultimately decisive. "Lambs to the slaughter comes to mind a little bit," he said. "We came with good intent and we executed our plans pretty well early...we just weren’t clean enough to take advantage. "As the game wore on, the Hawks' legs were telling against us and it just looked like we didn’t have anything under us. In the end, the result looked after itself." The Hawks were well off their game in the opening term, and might have been contemplating avoiding injury at all cost with so little to gain. The Magpies, meanwhile, had everything to play for with their finals flame flickering, and they threw their best at the reigning premiers for 30 minutes. But with an average of just 66 games' experience – compared to the Hawks' 118 – the tide was always going to turn. It did in the second quarter, with Mitchell and Lewis asserting themselves in the midfield, while Roughead and Gunston combined for five goals in the term. Roughead finished with four goals, leaving him five short of former Hawthorn teammate and Coleman Medal leader Lance Franklin (67). Collingwood's young team were "lambs to the slaughter" against a Hawthorn team tuning up for a run at the grand final. Coach Nathan Buckley praised his young team's endeavour in its 121-56 Friday night defeat but ultimately agreed with opposite number Alastair Clarkson – his side was too young and was always going to be overrun. "Lambs to the slaughter comes to mind a little bit. We came with good intent, we executed our plans pretty well early could have had a couple more ahead from the get go - (we) just weren't clean enough to take advantage of our dominance of field position. "And then, as the game wore on, the Hawks' legs were telling against us, and it just looked like we didn't have anything under us, and in the end the result looked after itself." Earlier, Hawthorn coach Clarkson had said he knew that despite Collingwood's strong first quarter the injury-hit side wouldn't be able to sustain the effort throughout. Clarkson, in fact, waited outside the press conference room as Buckley appeared before the media, side by side with retiring midfielder Luke Ball. Clarkson would wait until the conference was over for a chance to shake Ball's hand; Buckley spent much of the event gazing at Ball like a proud father would gaze upon his son. "It doesn't last forever," Buckley said. "Even the best blokes, who have given everything of themselves for the time they've had, it comes to an end for everyone. So the message for the young blokes is take advantage of it, make hay while the sun shines. Enjoy your field of dreams when you've got that chance." Ball, for his part, looked both emotional and embarrassed. "I was pretty keen to just keep it pretty low key and let it slide out after the game," he said. "Buck's advice was that it only happens once, and next week, a fortnight's time, you're just another ex-player. Have your moment - you've deserved it, even if you don't like it." Ball may be right. Certainly his coach is already looking to next season, as Ball looks to life after retiring from the "only job I've ever had". Of next season, Buckley said: "It doesn't feel like the end, it feels like the beginning. And it's the beginning of whatever we want to make it." |
HAWTHORN coach Alastair Clarkson was granted his wish at the MCG. A full dress rehearsal to prepare for another finals campaign. It was generally efficient, at times sloppy and ultimately could prove costly against a severely undermanned Collingwood. It finished with a 65-points win, 18.13 (121) to 8.8 (56). While a top two spot is now certain, the availability of key defender Brian Lake is not so assured after he limped off late in the third quarter. Lake sustained a hip or groin injury from a heavy bump to his right leg after a clearing kick. Understandably, he was subbed out of the game at the three-quarter time break. The diagnosis and recovery of such a crucial cog in the backline structure will be vital. And the mishap was untimely as much as unforeseen, particularly with the Hawks playing safe with key playmakers in this last finals “trial’’ game against the spirited if defenceless Magpies. After leaving out captain Luke Hodge (knee) and Ben Stratton (calf), speedy wingman Brad Hill (thigh) was a late withdrawal, giving Billy Hartung more game-time as the substitute. Hodge, Stratton and Hill all joined Thursday’s light training session and, while any nagging ailments could be safeguarded with the strict no-risk policy, nothing could prevent Lake’s mishap against an opposition fighting to stay alive in the fight for that eighth ladder position. Lake’s limp off was the only negative on a night tailor-made for a finals fine-tune when the 65 points victory and percentage boost reminded ladder leaders Sydney of the consequences if it slips up badly against Richmond. Like most opposition defences this season, the Pies were mesmerised by the speed on the lead and strength in the air from Hawks forwards Jarryd Roughead and Jack Gunston. And Jonathon Ceglar continued to shore up his place in the line-up, sharing the ruck duties with David Hale and looking dangerous as another forward marking option. It highlighted what has been lacking for Collingwood most of the season with the unhealthy reliance on injured Travis Cloke and only Jesse White regularly troubling the Hawks backline. Hawk Josh Gibson looked in fine touch down back, so was rebounding Grant Birchall and Shaun Burgoyne, not to mention prolific midfielders Jordan Lewis and Sam Mitchell. Clarkson wouldn’t have cared for several of the key team indicators nor individual attitudes when he walked to the quarter-time huddle. The Hawks repeated the slow, sluggish start of the previous weekend against Geelong to let the understrength Collingwood unit control most of the opening quarter. A set shot from the reliable Gunston with just 1.20 left on the clock prevented Hawthorn’s first goalless first term since back in round two against Essendon. The Magpies worked with intensity, desperation and vigour, in stark contrast to the Hawks whose early play could only be described as safe, conservative and flat. What hurt Collingwood was the inability to do the same on the scoreboard, the five points quarter time lead a poor return from the Magpie domination and five more inside 50 entries. It was as if the embarrassing opener stung the Hawks into action and slowly their improved disposal efficiency and attack on the ball started to swing the momentum. When Paul Puopolo goalled from a mark 11 minutes into the second quarter, it was the first time Hawthorn had the lead since the opening minute of the match. Increasingly, the premier looked threatening with the rebound from half-back with turnovers and attacked down the centre corridor with high balls inside the forward 50 arc. To no-one’s surprise, tall targets Roughead and Gunston shared five goals in the second quarter as the Hawthorn slammed on four straight, three of them in time-on to take a grip on the contest by the half-time break. The second half was largely a formality and extended game-plan tinkering for the Hawks. COLLINGWOOD premiership midfielder Luke Ball is content with his decision to retire after he was encouraged by coach Nathan Buckley to "have his moment" against Hawthorn on Friday night. Ball, whose future was sealed when he met with Buckley on Wednesday, said he was initially keen to make a low-key exit from the AFL after 223 games and a premiership in 2010. However, some advice from his coach led to him announcing the decision on Thursday, and his career was duly celebrated, with the popular veteran leaving the MCG through a guard of honour from both teams. "Bucks’ advice was that it only happens once and next week, in a fortnight’s time, you're just another ex-player, so have your moment, you’ve deserved it," Ball said. "I really thank him for that, because I've absolutely been humbled over the last 24 hours. Then the Hawks boys tonight, they certainly didn’t have to do that, they have bigger fish to fry next week. "I’m absolutely content that it’s the right call. I'm sure that in the light of day it will be a bit sad, but I'm definitely ready to move on." Ball said his conversation with Buckley on Wednesday was tough, but it was made easier by the pair's mutual respect. The Magpies ultimately fell 65 points short on Friday night, but Ball said he soaked up the final moments after another tireless performance. "In the last 10 minutes, I probably thought we were going to struggle to get back into it," he joked. "That was when I think the message came out … get yourself in the middle and just chase the footy a bit. "You rarely get that these days … I certainly tried to for that last 10 minutes, but unfortunately we were playing a side that is pretty hard to get the bloody ball back off." The Magpies' rooms were emotional post-match, as Buckley and president Eddie McGuire addressed the team and acknowledged Ball's contribution to the club. Result aside, Buckley said the club was "rapt to be able to celebrate Bally’s career". "These type of blokes don’t come around all the time, and it does highlight that it doesn’t last forever," the coach said. "Even the best blokes who have given everything of themselves for the time they have, it comes to an end for everyone unfortunately. "The message for the young blokes is take advantage of it, make hay while the sun shines and enjoy your field of dreams when you’ve got that chance." Ball admitted he wasn't 100 per cent sure what he would do post-football, but would map that out in the next few weeks. "My immediate future, I'll go and watch the VFL tomorrow and maybe channel a bit of Darren Millane and a few of those boys, sitting behind the glass and having a couple of cold beers," he said. "Lambs to the slaughter comes to mind a little bit. We came with good intent, we executed our plans pretty well early could have had a couple more ahead from the get go - (we) just weren't clean enough to take advantage of our dominance of field position."
|
Friday, August 29, 2014
Collingwood Forever Museum
 |
| Launch of Collingwood Forever Museum. Three Premiership captains: Nick Maxwell (2010), Tony Shaw (1990), and Murray Weiderman (1958). |
Luke Ball Retires
Collingwood News
A courageous, selfless footballer, Luke Ball can be found scrapping hard beneath the packs and is always the last man to rise when the umpire calls for a ball-up.
When he arrived at Collingwood at the end of 2009, he filled the gap in the engine room left by Scott Burns and Paul Licuria, and was a key part in securing the club’s 15th premiership twelve months later.
Ball was a key figure in St Kilda's rise in the mid-2000s, but found the sea change he was after at Collingwood. One of the most consistent and respected players in the game, Ball managed to fight back from a serious knee reconstruction to reclaim his place in the centre square.
To mark his retirement, collingwoodfc.com.au has charted his career, dating back to the 2001, the year he was drafted with the second selection in the ‘Super Draft’ that featured Luke Hodge and Chris Judd.
2001
Ball played for Sandringham U18 in the TAC Cup, and was school vice captain of Xavier College. He was famously drafted by St Kilda in the November ‘Super Draft’. At pick two, he was wedged between Luke Hodge (Hawthorn) and Chris Judd (West Coast).
2002
He spent the year completing his studies at Xavier College, and sat out all bar one match (for St Kilda’s then VFL affiliate Springvale) with osteitis pubis.
2003
Debuted for St Kilda in round one against the Kangaroos at the MCG, and looked at home immediately as he gathered 17 disposals and kicked the first goal of his career. He was nominated for the AFL Rising Star in round two against Adelaide (11 disposals, one goal).
Ball played 16 games for the season, peaking with 27 possessions in two matches (round five against Geelong and round 21 against the Bulldogs) and his brother Matthew (17 games) was drafted to Hawthorn.
2004
Ball played in St Kilda’s pre-season premiership team, and played in all 25 matches (including three finals) as the Saints reached the penultimate week. He kicked two in the Preliminary Final loss to Port Adelaide to cap off a strong finals series.
He received eight Brownlow votes for the year, and reached the 30-disposal mark for the first time in round 15 against Melbourne. He also managed 17 goals for the season, ran second in St Kilda’s Best and Fairest and represented Australia in the International Rules series.
2005
Named in the All-Australian side for the first time in his career, Ball amassed 528 disposals across 24 games. He continued to reinforce his reputation as a prolific tackler, recording 126 for the second year in succession.
He also received another nine Brownlow Medal votes, and initiated heated debate over his fearless play when he had his head split open by Port Adelaide’s Aaron Shattock mid-season.
2006
Anointed St Kilda’s captain (in line with then-coach Grant Thomas’ controversial policy of rotating the club captaincy), Ball struggled all season with groin injuries, but still managed to lead the team in handballs and tackles. His influence in front of goal was limited, as he kicked only three for the season. He still found 25 disposals and six tackles in the Elimination Final loss to Melbourne.
2007
Severe concussion suffered following a heavy bump from Demon Matthew Whelan meant Ball began his season on a sour note. He was forced to sit out the next two weeks, and was plagued there on by osteitis pubis.
He showed he was still capable of his best form when he won 31 possessions and kicked three goals against the resurgent Hawthorn in round 16. He had adductor-release surgery at season’s end to alleviate his groin troubles.
2008
Made some improvements on the previous two seasons, finishing ninth in St Kilda’s best and fairest, and playing the first 18 games without a miss. He ranked second at the club for tackles and contested possessions, but missed the last seven games (including three finals) with a hamstring injury. Ball also played in St Kilda’s pre-season premiership team for the second time in his career.
2009
Ball played 24 of 25 matches in the seniors, but was dropped for the first time since 2003 in round 16. He was a victim of the rapid improvement of second tier Saints such as Clint Jones and Andrew McQualter, and was squeezed out of the side due to a perceived lack of pace on the dry Docklands track.
Despite this, he was still one of St Kilda’s best-performed players in the losing Grand Final side, winning 22 disposals despite only playing 46 per cent of the match in conditions tailor-made for stoppage specialists.
He sought a trade to Collingwood in October but the two clubs could not strike a deal; footy folklore records that St Kilda refused Collingwood’s offer of pick 25 and a player for Ball’s services.
Regardless of the truth, Ball left the club and endured a nervous month until the Magpies’ Recruiting Manager Derek Hine finally called out his name with the 30th selection at the National Draft.
2010
It took just one season for Ball to vindicate his decision to cross to Collingwood.
He proved his doubters wrong with a brilliant season in the centre square, playing every match for the first time since 2005, bumping his season average disposal count back up to 21.1 and his tackle average to 6.5.
The leadership he provided to a youthful Collingwood team was not lost on his teammates, winning the Gavin Brown Award for Leading Desire Indicators, and running finished fifth in the Copeland Trophy.
His 155 tackles were a career-high, and he earned a Brownlow vote for his three goal, 20 disposal effort against Carlton in round six.
Ironically, Ball faced off with St Kilda in the two Grand Finals.
He battled to have an influence in the first Grand Final, winning only 13 disposals, but was one of the best afield in the replay when he gathered 25 disposals to cap off a controversial but ultimately fulfilling 12 months.
2011
Ball refused to rest on his laurels and turned in another stellar season in the midfield.
He joined the club’s leadership group, averaging 21.5 disposals and 166 tackles in 24 matches and also returned to form in front of goal, slotting 18.3 for the season to silence those in the media who claimed he’d lost power in his legs.
He became more important as the season wore on, turning out consistent performances all year long. He grabbed the spotlight during the finals with two clutch goals to seal victory – first against West Coast in the Qualifying Final, and the second a fortnight later against Hawthorn.
Loose at a stoppage inside 50m, Ball sharked the Hawthorn hitout and snapped truly on his left out of the congestion.
He began well against Geelong in the Grand Final but tapered as the game wore on.
Ball also played in his third pre-season premiership, and won his second Gavin Brown Award in as many years.
2012
Sadly, the tough midfielder’s 10th AFL season and third for Collingwood was cut dramatically short when he ruptured his right anterior cruciate ligament in round three against Carlton.
His renowned professionalism was on show when he continued to support his teammates with appearances at training and recovery while he was in rehabilitation, and was back on the track with them during the finals.
Ball fell about a month short of playing again and signed a two-year contract extension in June.
2013
Collingwood fans breathed a sigh of relief when their brave onballer finally returned from a knee reconstruction against Geelong in round eight.
Hamstring issues delayed his start to the season but once released into the VFL he wasted no time in getting his hands dirty.
He proved he had lost none of his touch when he recorded 26 possessions and eight clearances on return against Bendigo during a Friday night VFL fixture at the Queen Elizabeth Oval and was summoned to AFL ranks a fortnight later.
True to form, Ball managed to notch 28 disposals and nine tackles in his second game back against the Swans in round nine. He went on to produce a consistent season punctured by three one-week layoffs with calf complaints.
He was at his best against Essendon in round 19 when he polled three Brownlow votes owing to his seven tackles, 22 possessions and four clearances.
2014
Turning 30 in May, Ball’s season began well, averaging 22.0 disposals in the first month before a nagging back injury started to hamper his progress. He was forced to spend time in the VFL as he made his return, performing well against Box Hill and Essendon in successive weeks before slotting back into the side against Brisbane in round 21.
A courageous, selfless footballer, Luke Ball can be found scrapping hard beneath the packs and is always the last man to rise when the umpire calls for a ball-up.When he arrived at Collingwood at the end of 2009, he filled the gap in the engine room left by Scott Burns and Paul Licuria, and was a key part in securing the club’s 15th premiership twelve months later.
Ball was a key figure in St Kilda's rise in the mid-2000s, but found the sea change he was after at Collingwood. One of the most consistent and respected players in the game, Ball managed to fight back from a serious knee reconstruction to reclaim his place in the centre square.
To mark his retirement, collingwoodfc.com.au has charted his career, dating back to the 2001, the year he was drafted with the second selection in the ‘Super Draft’ that featured Luke Hodge and Chris Judd.
2001
Ball played for Sandringham U18 in the TAC Cup, and was school vice captain of Xavier College. He was famously drafted by St Kilda in the November ‘Super Draft’. At pick two, he was wedged between Luke Hodge (Hawthorn) and Chris Judd (West Coast).
2002
He spent the year completing his studies at Xavier College, and sat out all bar one match (for St Kilda’s then VFL affiliate Springvale) with osteitis pubis.
2003
Debuted for St Kilda in round one against the Kangaroos at the MCG, and looked at home immediately as he gathered 17 disposals and kicked the first goal of his career. He was nominated for the AFL Rising Star in round two against Adelaide (11 disposals, one goal).
Ball played 16 games for the season, peaking with 27 possessions in two matches (round five against Geelong and round 21 against the Bulldogs) and his brother Matthew (17 games) was drafted to Hawthorn.
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 8 Max 18 Chance of rain 20%: <1mm Wind: SSW 15kph Betting: Collingwood $9.50 Hawthorn $1.07 |
2004
Ball played in St Kilda’s pre-season premiership team, and played in all 25 matches (including three finals) as the Saints reached the penultimate week. He kicked two in the Preliminary Final loss to Port Adelaide to cap off a strong finals series.
He received eight Brownlow votes for the year, and reached the 30-disposal mark for the first time in round 15 against Melbourne. He also managed 17 goals for the season, ran second in St Kilda’s Best and Fairest and represented Australia in the International Rules series.
2005
Named in the All-Australian side for the first time in his career, Ball amassed 528 disposals across 24 games. He continued to reinforce his reputation as a prolific tackler, recording 126 for the second year in succession.
He also received another nine Brownlow Medal votes, and initiated heated debate over his fearless play when he had his head split open by Port Adelaide’s Aaron Shattock mid-season.
2006
Anointed St Kilda’s captain (in line with then-coach Grant Thomas’ controversial policy of rotating the club captaincy), Ball struggled all season with groin injuries, but still managed to lead the team in handballs and tackles. His influence in front of goal was limited, as he kicked only three for the season. He still found 25 disposals and six tackles in the Elimination Final loss to Melbourne.
2007
Severe concussion suffered following a heavy bump from Demon Matthew Whelan meant Ball began his season on a sour note. He was forced to sit out the next two weeks, and was plagued there on by osteitis pubis.
He showed he was still capable of his best form when he won 31 possessions and kicked three goals against the resurgent Hawthorn in round 16. He had adductor-release surgery at season’s end to alleviate his groin troubles.
2008
Made some improvements on the previous two seasons, finishing ninth in St Kilda’s best and fairest, and playing the first 18 games without a miss. He ranked second at the club for tackles and contested possessions, but missed the last seven games (including three finals) with a hamstring injury. Ball also played in St Kilda’s pre-season premiership team for the second time in his career.
2009
Ball played 24 of 25 matches in the seniors, but was dropped for the first time since 2003 in round 16. He was a victim of the rapid improvement of second tier Saints such as Clint Jones and Andrew McQualter, and was squeezed out of the side due to a perceived lack of pace on the dry Docklands track.
Despite this, he was still one of St Kilda’s best-performed players in the losing Grand Final side, winning 22 disposals despite only playing 46 per cent of the match in conditions tailor-made for stoppage specialists.
He sought a trade to Collingwood in October but the two clubs could not strike a deal; footy folklore records that St Kilda refused Collingwood’s offer of pick 25 and a player for Ball’s services.
Regardless of the truth, Ball left the club and endured a nervous month until the Magpies’ Recruiting Manager Derek Hine finally called out his name with the 30th selection at the National Draft.
2010
It took just one season for Ball to vindicate his decision to cross to Collingwood.
He proved his doubters wrong with a brilliant season in the centre square, playing every match for the first time since 2005, bumping his season average disposal count back up to 21.1 and his tackle average to 6.5.
The leadership he provided to a youthful Collingwood team was not lost on his teammates, winning the Gavin Brown Award for Leading Desire Indicators, and running finished fifth in the Copeland Trophy.
His 155 tackles were a career-high, and he earned a Brownlow vote for his three goal, 20 disposal effort against Carlton in round six.
Ironically, Ball faced off with St Kilda in the two Grand Finals.
He battled to have an influence in the first Grand Final, winning only 13 disposals, but was one of the best afield in the replay when he gathered 25 disposals to cap off a controversial but ultimately fulfilling 12 months.
2011
Ball refused to rest on his laurels and turned in another stellar season in the midfield.
He joined the club’s leadership group, averaging 21.5 disposals and 166 tackles in 24 matches and also returned to form in front of goal, slotting 18.3 for the season to silence those in the media who claimed he’d lost power in his legs.
He became more important as the season wore on, turning out consistent performances all year long. He grabbed the spotlight during the finals with two clutch goals to seal victory – first against West Coast in the Qualifying Final, and the second a fortnight later against Hawthorn.
Loose at a stoppage inside 50m, Ball sharked the Hawthorn hitout and snapped truly on his left out of the congestion.
He began well against Geelong in the Grand Final but tapered as the game wore on.
Ball also played in his third pre-season premiership, and won his second Gavin Brown Award in as many years.
2012
Sadly, the tough midfielder’s 10th AFL season and third for Collingwood was cut dramatically short when he ruptured his right anterior cruciate ligament in round three against Carlton.
His renowned professionalism was on show when he continued to support his teammates with appearances at training and recovery while he was in rehabilitation, and was back on the track with them during the finals.
Ball fell about a month short of playing again and signed a two-year contract extension in June.
2013
Collingwood fans breathed a sigh of relief when their brave onballer finally returned from a knee reconstruction against Geelong in round eight.
Hamstring issues delayed his start to the season but once released into the VFL he wasted no time in getting his hands dirty.
He proved he had lost none of his touch when he recorded 26 possessions and eight clearances on return against Bendigo during a Friday night VFL fixture at the Queen Elizabeth Oval and was summoned to AFL ranks a fortnight later.
True to form, Ball managed to notch 28 disposals and nine tackles in his second game back against the Swans in round nine. He went on to produce a consistent season punctured by three one-week layoffs with calf complaints.
He was at his best against Essendon in round 19 when he polled three Brownlow votes owing to his seven tackles, 22 possessions and four clearances.
2014
Turning 30 in May, Ball’s season began well, averaging 22.0 disposals in the first month before a nagging back injury started to hamper his progress. He was forced to spend time in the VFL as he made his return, performing well against Box Hill and Essendon in successive weeks before slotting back into the side against Brisbane in round 21.
Thursday, August 28, 2014
Round 23: The Team
Collingwood News
B: Jackson Ramsay, Jack Frost, Ben Sinclair
HB: Marley Williams, Lachlan Keeffe, Tony Armstrong
C: Heritier Lumumba, Scott Pendlebury, Sam Dwyer
HF: Steele Sidebottom, Corey Gault, Jarryd Blair
F: Tyson Goldsack, Jesse White, Brodie Grundy
Foll: Jarrod Witts, Josh Thomas, Tim Broomhead
Int: Alex Fasolo, Luke Ball, Paul Seedsman, Tom Langdon
Emg: Ben Kennedy, Quinten Lynch, Patrick Karnezis
IN: Corey Gault, Heritier Lumumba, Paul Seedsman
OUT: Brent Macaffer (knee), Dane Swan (hamstring), Clinton Young (hamstring)
NEW: Corey Gault (21, Swan Districts)
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 7 Max 21 Chance of rain 5%: <1mm Wind: SSW 14kph Betting: Collingwood $9.00 Hawthorn $1.07 |
HB: Marley Williams, Lachlan Keeffe, Tony Armstrong
C: Heritier Lumumba, Scott Pendlebury, Sam Dwyer
HF: Steele Sidebottom, Corey Gault, Jarryd Blair
F: Tyson Goldsack, Jesse White, Brodie Grundy
Foll: Jarrod Witts, Josh Thomas, Tim Broomhead
Int: Alex Fasolo, Luke Ball, Paul Seedsman, Tom Langdon
Emg: Ben Kennedy, Quinten Lynch, Patrick Karnezis
IN: Corey Gault, Heritier Lumumba, Paul Seedsman
OUT: Brent Macaffer (knee), Dane Swan (hamstring), Clinton Young (hamstring)
NEW: Corey Gault (21, Swan Districts)
|
Emerging tall Corey Gault will become the 1200th player to represent Collingwood in its VFA, VFL and AFL history when he lines up to make his debut against Hawthorn at the MCG on Friday night. Gault, who was sidelined for two months earlier this season after suffering a broken collarbone, surged into selection consideration over the last few weeks with a series of impressive displays at VFL level. Operating in the forward line and as a ruck, Gault’s performances have been characterised by his contested marking strength, aerial ability and stellar tap work, combining to earn the 21-year old his AFL debut. He is one of three inclusions for the match, alongside Heritier Lumumba and Paul Seedsman, with Brent Macaffer (knee), Clinton Young (hamstring) and Dane Swan (hamstring) all unavailable through injury. Drafted with the 65th pick in the 2011 National Draft, Gault arrived at the Westpac Centre as an athletic but still developing tall capable of rotating through the ruck or holding a key position role at either end of the ground. Such a description would hold true, with the West Australian’s versatility seeing him fielded in all three positions in the second tier competition, playing a pivotal role in the latter half of the season as he has helped propel the VFL Magpies to a second successive finals series. Lumumba meanwhile returns after missing Collingwood’s stirring eight-point triumph over Greater Western Sydney with a corked thigh. Having played 20 matches this season, averaging 20 disposals, three rebound 50s and three inside 50s per match, Lumumba’s inclusion will provide a necessary dose of experience to a Magpie side coping with the well documented absence of a host of established stars. After a three week stint in the VFL, Seedsman has been called up, ostensibly, to fill the void left by Young’s absence, with his added run and drive, and prodigious long kicking from half back and wing poised to be asset for the Magpies as the team looks to secure an unlikely berth in the finals series. Producing consecutive 24 disposal performances over the last fortnight, Seedsman’s inclusion arrives with his form in the ascendancy, and should be a welcome boost for the Black and White. |
Preview Round 23: Collingwood v Hawthorn
Collingwood News - David Natoli
As we embark on the final round of the 2014 home and away season, I would like to take this opportunity to thank those who have been loyal readers of my weekly articles, as well as the Collingwood Football Club for giving me the opportunity to post my previews on the club website.
It has been a really interesting year to preview Collingwood games given the extent of the team’s injuries, along with the amount of youth that has been required to step up and fill the void.
Although a finals position remains a possibility, I still believe it has been a positive year regardless of this weekend’s result, and the club is well positioned heading into the future.
So let’s delve into this week’s preview.
Collingwood can still scrape into the finals if it beats Hawthorn and Richmond loses to Sydney. It seems an almighty task for the Magpies considering they have not beaten the Hawks since the 2011 Preliminary Final and will be entering the game with as many as 11 first choice players unavailable due to injury.
Hawthorn may be without a few key players given the fact that it is cemented into the top four and looks destined for an MCG final against Geelong, regardless of the result on Friday night.
Nonetheless, the Hawks will be mindful of the fact that if they lose, and the Cats lose to Brisbane, that Fremantle has a small opportunity to leap frog both teams on the ladder and snare a home final, meaning the Hawks would have to travel to Perth in the first week of finals.
This possibility is extremely remote considering the Hawks remain a game and seven percentage points clear, but Alastair Clarkson and his men will want to remove all variables.
It is also unlikely that Clarkson will rest too many of his key players at it is important to have some form of continuity heading into finals and the Hawks won’t want to mess with their recent strong form.
Collingwood has no choice other than to head into this game and give it all it has.
It is likely to be an incredibly young team that will face the reigning premiers, but it is a team that will have gained some confidence from last week’s courageous effort against Greater Western Sydney.
The Formline
There would not have been too many pundits at the beginning of the season who would have claimed a win against Greater Western Sydney as Collingwood’s best win of the season.
But as the circumstances panned out, it could well and truly go down as a defining win in the club’s regeneration.
Following one of their most disastrous losses the week prior to Brisbane, the Magpies entered the match with a team that almost resembled the VFL Magpies, and was further hit during the match with injuries to Dane Swan, Clinton Young and Brent Macaffer.
The Magpies looked down and out as the Giants marched to a 21-point lead in the second quarter.
But the young Pies rallied and fought back to finally hit the lead deep in the final quarter and steal the match.
It must be said that the Giants were also undermanned, but it remains a really gutsy victory considering the way the game was going.
But it’s a completely different prospect this week against the reigning premier which is fresh from a commanding win against arch rivals Geelong.
Despite trailing by as much as five goals, the Hawks managed to kick 10 unanswered goals to totally blow the Cats away.
A half time spray by the coach was the impetus for the turnaround, as the Hawks re-established their premiership credentials for 2014.
It will be interesting to see how the two sides front up to this week’s game.
Collingwood may struggle to get up from a six-day turnaround with a young and battered side, while Hawthorn may suffer from a case of complacency given there are bigger fish to fry in the coming month and this game will likely count for little.
On the other hand, Collingwood still has a finals spot on the line and should throw everything at the game, while Hawthorn would like to enter the finals series with confidence.
Recent History between the Teams
As mentioned above, Collingwood has not beaten Hawthorn since the 2011 Preliminary Final. Hawthorn’s game-style has continually worried the Magpies due to the precision passing and ability to break the game open from defence.
This is the second time these two sides have met this year.
The last encounter was back in round 14 where the Hawks were comfortable 29-point winners. Collingwood did threaten at times and would have taken some confidence out of the game, but the Hawks always had their measure. It was their ability to break the game open in short bursts which was the difference.
Luke Breust was the destroyer with four goals, whilst Jarryd Roughead also bobbed up with three of his own. Jordan Lewis was brilliant with 27 disposals.
Scott Pendlebury was Collingwood’s best with 35 disposals, and Travis Cloke was dominant booting five goals.
At the Selection Table
Collingwood will have at least three forced changes this week with Dane Swan, Clinton Young and Brent Macaffer all ruled out.
Macaffer has torn an ACL and will require his second knee reconstruction.
Swan and Young remain a chance to play again this season provided the Magpies play in September.
Jamie Elliott and Heritier Lumumba both face fitness tests and would be welcome inclusions, while Alan Toovey is also still at least another week away.
At VFL level, the Magpies continue to impress with the likes of Patrick Karnezis, Kyle Martin, Ben Kennedy and Paul Seedsman all performing well in the win against Bendigo. Quinten Lynch, who announced his retirement this week, may also be in line for a farewell game given he booted five goals last week for the VFL Magpies.
Corey Gault has also been promoted off the rookie list and could be a surprise inclusion.
Turning the attention onto Hawthorn, and it looks as if there will be at least two forced changes this weekend, with the club likely to take a cautious approach on any player with a niggling injury.
Jack Gunston (ankle) and Matt Suckling (knee) will likely miss this Friday’s game but should be right for the first week of finals.
There is plenty in reserve, though, with Ryan Schoenmakers a logical replacement for Gunston, while Taylor Duryea could slot back into the side for Suckling.
Billy Hartung will also be available should any other Hawthorn midfield require a rest and Ben McEvoy remains on the cusp of selection as well, although Clarkson seems to favour ex-Magpie Jonathon Ceglar in the back-up ruck role at the moment.
It is important to note that both Collingwood and the Box Hill Hawks will play the first week of finals at VFL level this weekend.
Can the Magpies cause an upset?
Logic says that Collingwood is going to struggle this weekend. Even if Hawthorn does decide to rest a few key players, the Magpies will still be far more undermanned with a makeshift forward line, makeshift midfield and inexperienced defence.
The Hawks have battled injuries all year, but have a fit list heading into September, meaning there are plenty of players at VFL level who can comfortably fill the void this week if required.
But all is not lost yet.
History shows that the final round of the season always throws up a few upsets and can be quite unpredictable. It will be a mental test for the Hawks considering the players must be thinking about how close they are to September.
Even if Hawthorn drops a spot on the ladder, its first finals match will almost certainly be against Geelong at the MCG, meaning there will be no home ground advantage.
Collingwood also has the advantage of having nothing to lose.
I feel there is no doubt that Hawthorn will be casting its mind onto next week. Therefore, Collingwood must come out red hot to ensure the Hawks do not get the game on their own terms. With a young side, it will be important that the Magpies get a good start to build some self-belief.
Focus on Collingwood
It was not a pretty win last week, but the pleasing part was the amount of heart the side showed. It was a good day to be a Collingwood fan, and it was a win that will be replayed to the side over the off-season to draw on some inspiration.
Collingwood has continued to struggle in the clearances and was beaten in this department by the Giants for most of the match. But in the last quarter, Buckley played both his young ruckmen (Jarrod Witts and Brodie Grundy) on the ball and double-teamed the dominant Shane Mumford. This tactic worked and completely nullified Mumford’s influence. As a result, the Magpies began gaining the ascendency around the stoppages. It is a tactic I feel we’ll likely see employed this week against Hale and Ceglar.
Player Focus
Josh Thomas – After a breakthrough year in 2013, many were expecting Thomas to take his game to the next level in 2014. Unfortunately, a limited pre-season got his season off to the wrong start, and he has failed to find any consistency at senior level. This has seen him in and out of the side, but his VFL form has always been solid. He took his opportunity last week and played his best game for the club this season (and perhaps his career). Despite body cramps, Thomas led the midfield with 28 disposals and kicked three crucial goals. He will look to back up his great game this week against strong opposition and then carry this momentum into pre-season. Season 2015 looms as a huge year for Thomas, but the signs are really positive.
Tim Broomhead – Broomhead is another youngster to really take his chance. His form has been terrific at AFL level and he is proving a really dangerous player in front of goal. He has kicked eight goals in seven games, but it must be noted that his first two games were as substitute and he had little game-time. He brings pace and class to the side and looks a real player of the future. He had to battle glandular fever in his first season at the club, but his second season has been fantastic, showing he has a really bright future ahead. He is another who will be looking forward to a strong pre-season as he builds his fitness.
Focus on Hawthorn
There is no secret to Hawthorn’s dominance. All teams know that the key to stopping Hawthorn is preventing its run off half back and limiting its ability to pin-point targets.
It is also necessary to get on top in the midfield and make the most of opportunities, given the Hawks have a shorter defence than most, which can give the best key forwards a chance. Travis Cloke, for example, has a terrific record against Hawthorn.
Although we all know what to expect, there are very few teams in the AFL that have managed to break down Hawthorn’s system.
Once Hawthorn get its running game going, the forward line is simply too dangerous and will put the game away in the blink of an eye. You also can’t rest for a second against the Hawks, because they can turn a game in five-minute bursts.
The Magpies need to get on top in clearances and lock it in the 50 metre arc. I feel that Collingwood needs to make the game ugly and not let the Hawks get their precision kicking style flowing.
Again, this is easier said than done considering the Hawthorn midfield is a big bodied and experienced unit with the likes of Luke Hodge, Brad Sewell, Jordan Lewis and Shaun Burgoyne.
Player Focus
Bradley Hill – When these sides last met, Buckley sent Macaffer to do the tagging job on Hill. Hill had a huge first quarter, but Macaffer fought back to probably take the honours on the day. But the toll it took on Macaffer was evident, with the Magpie tagger seen vomiting at the quarter time huddle due to Hill’s huge work-rate. Hill is an elite endurance runner and his burst speed is impossible to catch. Without Macaffer this Friday night, the Magpies may be forced to use Marley Williams or Jackson Ramsey in the role, which is a huge ask for players not used to midfield tagging duties. Hill looms as the game-breaker.
Grant Birchall – It has been a season with little fanfare for Birchall, but he remains the player most sides elect to tag from the back half. Without Suckling, Birchall must be stopped this weekend, and I would not be surprised to see Tyson Goldsack thrown forward in a defensive job to try and keep him accountable. As stated above, Hawthorn’s greatest strength is its run from half back, so the Magpies need to be mindful of this.
The Wrap Up
It may be a next to impossible task, but don’t write the Magpies off this Friday. There is plenty of the line and it has been a year of upsets.
If Collingwood does manage to cause the upset, all eyes will then turn to Richmond’s encounter against Sydney, as that match will define the top eight.
Should the Tigers also cause an upset, they will dislodge Collingwood from the top eight and make the finals.
If both Richmond and Collingwood lose, the door remains ajar for West Coast and Adelaide to scrape into the eight.
It’s a huge match and I hope to see all fans at the MCG to support the team.
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 7 Max 21 Chance of rain 5%: <1mm Wind: SSW 14kph Betting: Collingwood $9.00 Hawthorn $1.07 |
It has been a really interesting year to preview Collingwood games given the extent of the team’s injuries, along with the amount of youth that has been required to step up and fill the void.
Although a finals position remains a possibility, I still believe it has been a positive year regardless of this weekend’s result, and the club is well positioned heading into the future.
So let’s delve into this week’s preview.
Collingwood can still scrape into the finals if it beats Hawthorn and Richmond loses to Sydney. It seems an almighty task for the Magpies considering they have not beaten the Hawks since the 2011 Preliminary Final and will be entering the game with as many as 11 first choice players unavailable due to injury.
Hawthorn may be without a few key players given the fact that it is cemented into the top four and looks destined for an MCG final against Geelong, regardless of the result on Friday night.
Nonetheless, the Hawks will be mindful of the fact that if they lose, and the Cats lose to Brisbane, that Fremantle has a small opportunity to leap frog both teams on the ladder and snare a home final, meaning the Hawks would have to travel to Perth in the first week of finals.
This possibility is extremely remote considering the Hawks remain a game and seven percentage points clear, but Alastair Clarkson and his men will want to remove all variables.
It is also unlikely that Clarkson will rest too many of his key players at it is important to have some form of continuity heading into finals and the Hawks won’t want to mess with their recent strong form.
Collingwood has no choice other than to head into this game and give it all it has.
It is likely to be an incredibly young team that will face the reigning premiers, but it is a team that will have gained some confidence from last week’s courageous effort against Greater Western Sydney.
The Formline
There would not have been too many pundits at the beginning of the season who would have claimed a win against Greater Western Sydney as Collingwood’s best win of the season.
But as the circumstances panned out, it could well and truly go down as a defining win in the club’s regeneration.
Following one of their most disastrous losses the week prior to Brisbane, the Magpies entered the match with a team that almost resembled the VFL Magpies, and was further hit during the match with injuries to Dane Swan, Clinton Young and Brent Macaffer.
The Magpies looked down and out as the Giants marched to a 21-point lead in the second quarter.
But the young Pies rallied and fought back to finally hit the lead deep in the final quarter and steal the match.
It must be said that the Giants were also undermanned, but it remains a really gutsy victory considering the way the game was going.
But it’s a completely different prospect this week against the reigning premier which is fresh from a commanding win against arch rivals Geelong.
Despite trailing by as much as five goals, the Hawks managed to kick 10 unanswered goals to totally blow the Cats away.
A half time spray by the coach was the impetus for the turnaround, as the Hawks re-established their premiership credentials for 2014.
It will be interesting to see how the two sides front up to this week’s game.
Collingwood may struggle to get up from a six-day turnaround with a young and battered side, while Hawthorn may suffer from a case of complacency given there are bigger fish to fry in the coming month and this game will likely count for little.
On the other hand, Collingwood still has a finals spot on the line and should throw everything at the game, while Hawthorn would like to enter the finals series with confidence.
Recent History between the Teams
As mentioned above, Collingwood has not beaten Hawthorn since the 2011 Preliminary Final. Hawthorn’s game-style has continually worried the Magpies due to the precision passing and ability to break the game open from defence.
This is the second time these two sides have met this year.
The last encounter was back in round 14 where the Hawks were comfortable 29-point winners. Collingwood did threaten at times and would have taken some confidence out of the game, but the Hawks always had their measure. It was their ability to break the game open in short bursts which was the difference.
Luke Breust was the destroyer with four goals, whilst Jarryd Roughead also bobbed up with three of his own. Jordan Lewis was brilliant with 27 disposals.
Scott Pendlebury was Collingwood’s best with 35 disposals, and Travis Cloke was dominant booting five goals.
At the Selection Table
Collingwood will have at least three forced changes this week with Dane Swan, Clinton Young and Brent Macaffer all ruled out.
Macaffer has torn an ACL and will require his second knee reconstruction.
Swan and Young remain a chance to play again this season provided the Magpies play in September.
Jamie Elliott and Heritier Lumumba both face fitness tests and would be welcome inclusions, while Alan Toovey is also still at least another week away.
At VFL level, the Magpies continue to impress with the likes of Patrick Karnezis, Kyle Martin, Ben Kennedy and Paul Seedsman all performing well in the win against Bendigo. Quinten Lynch, who announced his retirement this week, may also be in line for a farewell game given he booted five goals last week for the VFL Magpies.
Corey Gault has also been promoted off the rookie list and could be a surprise inclusion.
Turning the attention onto Hawthorn, and it looks as if there will be at least two forced changes this weekend, with the club likely to take a cautious approach on any player with a niggling injury.
Jack Gunston (ankle) and Matt Suckling (knee) will likely miss this Friday’s game but should be right for the first week of finals.
There is plenty in reserve, though, with Ryan Schoenmakers a logical replacement for Gunston, while Taylor Duryea could slot back into the side for Suckling.
Billy Hartung will also be available should any other Hawthorn midfield require a rest and Ben McEvoy remains on the cusp of selection as well, although Clarkson seems to favour ex-Magpie Jonathon Ceglar in the back-up ruck role at the moment.
It is important to note that both Collingwood and the Box Hill Hawks will play the first week of finals at VFL level this weekend.
Can the Magpies cause an upset?
Logic says that Collingwood is going to struggle this weekend. Even if Hawthorn does decide to rest a few key players, the Magpies will still be far more undermanned with a makeshift forward line, makeshift midfield and inexperienced defence.
The Hawks have battled injuries all year, but have a fit list heading into September, meaning there are plenty of players at VFL level who can comfortably fill the void this week if required.
But all is not lost yet.
History shows that the final round of the season always throws up a few upsets and can be quite unpredictable. It will be a mental test for the Hawks considering the players must be thinking about how close they are to September.
Even if Hawthorn drops a spot on the ladder, its first finals match will almost certainly be against Geelong at the MCG, meaning there will be no home ground advantage.
Collingwood also has the advantage of having nothing to lose.
I feel there is no doubt that Hawthorn will be casting its mind onto next week. Therefore, Collingwood must come out red hot to ensure the Hawks do not get the game on their own terms. With a young side, it will be important that the Magpies get a good start to build some self-belief.
Focus on Collingwood
It was not a pretty win last week, but the pleasing part was the amount of heart the side showed. It was a good day to be a Collingwood fan, and it was a win that will be replayed to the side over the off-season to draw on some inspiration.
Collingwood has continued to struggle in the clearances and was beaten in this department by the Giants for most of the match. But in the last quarter, Buckley played both his young ruckmen (Jarrod Witts and Brodie Grundy) on the ball and double-teamed the dominant Shane Mumford. This tactic worked and completely nullified Mumford’s influence. As a result, the Magpies began gaining the ascendency around the stoppages. It is a tactic I feel we’ll likely see employed this week against Hale and Ceglar.
Player Focus
Josh Thomas – After a breakthrough year in 2013, many were expecting Thomas to take his game to the next level in 2014. Unfortunately, a limited pre-season got his season off to the wrong start, and he has failed to find any consistency at senior level. This has seen him in and out of the side, but his VFL form has always been solid. He took his opportunity last week and played his best game for the club this season (and perhaps his career). Despite body cramps, Thomas led the midfield with 28 disposals and kicked three crucial goals. He will look to back up his great game this week against strong opposition and then carry this momentum into pre-season. Season 2015 looms as a huge year for Thomas, but the signs are really positive.
Tim Broomhead – Broomhead is another youngster to really take his chance. His form has been terrific at AFL level and he is proving a really dangerous player in front of goal. He has kicked eight goals in seven games, but it must be noted that his first two games were as substitute and he had little game-time. He brings pace and class to the side and looks a real player of the future. He had to battle glandular fever in his first season at the club, but his second season has been fantastic, showing he has a really bright future ahead. He is another who will be looking forward to a strong pre-season as he builds his fitness.
Focus on Hawthorn
There is no secret to Hawthorn’s dominance. All teams know that the key to stopping Hawthorn is preventing its run off half back and limiting its ability to pin-point targets.
It is also necessary to get on top in the midfield and make the most of opportunities, given the Hawks have a shorter defence than most, which can give the best key forwards a chance. Travis Cloke, for example, has a terrific record against Hawthorn.
Although we all know what to expect, there are very few teams in the AFL that have managed to break down Hawthorn’s system.
Once Hawthorn get its running game going, the forward line is simply too dangerous and will put the game away in the blink of an eye. You also can’t rest for a second against the Hawks, because they can turn a game in five-minute bursts.
The Magpies need to get on top in clearances and lock it in the 50 metre arc. I feel that Collingwood needs to make the game ugly and not let the Hawks get their precision kicking style flowing.
Again, this is easier said than done considering the Hawthorn midfield is a big bodied and experienced unit with the likes of Luke Hodge, Brad Sewell, Jordan Lewis and Shaun Burgoyne.
Player Focus
Bradley Hill – When these sides last met, Buckley sent Macaffer to do the tagging job on Hill. Hill had a huge first quarter, but Macaffer fought back to probably take the honours on the day. But the toll it took on Macaffer was evident, with the Magpie tagger seen vomiting at the quarter time huddle due to Hill’s huge work-rate. Hill is an elite endurance runner and his burst speed is impossible to catch. Without Macaffer this Friday night, the Magpies may be forced to use Marley Williams or Jackson Ramsey in the role, which is a huge ask for players not used to midfield tagging duties. Hill looms as the game-breaker.
Grant Birchall – It has been a season with little fanfare for Birchall, but he remains the player most sides elect to tag from the back half. Without Suckling, Birchall must be stopped this weekend, and I would not be surprised to see Tyson Goldsack thrown forward in a defensive job to try and keep him accountable. As stated above, Hawthorn’s greatest strength is its run from half back, so the Magpies need to be mindful of this.
The Wrap Up
It may be a next to impossible task, but don’t write the Magpies off this Friday. There is plenty of the line and it has been a year of upsets.
If Collingwood does manage to cause the upset, all eyes will then turn to Richmond’s encounter against Sydney, as that match will define the top eight.
Should the Tigers also cause an upset, they will dislodge Collingwood from the top eight and make the finals.
If both Richmond and Collingwood lose, the door remains ajar for West Coast and Adelaide to scrape into the eight.
It’s a huge match and I hope to see all fans at the MCG to support the team.
Preview Round 23: Collingwood v Hawthorn
SportMatt
SO IT’S COME DOWN TO THIS, after 21 games the Collingwood football club get one shot at qualifying for the finals, and it happens this Friday. It’s an easy equation for the Magpies really, win and then hope the Swans beat the Tigers on Saturday, and they will finish 8th and make their 9th consecutive AFL finals series. Lose though and it’s all over, season 2014 will be entered in the history books as a failure for Collingwood.
It all started so well for the biggest sporting club in Australia, as at the halfway point of the season they held an 8-3 win/loss record and looked a certainty for finals, and maybe even a top 4 chance. Since then though it’s all fallen apart, with injuries, form and an inability to win some close games putting the Pies in a free fall down the AFL ladder. While most focus on the extensive injuries that have befallen Collingwood this season the story goes deeper than that, with their depth being exposed as young and inexperienced or simply not good enough at times. It’s been a bad year for the Pies in many facets but there have been positives also, and with a win here they could just salvage something yet.
So onto Friday night, when the Hawks and Pies clash for the second time this season at the MCG. The last time they clashed the Hawks defeated the Magpies for the 6th consecutive time, a streak that goes back to the epic 2011 preliminary final where the Pies came from behind to steal an improbable win. In round 14 the Pies put up a fight for the whole game but never really looked like winning, as the Hawks won by 19 points and the free fall for the Pies just started to take shape. Since then Hawthorn has cemented a spot in the top 2, and are almost certain now to be facing Geelong in week one of the finals, a side they defeated in spectacular fashion last Saturday night. Hawthorn themselves has a few injury concerns leading into the finals but with at least a 7 day break between this game and their first final, it’s hard to see them resting too many against Collingwood.
COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
Some may say that Collingwood have done well to even still be in contention for a spot in the eight considering all the problems they’ve had, but realistically anything other than a finals appearance is a failure for the Magpies. Last weekend up in Sydney the Pies kept their finals hopes alive with a gutsy come from behind win over the upstart GWS Giants. It wasn’t the prettiest of wins but was one that gave the Magpies army plenty of satisfaction. Once again the Pies had to battle with troops down, with Swan, Young and Macaffer all off injured early it became a tough task for a side out of form to find a way to win with only one player left on the bench. Somehow though some of the lesser known Magpies lifted and they were able to steal an 8 point win that gave them hope, even if it’s slight hope. The return to form of the likes of Thomas, Blair, Williams and the leadership of Pendlebury and Sidebottom was the main reason Collingwood were able to win, and they’ll be leaning on their leaders again this Friday night.
With three players going out through injury somewhere Collingwood needs to find three to replace them, and they may be in luck for once with Jamie Elliott and Heritier Lumumba pushing to return after missing recent games through injury. Elliott in particular would add a dangerous edge to a Magpies attack that is badly needed in the absence of first choice forwards Cloke and Reid. The VFL side had yet another good win (and will play finals) and at least one player out of that win will be promoted to the seniors this week. Those in contention out of the VFL include Kennedy, Martin, Karnezis, Lynch, Gault and Seedsman, but there’s almost nothing left after that to chose from.
One statistic that says it all about the Pies this year is that Jack Frost, basically a first year player, will become the only Collingwood player to play all 22 games if he lines up this week. The Magpies are down to the bare bones at the bottom of their list but they will field a side on Friday night that will believe it is a chance of causing an upset and keeping their season alive, for one more week at least.
OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
Hawthorn came into season 2014 looking to become the first team to win back to back flags since Adelaide in 1997-98. After 21 games they have secured a top four spot and with the win over Geelong last weekend all but assured themselves of a first week final at the MCG. Put simply they have as good a chance of going back to back as any club has had in the last decade. They’ve done things a little differently this year too, with an aging team in the last 2 grand finals it was clear that an injection of youth was needed and that’s exactly what has happened. One of those players has been an ex Magpies, Jonathon Ceglar, who you could say has been more impressive than the Hawks big off season recruit, Ben McEvoy. The injection of youth has reinvigorated some of the older players and despite a decent bout of injuries the Hawks are primed for a shot at football immortality.
The Hawks backline is largely under rated, but of course was given a boost in notoriety with Brian Lake winning the Norm Smith medal last season. The Hawks have always has a good team mentality when it comes to the defensive side of the game and that has meant they haven’t had to had supreme talent down back. They do still rely on Lake and Stratton to carry the burden of covering the oppositions key forwards though and for the most part they do that job well. Sides may see the small and medium defender positions as areas where they can exploit the Hawks but when a team has won as many games as this one has in the last 3 seasons, there really isn’t an apparent weakness down back. They’ll face off this week against a severely weakened Pies forward line with no Cloke, Reid or Beams to cause havoc. It’s an area of the ground the Hawks will need to get right come finals, so I wouldn’t be expecting any let down defensively on Friday night.
The Hawthorn forward line is scary for opposition back lines and that’s before you add the plethora of scoring options they have through the middle and off half back. They have 3 of the top 10 forwards in the AFL in Roughead, Breust and Gunston, who between them have kicked 156 goals so far this season. Luckily for the Pies Cyril Rioli won’t play this week so that makes the task of restricting the highest scoring team in the AFL just a little bit easier. Realistically though this is the part of the ground which will probably decide the game, with the Hawks being so powerful when they go forward that they’ve scored over 250 points more than the next best team in the AFL. The Pies backline has been decimated with no Toovey, Maxwell, Reid or Brown so it’s going to be very hard to stop the Hawks from posting a big score.
The midfield that the Hawks possess is strong, skilful and has a defensive edge to it that few others in the AFL possess. It’s no secret that the best sides win the majority of the clearances and the Hawks sure do dominate here as they are ranked 1st for centre clearances and 2nd for total clearances. It allows the Hawks to dictate the terms by which they want to play with and it works a treat for them. The names that rotate through this central grouping would be starting 22 players at any club, with Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis, Shiels, Hill, Smith and Sewell all class footballers but with a hard edge to them. The Magpies midfield, like most of it’s side, has been hit hard by injuries and the absence of Swan, Adams and Beams will be felt the most against this Hawks team. Everywhere you look the Pies are outmatched but football isn’t played on paper, so anything is possible.
Hawthorn will use this game as a tune up before heading into a finals series they hope will deliver them back to back flags. They may rest a player or two if they have any significant injuries but I can’t see them holding back too much, especially with a guaranteed 7 day break leading into the first final after this. The Hawthorn side is full of class, knows how to defend when they don’t have the ball and punishes sides like no other once they get on top. They are a true premiership contender and will make the Pies earn a finals spot.
TIP
The odds say that the Hawks are nigh on unbeatable this week but as we’ve seen already this season, and plenty of times in the past, upsets do happen. The Swans lost to GWS, and Fremantle lost to St Kilda so it’s not beyond the Magpies to cause the third huge upset of season 2014.
Of course the Hawks deserve to be favourites for this game, they are about to start a finals series where as the Pies, decimated by injuries, need to win just to be in those finals.
I just feel as if the desperate young Magpies, with more to prove and play for, may sneak across the line in a famous win for the Collingwood Football Club.
MAGPIES BY 2 POINTS.
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 7 Max 21 Chance of rain 5%: <1mm Wind: SSW 14kph Betting: Collingwood $9.00 Hawthorn $1.07 |
It all started so well for the biggest sporting club in Australia, as at the halfway point of the season they held an 8-3 win/loss record and looked a certainty for finals, and maybe even a top 4 chance. Since then though it’s all fallen apart, with injuries, form and an inability to win some close games putting the Pies in a free fall down the AFL ladder. While most focus on the extensive injuries that have befallen Collingwood this season the story goes deeper than that, with their depth being exposed as young and inexperienced or simply not good enough at times. It’s been a bad year for the Pies in many facets but there have been positives also, and with a win here they could just salvage something yet.
So onto Friday night, when the Hawks and Pies clash for the second time this season at the MCG. The last time they clashed the Hawks defeated the Magpies for the 6th consecutive time, a streak that goes back to the epic 2011 preliminary final where the Pies came from behind to steal an improbable win. In round 14 the Pies put up a fight for the whole game but never really looked like winning, as the Hawks won by 19 points and the free fall for the Pies just started to take shape. Since then Hawthorn has cemented a spot in the top 2, and are almost certain now to be facing Geelong in week one of the finals, a side they defeated in spectacular fashion last Saturday night. Hawthorn themselves has a few injury concerns leading into the finals but with at least a 7 day break between this game and their first final, it’s hard to see them resting too many against Collingwood.
COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
Some may say that Collingwood have done well to even still be in contention for a spot in the eight considering all the problems they’ve had, but realistically anything other than a finals appearance is a failure for the Magpies. Last weekend up in Sydney the Pies kept their finals hopes alive with a gutsy come from behind win over the upstart GWS Giants. It wasn’t the prettiest of wins but was one that gave the Magpies army plenty of satisfaction. Once again the Pies had to battle with troops down, with Swan, Young and Macaffer all off injured early it became a tough task for a side out of form to find a way to win with only one player left on the bench. Somehow though some of the lesser known Magpies lifted and they were able to steal an 8 point win that gave them hope, even if it’s slight hope. The return to form of the likes of Thomas, Blair, Williams and the leadership of Pendlebury and Sidebottom was the main reason Collingwood were able to win, and they’ll be leaning on their leaders again this Friday night.
With three players going out through injury somewhere Collingwood needs to find three to replace them, and they may be in luck for once with Jamie Elliott and Heritier Lumumba pushing to return after missing recent games through injury. Elliott in particular would add a dangerous edge to a Magpies attack that is badly needed in the absence of first choice forwards Cloke and Reid. The VFL side had yet another good win (and will play finals) and at least one player out of that win will be promoted to the seniors this week. Those in contention out of the VFL include Kennedy, Martin, Karnezis, Lynch, Gault and Seedsman, but there’s almost nothing left after that to chose from.
One statistic that says it all about the Pies this year is that Jack Frost, basically a first year player, will become the only Collingwood player to play all 22 games if he lines up this week. The Magpies are down to the bare bones at the bottom of their list but they will field a side on Friday night that will believe it is a chance of causing an upset and keeping their season alive, for one more week at least.
OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
Hawthorn came into season 2014 looking to become the first team to win back to back flags since Adelaide in 1997-98. After 21 games they have secured a top four spot and with the win over Geelong last weekend all but assured themselves of a first week final at the MCG. Put simply they have as good a chance of going back to back as any club has had in the last decade. They’ve done things a little differently this year too, with an aging team in the last 2 grand finals it was clear that an injection of youth was needed and that’s exactly what has happened. One of those players has been an ex Magpies, Jonathon Ceglar, who you could say has been more impressive than the Hawks big off season recruit, Ben McEvoy. The injection of youth has reinvigorated some of the older players and despite a decent bout of injuries the Hawks are primed for a shot at football immortality.
The Hawks backline is largely under rated, but of course was given a boost in notoriety with Brian Lake winning the Norm Smith medal last season. The Hawks have always has a good team mentality when it comes to the defensive side of the game and that has meant they haven’t had to had supreme talent down back. They do still rely on Lake and Stratton to carry the burden of covering the oppositions key forwards though and for the most part they do that job well. Sides may see the small and medium defender positions as areas where they can exploit the Hawks but when a team has won as many games as this one has in the last 3 seasons, there really isn’t an apparent weakness down back. They’ll face off this week against a severely weakened Pies forward line with no Cloke, Reid or Beams to cause havoc. It’s an area of the ground the Hawks will need to get right come finals, so I wouldn’t be expecting any let down defensively on Friday night.
The Hawthorn forward line is scary for opposition back lines and that’s before you add the plethora of scoring options they have through the middle and off half back. They have 3 of the top 10 forwards in the AFL in Roughead, Breust and Gunston, who between them have kicked 156 goals so far this season. Luckily for the Pies Cyril Rioli won’t play this week so that makes the task of restricting the highest scoring team in the AFL just a little bit easier. Realistically though this is the part of the ground which will probably decide the game, with the Hawks being so powerful when they go forward that they’ve scored over 250 points more than the next best team in the AFL. The Pies backline has been decimated with no Toovey, Maxwell, Reid or Brown so it’s going to be very hard to stop the Hawks from posting a big score.
The midfield that the Hawks possess is strong, skilful and has a defensive edge to it that few others in the AFL possess. It’s no secret that the best sides win the majority of the clearances and the Hawks sure do dominate here as they are ranked 1st for centre clearances and 2nd for total clearances. It allows the Hawks to dictate the terms by which they want to play with and it works a treat for them. The names that rotate through this central grouping would be starting 22 players at any club, with Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis, Shiels, Hill, Smith and Sewell all class footballers but with a hard edge to them. The Magpies midfield, like most of it’s side, has been hit hard by injuries and the absence of Swan, Adams and Beams will be felt the most against this Hawks team. Everywhere you look the Pies are outmatched but football isn’t played on paper, so anything is possible.
Hawthorn will use this game as a tune up before heading into a finals series they hope will deliver them back to back flags. They may rest a player or two if they have any significant injuries but I can’t see them holding back too much, especially with a guaranteed 7 day break leading into the first final after this. The Hawthorn side is full of class, knows how to defend when they don’t have the ball and punishes sides like no other once they get on top. They are a true premiership contender and will make the Pies earn a finals spot.
TIP
The odds say that the Hawks are nigh on unbeatable this week but as we’ve seen already this season, and plenty of times in the past, upsets do happen. The Swans lost to GWS, and Fremantle lost to St Kilda so it’s not beyond the Magpies to cause the third huge upset of season 2014.
Of course the Hawks deserve to be favourites for this game, they are about to start a finals series where as the Pies, decimated by injuries, need to win just to be in those finals.
I just feel as if the desperate young Magpies, with more to prove and play for, may sneak across the line in a famous win for the Collingwood Football Club.
MAGPIES BY 2 POINTS.
Wednesday, August 27, 2014
Preview Round 23: Collingwood v Hawthorn
AFL
COLLINGWOOD has everything to play for as it tries to keep its season alive with a win over Hawthorn. A Magpies win and a Tigers loss to the Sydney Swans would see Collingwood make the finals for the ninth consecutive year. Even if the Magpies cause an upset over the Hawks, they will be sweating on the result of the Swans-Tigers Saturday night clash. A Richmond win would see Collingwood eliminated from the finals race. It's hard to see the Magpies taking down the Hawks, given they are decimated by injury and their opponents will be looking for a perfect tune-up on the eve of finals.
LAST FIVE TIMES
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 7 Max 21 Chance of rain 5%: <1mm Wind: SSW 13kph Betting: Collingwood $9.00 Hawthorn $1.07 |
LAST FIVE TIMES
- R14, 2014, Hawthorn 17.13 (115) d Collingwood 13.8 (86) at the MCG
- R21, 2013, Hawthorn 18.11 (119) d Collingwood 12.12 (84) at the MCG
- R3, 2013, Hawthorn 22.13 (145) d Collingwood 12.12 (84) at the MCG
- QF1, 2012, Hawthorn 20.15 (135) d Collingwood 15.7 (97) at the MCG
- R17, 2012, Hawthorn 21.12 (138) d Collingwood 13.13 (91) at the MCG
- Hawthorn has now won the past six clashes against the Magpies and seven of the past nine matches between the sides.
- Hawthorn uses handball more than any other side in the competition. The Hawks average 171.1 handballs per game, compared with the Magpies' 150.3 per game (ranked 14th).
- The Hawks remain the worst tackling side in season 2014, ranked 18th in the competition, averaging 61.2 per game. The Magpies fare much better, ranked with an average of 71.8.
- If Collingwood doesn't convert its opportunities, it could be in for a long night. The Hawks are the most accurate team in front of goal in the competition (56.8 per cent). The Magpies are 15th in the competition (46.8 per cent).
- Hawk forwards Luke Breust, Jarryd Roughead and Cyril Rioli combined for nine goals when Hawthorn defeated Collingwood by 29 points earlier this season.
- Jarryd Blair was Collingwood's top scoring player in Official AFL Player Ratings last round. Hawks midfielder Jordan Lewis is eighth in the competition for average points in the past month.
Tuesday, August 26, 2014
Injury List
Collingwood News
Brent Macaffer and Matthew Scharenberg’s seasons are over, but Dane Swan’s lives on.
That is the prognosis from Director of Football Rodney Eade, who told CollingwoodTV’s Blackmores Injury Update that Swan’s hamstring complaint, sustained during the win against Greater Western Sydney on the weekend, was back-related.
“Dane Swan is not as bad as first thought,” Eade said.
“He won’t play this week with a six-day break.
“It was just a bit of an overload in his hamstring. He was in a kicking motion and we think it’s more back-related – he’s had back issues this year – so we think that actually contributed to his tight hamstring.”
Like Swan, Clinton Young also damaged his hamstring in Saturday’s win.
He won’t play this week, but remains in the frame for a return should the Magpies qualify for the finals and progress deep into September.
“He normally plays 75 per cent game time because he’s such an explosive player,” Eade explained.
“He played 95 per cent the week before (against Brisbane) because we didn’t have any rotations.
“With the heavy ground, he was in that kicking motion and got pushed as he kicked a long kick, so we think all those factors contributed to him getting a strain.”
Sadly, Macaffer and Scharenberg’s seasons are over.
Both players ruptured their anterior cruciate ligaments (ACL) in the space of 24 hours on the weekend.
Fortunately, Macaffer’s injury was not a reoccurrence of the ACL tear he sustained in February 2012.
“There’s no other damage, which should enhance the recovery time. We’re hopeful that he can be nine months,” Eade said.
“He was very disappointed and down, as you’d imagine, but his spirits have lifted since and he’ll probably have an operation by maybe the end of the week or early next week."
Scharenberg’s injury is a devastating blow for both player and club, for he had worked diligently for several months to rehabilitate his foot injuries.
“He fought his way back from his feet but it was just a classic motion in an ACL injury that contributed to him going down in a corkscrew motion,” Eade said.
“He changed direction and his foot actually got stuck in the turf and didn’t release and he just did his ACL.
“People have said that he went off earlier with the injury but that’s not correct.
“He actually got a knock to the knee. It was fully tested so it was just an actual knock.
“He was completely stable. He did a lot of testing on it, went back on and played for another 15 minutes. Unfortunately it was just one of those things.
“People talk about our hamstrings but now we’ve had eight ACLs in the last three years so it’s probably an area, too, we need to look at to see whether it’s just bad luck or whether it’s anything that we can assist with within our program.”
Looking ahead to Friday's game, senior stars Jamie Elliott (hamstring) and Heritier Lumumba (corked thigh) will undergo fitness tests on their respective ailments later this week.
Injury List as of Tuesday 26 August 2014
Long-term injury list: Nathan Brown, Ben Hudson and Adam Oxley have been added to Collingwood's long-term injury list. Jack Frost, Corey Gault and Kyle Martin have been elevated from the rookie list as their replacements.
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 7 Max 19 Chance of rain 5%: <1mm Wind: S 13kph Betting: Collingwood $8.00 Hawthorn $1.08 |
That is the prognosis from Director of Football Rodney Eade, who told CollingwoodTV’s Blackmores Injury Update that Swan’s hamstring complaint, sustained during the win against Greater Western Sydney on the weekend, was back-related.
“Dane Swan is not as bad as first thought,” Eade said.
“He won’t play this week with a six-day break.
“It was just a bit of an overload in his hamstring. He was in a kicking motion and we think it’s more back-related – he’s had back issues this year – so we think that actually contributed to his tight hamstring.”
Like Swan, Clinton Young also damaged his hamstring in Saturday’s win.
He won’t play this week, but remains in the frame for a return should the Magpies qualify for the finals and progress deep into September.
“He normally plays 75 per cent game time because he’s such an explosive player,” Eade explained.
“He played 95 per cent the week before (against Brisbane) because we didn’t have any rotations.
“With the heavy ground, he was in that kicking motion and got pushed as he kicked a long kick, so we think all those factors contributed to him getting a strain.”
Sadly, Macaffer and Scharenberg’s seasons are over.
Both players ruptured their anterior cruciate ligaments (ACL) in the space of 24 hours on the weekend.
Fortunately, Macaffer’s injury was not a reoccurrence of the ACL tear he sustained in February 2012.
“There’s no other damage, which should enhance the recovery time. We’re hopeful that he can be nine months,” Eade said.
“He was very disappointed and down, as you’d imagine, but his spirits have lifted since and he’ll probably have an operation by maybe the end of the week or early next week."
Scharenberg’s injury is a devastating blow for both player and club, for he had worked diligently for several months to rehabilitate his foot injuries.
“He fought his way back from his feet but it was just a classic motion in an ACL injury that contributed to him going down in a corkscrew motion,” Eade said.
“He changed direction and his foot actually got stuck in the turf and didn’t release and he just did his ACL.
“People have said that he went off earlier with the injury but that’s not correct.
“He actually got a knock to the knee. It was fully tested so it was just an actual knock.
“He was completely stable. He did a lot of testing on it, went back on and played for another 15 minutes. Unfortunately it was just one of those things.
“People talk about our hamstrings but now we’ve had eight ACLs in the last three years so it’s probably an area, too, we need to look at to see whether it’s just bad luck or whether it’s anything that we can assist with within our program.”
Looking ahead to Friday's game, senior stars Jamie Elliott (hamstring) and Heritier Lumumba (corked thigh) will undergo fitness tests on their respective ailments later this week.
Injury List as of Tuesday 26 August 2014
| Name | Injury | Status |
| Marty Clarke | Illness | Test |
| Jamie Elliott | Hamstring | Test |
| Heritier Lumumba | Corked thigh | Test |
| Caolan Mooney | Ankle | Test |
| Alan Toovey | Groin | 1 week |
| Dane Swan | Hamstring | 1-2 weeks |
| Travis Cloke | Ankle | 3-4 weeks |
| Clinton Young | Hamstring | 3-4 weeks |
| Taylor Adams | Finger | Season |
| Dayne Beams | Knee | Season |
| Nathan Brown | Shoulder | Season |
| Nathan Freeman | Hamstring | Season |
| Ben Hudson | Shoulder | Season |
| Brent Macaffer | Knee | Season |
| Jonathon Marsh | Hamstring | Season |
| Adam Oxley | Ankle | Season |
| Ben Reid | Hamstring | Season |
| Matthew Scharenberg | Knee | Season |
| Nick Maxwell | Ankle | Retired |
Monday, August 25, 2014
The Finals: The Maths
Collingwood v Hawthorn
Friday August 29, 7.50pm MCG 7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm Weather: Min 7 Max 19 Chance of rain 5%: <1mm Wind: S 13kph Betting: Collingwood $8.00 Hawthorn $1.08 |
AFL Media examines what needs to happen for the Magpies to qualify for a ninth straight finals series.
9. COLLINGWOOD
44 points (11 wins, 10 losses) 97.4 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Hawthorn at the MCG
If the Magpies win next week:
- And Richmond loses to the Swans, they reach the finals for the ninth consecutive year - Their season ends if the Tigers win in Sydney
- Their finals streak ends at eight seasons - They can finish anywhere from ninth to 11th
A DETAILED LOOK AT POSITIONS 1 TO 12 HEADING INTO THE FINAL ROUND OF SEASON 2014
1. SYDNEY SWANS
68 points (17 wins, four losses) 145.1 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Richmond at ANZ Stadium
If the Swans win next week:
- They deliver their first minor premiership in 18 years
- They host a qualifying final regardless - They retain top spot if the Hawks lose, or if the Hawks win but fail to close their percentage gap to the Swans
- They slip to second if Hawthorn's margin is roughly 90 points better than the Swans'. For example, if the Hawks beat Collingwood by 60 points, the Swans would need to lose by at least 30 points
Predicted final match-up: Sydney Swans v Fremantle, first qualifying final, ANZ Stadium
2. HAWTHORN
64 points (16 wins, five losses) 138.3 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Collingwood at the MCG
If the Hawks win next week:
- And the Tigers defy the odds at ANZ Stadium, Hawthorn can claim a hat-trick of minor premierships
- They finish second if the Swans beat the Tigers
- Providing the Cats and Swans both win, Hawthorn and Geelong will meet in the finals for the fourth time in seven years
- They can finish as low as fourth if the Cats win and the Dockers thrash Port Adelaide - They hold onto second if the Lions and Power both win - They finish third in all other scenarios
Predicted final match-up: Hawthorn v Geelong, second qualifying final, MCG
3. GEELONG
64 points (16 wins, five losses) 110.8 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Brisbane Lions at Simonds Stadium
If the Cats win next week:
- And the Hawks win, it's status quo and the Cats finish third - They climb to second if the Magpies roll Hawthorn
- And Fremantle beats Port Adelaide, they finish fourth - They remain third if the Power win in Perth
Predicted final match-up: Hawthorn v Geelong, second qualifying final, MCG
4. FREMANTLE
60 points (15 wins, six losses) 131.9 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Port Adelaide at Patersons Stadium
If the Dockers win next week:
- And the Lions win in Geelong, they finish third - They can finish no lower than fourth - They earn a home qualifying final in the unlikely event that Geelong loses, Hawthorn loses, and Fremantle and Collingwood's combined winning margin is at least 90 points
- They finish fifth and host an elimination final
Predicted final match-up: Sydney Swans v Fremantle, first qualifying final, ANZ Stadium
5. PORT ADELAIDE
56 points (14 wins, seven losses) 132.4 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Fremantle at Patersons Stadium
If the Power win next week:
- They finish fourth, pocketing the double chance and an away qualifying final against the Swans or Hawthorn
- They host an elimination final at Adelaide Oval - They finish fifth unless they lose by around 20 goals and the Kangaroos beat Melbourne by a similar margin, in which case they slide to sixth - An elimination final Showdown is possible if Port finishes fifth and the Crows overhaul Richmond, Collingwood and West Coast
Predicted final match-up: Port Adelaide v West Coast, first elimination final, Adelaide Oval
6. NORTH MELBOURNE
52 points (13 wins, eight losses) 116.2 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Melbourne at Etihad Stadium
If the Kangaroos win next week:
- They earn a home elimination final - They finish sixth unless two extraordinary blowouts allow the Roos to close their 16-point percentage gap on Port Adelaide
- They play Essendon or Richmond in an elimination final - They finish sixth if Essendon loses, or if the Bombers win but fail to overtake North on percentage - They finish seventh (and Essendon sixth) if the Bombers win by around 75 points and North loses by a similar margin
Predicted final match-up: North Melbourne v Essendon, second elimination final, MCG
7. ESSENDON
48 points (12 wins, nine losses) 106.7 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Carlton at the MCG
If the Bombers win next week:
- They finish no lower than seventh - They can only climb to sixth if they thrash Carlton by a huge margin and North Melbourne is heavily beaten by the Demons
- They still qualify for finals if either Collingwood or Richmond loses, or if the Bombers maintain their superior percentage over either team - They finish seventh unless Richmond beats the Swans or Collingwood thrashes Hawthorn - They are near mathematical certainties to make the finals. However, pessimistic Bomber fans can consider the following scenario: they lose by 10 goals; the Tigers win; the Magpies demolish Hawthorn by 100 points
Predicted final match-up: North Melbourne v Essendon, second elimination final, MCG
8. RICHMOND
44 points (11 wins, 10 losses) 105.8 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Sydney Swans at ANZ Stadium
If the Tigers win next week:
- And Collingwood fails to beat Hawthorn by at least 120 points, they qualify for their second consecutive finals series
- It's prayer time. To make the finals they must hope Collingwood, Adelaide and West Coast all lose their round 23 games - They can finish as low as 11th - If exactly one of Collingwood, Adelaide and West Coast wins, the Tigers finish ninth
9. COLLINGWOOD
44 points (11 wins, 10 losses) 97.4 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Hawthorn at the MCG
If the Magpies win next week:
- And Richmond loses to the Swans, they reach the finals for the ninth consecutive year - Their season ends if the Tigers win in Sydney
- Their finals streak ends at eight seasons - They can finish anywhere from ninth to 11th
10. WEST COAST
40 points (10 wins, 11 losses) 114.7 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: Gold Coast at Metricon Stadium
If the Eagles win next week:
- They sneak into the finals if Richmond and Collingwood lose to the Swans and Hawks respectively, providing the Eagles also preserve their percentage advantage over Adelaide - They miss the finals if the Tigers or Magpies win - They miss the finals if they only narrowly beat the Suns while the Crows wallop St Kilda by at least 12 goals.
- They finish either 11th or 12th
Predicted final match-up: Port Adelaide v West Coast, first elimination final, Adelaide Oval
11. ADELAIDE
40 points (10 wins, 11 losses) 110.2 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: St Kilda at Adelaide Oval
If the Crows win next week:
- And the Tigers, Magpies and Eagles all lose, Adelaide qualifies for the finals - They would also finish eighth if Collingwood and Richmond lose but West Coast wins, providing the Crows beat St Kilda by enough to leapfrog the Eagles on percentage - They can finish as low as 11th
- They finish 11th or 12th
12. GOLD COAST
40 points (10 wins, 11 losses) 96.0 per cent
The run home: Rd 23: West Coast at Metricon Stadium
If the Suns win next week:
- They're in miracle territory to make the finals - They can finish eighth if they thrash the Eagles by a 100-point margin while Richmond, Collingwood and Adelaide all lose. The Tigers and Magpies must both lose heavily. - They can still finish as low as 11th
- They finish 12th, two places higher than their best finish in their three previous AFL seasons
2014 LADDER: ROUND 22
 |
| Pos Position C Change from last round P Played W Won L Lost D Drawn F Points for A Points against % Percentage Form Past five results Next Next opponent Pts Points |
Sunday, August 24, 2014
Round 22: Collingwood 75 GWS 67
COLLINGWOOD 2.3.15 5.5.35 7.7.49 11.9.75
GWS 3.4.22 6.6.42 8.11.59 9.13.67
SCORERS - Collingwood: Thomas (3.1), Broomhead (2.1), White (2.0), Williams (1.1), Blair (1.0), Sidebottom (1.0), Sinclair (1.0), Fasolo (0.2)
BEST - Collingwood: Thomas, Pendlebury, Broomhead, Williams, Armstrong, White
INJURIES - Collingwood: Young (hamstring), Swan (hamstring), Macaffer (knee)
SUBSTITUTES - Collingwood: Clinton Young replaced by Luke Ball in the second quarter
REPORTS - Collingwood: Nil
OFFICIAL CROWD: 10,851 at Spotless Stadium
| 1. Collingwood keeps September flame burning The Magpies' courageous come-from-behind win over the GWS Giants – the club did not hit the front until the 23-minute mark of the final term - puts the team inside the top eight with an 11-10 win-loss record, and keeps their finals hopes alive heading into next week's round 23 do-or-die clash with Hawthorn. Whether they stay there at the end of the weekend will depend on the outcome of Sunday's game at the MCG where Richmond goes for its eighth straight victory when it takes on St Kilda. 2. Injury toll keeps mounting for Magpies Builders may need to be called in for extensions to the Collingwood medical room after another horror weekend. Fresh from losing five players - Dayne Beams (knee), Travis Cloke (ankle), Heritier Lumumba (leg), Ben Reid (hamstring) and Alan Toovey (groin) - last Saturday night at the MCG, Sydney's Spotless Stadium offered little respite. Dane Swan and Clinton Young both suffered hamstring injuries in the second term, before the the club was down to just one interchange player when Brent Macaffer suffered a knee injury early in the second half. 3. Despite gallant effort Giants fail to add seventh name to list of vanquished The Magpies had thrashed the Giants in their only two prior meetings, winning by 40 points at the MCG in 2013 and 120 points at this venue in 2012. It was a far different story this afternoon though. The Giants were in front for all but the last eight or so minutes and looked very likely to add Collingwood to the list of teams they have beaten so far in their short history. Alas it was not to be. Entering Saturday afternoon's contest, GWS had beaten Melbourne (three times), the Brisbane Lions, Carlton, Port Adelaide, Gold Coast and cross-town rivals the Sydney Swans. |
4. Heath Shaw has come a long way Following in the footsteps of his father Ray, uncle Tony and brother Rhyce, Heath Shaw spent nine years at Collingwood, playing 179 games and helping the Pies to the 2010 flag. But it wasn't all smooth sailing, with the dashing defender ultimately shipped to GWS last year in a trade for Taylor Adams. But he has embraced a leadership role at the Giants with some gusto and capped his impressive career renaissance by captaining the side against Collingwood on Saturday. It must still be a strange feeling for the rest of the Shaw family, but Heath is now entrenched in GWS orange, white and charcoal. 5. Ross Oakley praises Sheedy in birth of Giants Former VFL/AFL chief executive Ross Oakley has likened the appointment of Kevin Sheedy as inaugural coach of the Giants to the time the Sydney Swans lured legend Ron Barassi up north. Oakley was a guest of the Giants at the pre-match president's function and told those present making Barassi coach was a key turning point for the Swans during what were very dark early years in the Harbour City. Oakley said Barassi gave the Swans "some credibility, as you have done with Kevin Sheedy". Oakley said Sydney had to have two teams, particularly given the importance of the Sydney market for the game's media rights. Builders may need to be called in for extensions to the Collingwood medical room after another horror weekend. Dane Swan and Clinton Young both suffered hamstring injuries in the second term, before the the club was down to just one interchange player when Brent Macaffer suffered a knee injury early in the second half. Builders may need to be called in for extensions to the Collingwood medical room after another horror weekend. |
| THE MEDIA | |
|
Bloodied, bruised and staggering on the ropes, an injury-ravaged Collingwood has somehow overcome Greater Western Sydney by eight points to keep its faint finals hopes alive. In an enthralling contest that belied the dreadful conditions, the Magpies overcome the loss of Brent Macaffer (knee), Dane Swan and Clinton Young (both hamstring) to seal a 11.9 (75) to 9.13 (67) triumph. The result lifts the Pies into eighth place ahead of next week's clash with Hawthorn, although Richmond will replace them if it gets past St Kilda at the MCG on Sunday. In front of 10,851 fans, the Giants' second biggest Spotless Stadium crowd this year, Josh Thomas' goal with less than six minutes remaining in the match remarkably gave the Pies the lead for the first time all game. Steele Sidebottom then added a late sealer as Collingwood kicked the final three goals of the match to steal the critical four points. With only one rotation on the bench from early in the third term, the victory would have to rate among the Pies' best in recent memory. Defeat was still cruel on the Giants, however, who led by as much as 21 points in the second term and were desperately unlucky to end up on the losing end of such a quality contest. GWS also had injury troubles of its own, with Phil Davis (calf) a late withdrawal, adding his name to fellow co-captain Callan Ward, Tom Scully, Jeremy Cameron, Lachie Whitfield and Jon Patton among the Giants' casualty ward. In the end the Pies' cool heads prevailed in the dying moments, led by the exceptional Thomas (29 touches, three goals). He was backed up by Scott Pendlebury (28 touches, nine clearances), Marley Williams (20 touches, seven inside 50s) and Tim Broomhead (23 touches, two goals) for the visitors. Toby Greene was brilliant for the Giants, picking up 27 touches to half-time and finishing with a career-best 42, also adding one goal and six inside 50s to his day's work. Devon Smith (23 touches, two goals), Josh Kelly (28 touches, six tackles) and Shane Mumford (46 hitouts, nine tackles) were all brilliant for the home side, which fell agonisingly short of its sixth win of a vastly improved 2014. The Giants were up for the contest from the first bounce, quickly registering the game's first three goals to establish an early 20-point lead. Collingwood finally kicked into gear late in the term, with Broomhead and Jesse White kicking majors to make it just a seven-point GWS lead at quarter-time. The second term then followed a similar script, with the Giants again dominating possession and kicking three more goals before the Pies responded once more. Broomhead and White were again prominent in the comeback, with Jarryd Blair's clever late effort off the ground from the goalsquare dragging the Pies back within seven points at half-time. The match was an absolute arm-wrestle from that point on, with both sides kicking two goals apiece in the third term as GWS enjoyed a 10-point edge heading into the final quarter. But four goals to one in the final quarter allowed Collingwood to seal a famous victory that keeps its season alive. Leon Cameron said during the week Collingwood were at their best with their backs to the wall, and he was proven right on Saturday night. With one of their most undermanned sides of recent years, the Magpies produced one of the most remarkable victories of the season to keep their faint finals hopes alive for one more week. Believe it or not, the Magpies are in the eight and still have a pulse, on a night where their injury problems reached crisis point. Already without 10 of their best 22, the Magpies lost Clinton Young, Dane Swan and Brent Macaffer, most probably all to season-ending injuries, but won a match they had no right to win. In a battle between two sides depleted by injury, it seemed the club with nothing to play for would prevail over the side playing for a September berth. It may all yet prove to be for naught for the Pies but at the very least their unheralded youngsters showed their supporters the future is still bright despite the doom which had descended upon the club in recent weeks. The Magpies did not find the lead until 22 minutes into the final term but once they hit the front they were determined to stay there. While they were ably led by Scott Pendlebury and Luke Ball, it was Josh Thomas, with three goals, Tim Broomhead and Marley Williams who answered their club's call. For the Giants, this was a lost opportunity - a game they should have won but found a way to lose. They controlled the game for much of the night and led by as much as 21 points in the second term. At one stage, the inexperienced Magpies defence, through a lack of know how more than any lack of effort, could not find a way out of their back half. Inevitably, the Giants conjured a goal, through Tom Boyd, who marked strongly on the lead. They were gifted another minutes later when Jarrod Witts and Tyson Goldsack spoilt each other deep in defence, allowing Josh Hunt an uncontested crumb. The Magpies now had every reason to roll over. They lost Clint Young to a hamstring strain and Dane Swan later in the quarter but, against the flow, jagged two goals in the last two minutes before half time to bridge the gap to seven points. The Pies were down to just one fit man on the bench a minute into the third quarter when Brent Macaffer's right knee buckled but, defying logic, then enjoyed their best period of the match. For about 15 minutes, the Magpies asked some tough questions of the Giants defence but, with Travis Cloke and Ben Reid missing, produced just one goal for their dominance. But the Giants' ability to hang tough for longer has been one of the reasons why they are no longer considered the easybeats of the competition. Their perseverance was rewarded with back-to-back goals entering time on to the impressive Toby Greene, the game's best on-baller, and Rhys Palmer. Logic said the Giants would now kick away but the whiff of September, however faint, proved intoxicating for the Magpies, who kicked the last goal of the third and the first one of the last term to pull within three points. After hitting the wood work twice, the Giants appeared to have the game iced when Will Hoskin-Elliott scored a goal from 50 but it was not the case. |
AN injury depleted Collingwood have staged a courageous comeback to beat the Giants by eight points and keep their finals hopes alive. With injury forcing three of their players out of the match from just after half time the Magpies dug deep to overcome a 21 point deficit mid-way through the second quarter. They trailed for almost the entire match before Josh Thomas put them in front at the 22-minute mark of the last quarter and Steele Sidebottom found the sealer minutes later. The black cat that crossed Nathan Buckley’s path last week followed him to Spotless Stadium. Clinton Young and Dane Swan had second quarter hamstring injuries and then Brent Macaffer went down early in the third with a serious knee injury. But unlike last week when they lost to Brisbane by 67 points, his team was able to fight the game out and find a way to win. Toby Greene won a staggering 42 possessions and kicked a goal but his huge effort wasn’t enough for the Giants who struggled to find a target up forward with Jonathon Patton and Jeremy Cameron on the sidelines. Last year’s number one draft pick Tom Boyd struggled all night touching the ball only three times. In just his second game, James Stewart, son of former Collingwood player Craig, had two second half shots at goal which hit the post and could potentially have won the match. Shane Mumford battled on manfully against two young opponents in Jarrod Witts and Brodie Grundy but the loss of Callan Ward to a calf injury proved costly. It wasn’t a showpiece of the games skills but the 10,851 in attendance saw a match as hard fought as any this season. The Magpies made six changes to the team which were beaten by the Lions by 67 points, five of those were forced by injury but importantly they had their captain Scott Pendlebury back in action. Phil Davis was a late withdrawal due to last week’s concussion and he was quickly joined on the injury list by Jono O’Rourke just 22 minutes into the first quarter when he pulled a hamstring as he ran through the interchange area. Goals to Mark Whiley,Tom Bugg and Devon Smith were pegged back by Tim Broomhead and Jesse White to close the gap to seven points at quarter time. The Giants jumped out again in the second term with Boyd and veteran Josh Hunt snaring the opening goals before White and Broomhead kicked their second goals and Jarryd Blair’s soccer off the deck brought the margin back to seven points. Thomas snared the important first goal of the last quarter for the Magpies before Will Hoskin-Elliott stretched the lead back to 10 points. In the end Scott Pendlebury’s class and experience through the midfield proved the difference as the Magpies kicked the last three goals of the game through Thomas, Ben Sinclair and Sidebottom. When the long injury lists of both clubs were tallied there wasn’t much difference between the teams. The Giants perhaps were without Davis, Callan Ward, Jon Patton, Lachie Whitfield, Tom Scully, Tim Mohr, Jeremy Cameron, Stephen Coniglio, Nick Haynes and Curtly Hampton. The Magpies were without Travis Cloke, Heritier Lumumba, Alan Toovey, Dayne Beams, Taylor Adams and Ben Reid. COLLINGWOOD players were reduced to tears at three-quarter time on Saturday after tagger Brent Macaffer suffered another serious knee injury. The club suspects Macaffer ruptured the anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee after twisting his knee during an innocuous moment in the third term of the eight-point win over GWS. He left the field immediately aided by trainers. Macaffer missed the 2012 season after rupturing an ACL in his left knee. "I really felt for Macaffer in particular,” Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley said after the club's gutsy eight-point win over the Giants in Sydney. "When you go to the three-quarter time huddle and you can see some of his teammates in tears because they know what's happened and they know what he's been through ... that tells you something about the make-up of our playing group. "The supporters of the club should rest assured that you have got a young senior group and a young up-and-coming talented group that are absolutely committed to this footy club and doing whatever they can to make a success of it." Collingwood’s injury crisis deepened further with Dane Swan and Clinton Young both suffering hamstring injuries against the Giants. The pair is unlikely to face Hawthorn next Friday night at the MCG in a game the Magpies must win to play finals. The Pies are already reeling from injuries to Dayne Beams (knee), Travis Cloke (ankle), Heritier Lumumba (leg), Ben Reid (hamstring) and Alan Toovey (groin). Collingwood sits inside the eight with an 11-10 win-loss record. Despite the long list of players unavailable, Buckley rebuffed suggestions the team that would face Hawthorn might one of be the weakest to take the field in black-and-white in recent memory. "If the majority of these blokes that played tonight are playing I wouldn't call it the weakest because they just displayed some real grit and endeavour," Buckley said. "Regardless of what our injury profile looks like we will take the 22 fittest player onto the field and if we show the heart that we showed tonight we will give ourselves a chance. "If we win next week we play finals." Asked whether the interchange needed to be expanded Buckley said: "I think four interchange would be handy. I don't know if you'd need any more than that." "When you go to the three-quarter time huddle and you can see some of his (Macaffer's) teammates in tears because they know what's happened and they know what he's been through ... that tells you something about the make-up of our playing group. The supporters of the club should rest assured that you have got a young senior group and a young up-and-coming talented group that are absolutely committed to this footy club and doing whatever they can to make a success of it."
|
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)