Wednesday, May 06, 2015

Preview Round 6: Collingwood v Geelong

AFL

SUMMARY

Collingwood v Geelong
Friday May 8, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 10 Max 17
Chance of rain 70%: < 1mm
Wind: WNW 28kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.72
Geelong $2.10
Many pundits are already announcing the end of Geelong's long run of finals appearances, and a loss to the young Pies on Friday night would only strengthen such bleak forecasts.
However, the Cats' greater big-game experience and perhaps overall talent should prove pivotal. The most impressive aspect of the Magpies' performance so far this season has been their desperation, pressure, discipline and defensive mechanisms that have made them difficult to score against.
They have been superb over the past fortnight in huge, emotion-charged clashes against Essendon on Anzac Day and old enemy Carlton in former coach Mick Malthouse's milestone game, and the Cats will be poised to capitalise on the slightest sign of letdown or blockbuster fatigue.

PAST FIVE TIMES
  1. R3, 2014, Geelong 12.15 (87) d Collingwood 11.10 (76) at the MCG
  2. R8, 2013, Collingwood 15.12 (102) d Geelong 14.12 (96) at the MCG
  3. R16, 2012, Collingwood 17.8 (110) d Geelong 10.19 (79) at the MCG
  4. R8, 2012, Collingwood 14.12 (96) d Geelong 11.18 (84) at the MCG
  5. GF, 2011, Geelong 18.11 (119) d Collingwood 12.9 (81) at the MCG
THE SIX POINTS
  1. Collingwood is the No.1 contested-possession team this year, averaging 157.2 a game compared to Geelong's 125.6, ranked last.
  2. No team has kicked the ball less this year than the Cats, who are ranked last with 186.2 kicks a game, compared to the Magpies, who are ranked sixth with 209.2 a game.
  3. Both teams have struggled in the clearances so far in 2015; Geelong is ranked 18th averaging 31.8 while Collingwood is 17th with 38.8 per game.
  4. Collingwood has won three of the past four contests between the sides, but since 2010 nothing separates the sides with five wins each. Three of the past four have been decided by two goals or less.
  5. This will be the 43rd time these teams have played at the MCG and the Cats hold a narrow advantage winning 23 games to 19.
  6. Collingwood's superstar skipper Scott Pendlebury has claimed the No.1 mantle in the Official AFL Player Ratings after maintaining a typically high level of performance while Gold Coast counterpart Gary Ablett tries to overcome a shoulder injury. Meanwhile, Cats captain Joel Selwood remains in third position while veteran teammate Steve Johnson has fallen to No. 26.
IT'S A BIG WEEK FOR …
Steve Johnson. The Geelong genius suffered the indignity of being handed the substitute's vest a fortnight ago and uncharacteristically butchered the ball early last week. Stevie J's indifferent form has left many wondering whether he erred in rejecting a fat, last-minute offer from Greater Western Sydney during last year's trade period. The soon-to-be 32-year-old will be desperate to show the footy public he is far from a spent force.

PREDICTION: Geelong by 15 points

Monday, May 04, 2015

Elliott Signs For Three Years

REAL FOOTY

Collingwood v Geelong
Friday May 8, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 11 Max 17
Chance of rain 70%: < 1mm
Wind: NW 28kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.72
Geelong $2.10
Collingwood fan favourite Jamie Elliott believes there is no reason why the Magpies can't have a "crack" at the premiership this season, as club president Eddie McGuire again urges his team to dare to dream.
Enjoying life in second spot on the ladder, the Magpies had further good news on Monday when Elliott, 22, confirmed he had signed a three-year contract extension, ensuring he remains at the club until the end of 2018.
Elliott, with nine goals this season and a key component of the Magpies' fierce defensive pressure inside their attacking 50, said he had not given any thought to joining another club.
"Three years is plenty for me to see how I go individually but, team wise, we are not getting hyped up about how we are at the moment," he said. "But we are looking very positive and the environment around the club is very good as well.
"In our pre-season – the NAB Challenge – we were a bit shaky and that's where the media jumped on board and wanted to say that we weren't going to do too well this year.
"But we have stuck to how Bucks [coach Nathan Buckley] wants us to play and, if we continue to do that and bring pressure to the game, and fix up and tidy up the little things, we are going to, hopefully, have a really good crack this year and then the next couple of years.
"With the youngsters, and I am one of them, hopefully we develop really quickly and it's going to be successful."
That pressure Elliott has spoken about has resulted in the Magpies conceding just 12 goals in the past fortnight in wins over arch-rivals Essendon and Carlton.
The Pies face another test when they confront Geelong on Friday night, before the fixture potentially opens up again with struggling Richmond and Gold Coast.
McGuire wouldn't buy into suggestions this season had the feel of the unexpected rise of 2002 when the Magpies reached the grand final, but that could change should their good form continue.
Buoyant from securing another major sponsor, La Trobe Financial, McGuire re-iterated his pre-season stance that this was a year when the Magpies could "pinch" what would be a 16th premiership.
"This is the year that any one can pinch it, that there are opportunities and Collingwood needed to approach the year not as if we are young players and looking to the future," he said. "Tomorrow doesn't come in football. You have got to make it happen.
"It's early days yet. But you look at what the Western Bulldogs are doing, you look at some of the more established sides like Hawthorn and Port Adelaide and Fremantle, Sydney, of course, are there. There are opportunities for everybody.
"Teams will come up and down, we all know what happens with injuries. We have had a horror run with injuries in the past three years. With a little bit of luck, I always believed we were there.
"Collingwood is always in contention. Am I surprised? No. Am I delighted? Yes. Is there a long way to go? You better believe it."
The high-marking Elliott, whose No. 5 guernsey is one of the club's top sellers, also believes there is a long way to go in his career, and he hopes this will allow him eventually to spend more time in the midfield.
"If I am looking at the bigger picture, I definitely want to take my game to the next level, and that's where I see my game going," he said.
"At the moment, I don't mind sitting in the forward 50 to be honest. With a few more pre-seasons, hopefully, I can get fitter because it doesn't come naturally to me. So, hopefully, two or three more pre-seasons, I'll get some strong runs in, and then I'll run out the game better and, hopefully, play in the midfield."
Elliott is also clearly one of McGuire's favourites. "He plays the game the way we all wish we used to play it," he said.
                                          
Collingwood News

To mark Jamie Elliott’s three-year contract extension, Collingwood Media looks at five facts behind the man in the famous No. 5 jumper.

The story so far
A small forward with incredible strength and speed, Elliott marks unbelievably well for his size.
His style of play has seen comparisons drawn with Paul Medhurst and Stephen Milne, but it is through his tackling and defensive work in attack that he has impressed his coaches.
In just over 50 games, Elliott has already enjoyed some big outings, none more memorable than his five goal haul against Carlton in 2013, although many may argue his Mark of the Year against Port Adelaide was even better.
Having slotted a career-high 33 goals in 2014, Elliott still appears to have much improvement still left in him and is rightly considered one of Collingwood's most exciting young prospects.

Five facts about our No. 5
1. He hails from Euroa
Elliott grew up in Euroa, a township boasting a population of 3,166 as per the 2011 Census. Located in Victoria’s north-east, it is situated midway between Melbourne and Albury. Appropriately, the town’s football team is known as the Euroa Magpies and plays in the Goulburn Valley Football League.
2. He played for Collingwood before he was actually playing for Collingwood
Make sense? Probably not. Let us explain.
The VFL has a rule allowing clubs to add top-up players from the TAC Cup to their teams during the home and away season. Collingwood’s VFL affiliation with the Murray Bushrangers allowed it to choose Elliott as a top-up player for two games midway through 2010.
Who would have thought that the teenager with the blond tips who ran out alongside Josh Fraser, Paul Medhurst, Shane O’Bree and Jarryd Blair out at Box Hill and Victoria Park would eventually become one of the stars of the show?
3. He has worn three numbers in four years
Several players end up changing numbers as they make the transition from young tyro to senior footballer.
But rare are those who wear three numbers – in four years, no less.
Elliott started in the No. 35 before progressing to No. 19 when Cameron Wood departed ahead of the 2013 season. At the end of 2014, Elliott was approached by the retiring Nick Maxwell, who was keen to ensure the famous No. 5 stayed on one of the club’s most popular backs.
Elliott now follows in the footsteps of Maxwell, Nathan Buckley and Ron McKeown as those to wear the No. 5 in recent times.
4. Don’t confuse him with Jamie Elliott
Long before our Jamie Elliott burst onto the scene, there was another footballer of the same name making waves in the AFL.
Jamie Elliott played 58 games for Fitzroy, Richmond and St Kilda between 1991 and 1996. Touted by then-Roys coach Robert Shaw as a potential future captain, Elliott was beset by injuries. His career finished at Moorabbin in 1998 and he went on to play and coach in country Victoria.
5. He rarely misses
In Elliott’s first season, he kicked six goals and 11 behinds.
In his 42 games since, he has bagged 72.31 with hauls of five in each of the past two years.

2015 LADDER: ROUND 5

Saturday, May 02, 2015

Round 5: Collingwood 120 Carlton 45

COLLINGWOOD   4.4.28   8.9.57   14.11.95   18.12.120
CARLTON               1.1.7    2.3.15       5.6.36        6.9.45

SCORERS - Collingwood: Cloke (2.3), Elliott (2.3), Pendlebury (2.1), Oxley (1.3), Crisp (1.1), Adams (1.0), Blair (1.0), Dwyer (1.0), Gault (1.0), Goldsack (1.0), Grundy (1.0), Karnezis (1.0), Swan (1.0), Varcoe (1.0), White (1.0)

BEST - Collingwood: Pendlebury, Oxley, Swan, Elliott, Grundy, Crisp, Adams

INJURIES - Collingwood: Seedsman (hip)

SUBSTITUTES - Collingwood: Paul Seedsman replaced by Patrick Karnezis in the third quarter

REPORTS: Nil

OFFICIAL CROWD: 71,759 at the MCG







1. Mick's dark night
The celebrations for Mick Malthouse's record-breaking game reached a crescendo minutes before the bounce on Friday night when he walked onto a darkened MCG with his wife, four children and five grandchildren. He walked off the ground briskly through a guard of honour once it was all over. Earlier, Malthouse was honoured at the Blues' president's function, rebuilding bridges with guest Eddie McGuire and his former club Collingwood. He was lauded pre-match on all radio broadcasts, with Dale Thomas saying he hopes the coach is re-signed by the Blues, and sidekick Rob Wiley saying Malthouse still had the fire in his belly for the job. There were even fireworks at half time, but unfortunately for the occasion, Malthouse's team barely fired a shot in the 75-point loss.
2. Carlton drought
There is a worrying trend emerging for the 1-4 Blues, who kicked just one goal in each of the first two quarters on Friday night, going long periods without scoring. It wasn't the first time this season their scoring had dried up. In round one they went goalless in the third quarter against Richmond, in round two they had a goalless second quarter against West Coast, and in round four St Kilda restricted them to just one goal in the first quarter. The second quarter against Collingwood would have been painful to watch for Carlton supporters as their team struggled to lay a hand on the Magpies, laying 12 tackles to 29.    
3. Seedsman cut down
After winning the Anzac Day Medal last Saturday for his brilliant performance against Essendon, Collingwood's Paul Seedsman shaped as a danger man against the Blues. Still, he was given free rein in the first quarter and racked up nine possessions and five inside 50s. Tagger Ed Curnow was deployed to shut him down after quarter-time, and did a good job before an apparent left hip injury ended Seedsman's night. The attacking half-back was substituted in the third quarter and immediately iced his hip.
4. A doctor in the house
There was a surprise guest in the Carlton coach's box on Friday night, with doctor Geoffrey Edelsten taking a seat in the back row. The explanation? Edelsten is a member of corporate coterie group, which has a different member in the coach's box most weeks. Born in Carlton, Edelsten was awarded life membership of the club in 2013. He is the former owner of the Sydney Swans.
5. Hendo hamstrung
Carlton forward Lachie Henderson looked off his game early, and it soon became apparent why. The key tall played forward and lacked opportunities, but he entered quarter-time without a stat. By half time he still hadn't touched the ball with just a tackle to his name. That's where it finished when he was substituted early in the third quarter, immediately applying ice to his right hamstring. With tall forward Levi Casboult dropped, the Blues were relying on a big contribution from Henderson, who finished third in their best and fairest in 2013. 

THE MEDIA

Collingwood has cruised to its third straight victory, spoiling the milestone night of former coach Mick Malthouse with a 75-point thumping of a lacklustre Carlton at the MCG on Friday night.
Malthouse coached his 715th VFL/AFL game to break a record set by former Collingwood coach Jock McHale that had stood for 66 years, but the triple-premiership mentor had little to smile about as the Pies ran rampant in the 18.12 (120) to 6.9 (45) result.
Collingwood improved its record to 4-1 for the season and continued to take advantage of a favourable early draw, with three of those wins coming over St Kilda, the Brisbane Lions and Carlton, teams unlikely to figure in finals contention this season.
While Carlton could be forgiven for being totally outclassed, its effort was again found wanting.
The Blues were beaten in possessions (375-297) but also tackles (81-47), and looked a dysfunctional outfit as they slumped to 1-4.
On the flipside, the Magpies continued their impressive form under Malthouse's protege Nathan Buckley, with their fourth win built on the back of seven unanswered majors either side of half-time.
ANZAC Day Medallist Paul Seedsman continued his stellar start to the year for the Pies before he was substituted with a suspected left hip problem in the third quarter, while skipper Scott Pendlebury (32 touches and two goals) racked up possessions at will.
After starting the week in a moon boot, Dane Swan shrugged off ankle concerns and improved as the match went on, with strong support from Adam Oxley.
The party-pooping Pies had winners all over the ground, but Carlton struggled to find a single player who convincingly beat his man.
Tom Bell and last round's AFL Rising Star nominee Patrick Cripps had a crack, while Sam Rowe battled manfully on inaccurate Pies spearhead Travis Cloke (2.3).
But there were few other contributors, with the horror night summed up by last week's five-goal hero Lachie Henderson held statless by Jack Frost before he was substituted with a suspected hamstring issue in the third term.
Apart from Carlton's dismal effort, the evening's talking point came during a pre-game function, when Malthouse shook hands and appeared to call a truce with Eddie McGuire after the master coach's acrimonious split from the Pies at the end of 2011.
Malthouse led Collingwood in 264 games and to the 2010 flag, after his coaching journey started at Footscray (132 games) in 1984 and continued at West Coast, where he won the '92 and '94 premierships during a 218-game stint.
Fittingly, Malthouse received a rousing reception from both clubs' supporters when he and his family led the Blues onto the darkened MCG before the match.
But with the formalities over, his attention quickly turned to upsetting his former club.
Malthouse had never beaten the Pies in four previous attempts as Carlton coach, and there were worrying signs from the moment key defender Michael Jamison (calf) was a late withdrawal.
After kicking only two goals in the first half, Carlton did little to save face after the main break, and plenty of the 71,759 supporters had left when Malthouse was clapped from the ground by a guard of honour after the final siren.
He will have to search for win number 407 (McHale won 467) against the bottom-placed Brisbane Lions at Etihad Stadium in round six, while the Pies return to the MCG next Friday night against Geelong.
                           

A victorious Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley has declared that his emerging team ''has a long way to go'' in 2015 despite the major steps they have taken early this season.
Buckley said the Magpies had ''some momentum'' and had backed up their Anzac Day game with a strong and efficient performance against Carlton, whom the Pies thrashed by 75 points on Friday night. But he said there was significant growth in the side.
''We've got a long way to go. We've got a real long way to go. But the steps we've taken early this season have been strong. The tests keep coming,'' Buckley said following Collingwood's clinical dismantling of a dismal Carlton in Mick Malthouse's record-breaking 715th game as a senior coach.
The Collingwood coach was pleased that the Pies had used ball better than in previous games this year against the Blues. ''Our tackle efficiency was really high....clearly our efficiency with the ball in hand tonight was our best performance this year, probably our best performance for a couple of years really, we really controlled the ball well, created 58 inside-50 entries and..scored at over 50 per cent.''
Buckley was not concerned about players getting carried away with their position — the Pies are 4-1 — and was pleased they had retained application after a strong Anzac Day effort. ''The game itself caps it.... we've started well and there are lot of positive signs. We've got some momentum but I thought the response tonight off the back of Anzac Day shows that our players were able to absorb a really strong performance against a rated opponent and still apply themselves to their preparation and then come out tonight and play a really strong brand of footy... we've got a long way to go. We've got a lot of growth in us.''
Buckley said Paul Seedsman, who had been among the better players prior to being subbed out with a gluteal injury, had been taken off as a precaution. ''In the end it was precautionary. He wasn't 100 per cent, we didn't want to risk him any further.'' The coach praised his defence, which ''worked well together.''
Buckley said the Pies could improve in centre bounces — they lost lost centre breaks 19-9 — though they booted 10 goals to two from clearances. ''Centre bounce was the only place we weren't able to control clearances.''
He said Dane Swan, who had his foot in a moon boot during the week, ''did remarkably well'' to recover and it was ''testament to his professionalism'' that he managed to play. ''The players are really clear if they are not 100 per cent they don't put their hand up.''
Buckley called his old coach Malthouse's record-breaking achievement ''massive'' and said he couldn't see the record being broken. ''Mick speaks about holding on to the baton for someone else. I can't see that happening. You know, the game's changed so much, I can't see anyone coaching for 30 years.
''He's been a survivor for a long time Mick and I think it's due credit to him that he's received all of those accolades during the week.''

MOVE over Gary Ablett, the AFL has a new No.1 player.
Courtesy of his best-on-ground display against Carlton on Friday night, Collingwood skipper Scott Pendlebury has assumed the mantle as the competition's best footballer, according to the Official AFL Player Ratings.
Pendlebury was simply outstanding in his side's 75-point belting of the Blues, racking up 32 touches, winning five clearances and booting two majors.
It was more than enough to see him leapfrog Gold Coast champion Ablett, who is still on the sidelines with a shoulder injury, and claim the No.1 ranking.
It is the first time in more than three years that Ablett has been dethroned.
Pendlebury started the match just 10.1 points in arrears but easily reeled in the deficit.
His 18.3-point performance propelled him to 683.7 points, comfortably clear of Ablett on 675.6.
The Official AFL Player Ratings are based on a player's past 40 games, delivering a long-term view of a player's standing within the AFL.
A player's rating is determined by aggregating his points tally based on a rolling window of the previous two seasons, with more recent matches given a greater weighting than games earlier in the 40-game window.
This creates a buffer for players missing matches through injury, suspension, omission or by not being involved in finals.
But Ablett would want to hurry back soon. His former teammate, Geelong skipper Joel Selwood, is breathing down his neck, just 40 points behind in third place before playing in round five against Richmond.
                               


CRISP, Ramsay, Seedsman, Oxley. Significantly, it was Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley’s young pack who enhanced their standings.
On this record-smashing night, Buckley’s boys were pivotal performers to humble traditional foe Carlton in front of 71,759 fans at the MCG.
Jack Crisp found as much of the ball-efficiency as his run-with opponents Marc Murphy and Chris Judd while Jackson Ramsay, Paul Seedsman and Adam Oxley carved up the Blues with run and rebound so embarrassingly absent from the outclassed Navy Blues.
Who would have bargained on this fixture, hand-picked by the exalted Mick Malthouse, degenerating into a massive 75 points percentage boost for his old club? And what a stunning endorsement for his Magpie counterpart’s new breed.
Like Jack Frost who didn’t give Blues forward Lachie Henderson a touch of the leather in this monumental mismatch under the damning glare of the tower lights, not to mention the TV cameras.
Malthouse and his assistants could never corral Collingwood captain Scott Pendlebury who lit the way for his eager young teammates. And Dane Swan made a mockery of his foot ailment doubts with a typical hard-running performance. There were ample helpers too from a host of players nurtured and developed under Buckley’s watch.
In the end the Magpies were lining up to get on the scoresheet — a staggering 15 of them contributing to the goal tally.
Collingwood players oozed superior desperation as well as decision-making. Like little Jamie Elliott, outnumbered two to one, fighting to trap the ball near the 50m arc midway through the second term.
While the Magpies found time and space to identify and hit a moving teammate, the Blues had little system going forward. Too often, it was the old-fashioned bang-it-on-the-boot that became easy pickings for Collingwood’s back half. Carlton’s 70s style approach produced an astonishing three uncontested marks to Collingwood’s 28 in the second quarter.
Any remote hope of a Carlton second half fightback disappeared when Henderson, who kicked five goals in the Anzac Day victory in Wellington, was subbed out with a left hamstring injury in the opening minutes after the resumption.
Goals from Jesse White, who was able to run to the line, Travis Cloke, from a mark on the edge of the goal square, and the overworked Crisp completed a run of seven in a row to stretch the lead past 60 points until Kade Simpson snapped that sequence 11 minutes into the third term.
Admittedly, Carlton’s night didn’t start well with shoulder soreness forcing key defender Michael Jamison to be a late withdrawal, replaced by ruckman Rob Warnock.
The Blues tried to stretch Collingwood’s defence by starting Cameron Wood up forward while Warnock handled the ruck duties.
It provided almost an instant success when Wood converted for the opening goal after a contested mark right on the line between the goal and behind posts after just two minutes.
But the Magpies settled far quicker with goals from Jarryd Blair, Oxley, Tyson Goldsack and Sam Dwyer establishing an early scoreboard buffer that kept stretching and stretching and stretching.
A damning measure of the intensity was Carlton’s 25 tackles in the lopsided first half — compared to double that tally by Collingwood.
Henderson trudged in to the rooms at half-time with just one stat, a tackle. It reflected the disappointing response by the Blues that rendered such an important occasion memorable for all the wrong reasons.
                           

''
 We've got a long way to go. We've got a real long way to go. But the steps we've taken early this season have been strong. The tests keep coming. Our tackle efficiency was really high....We've got some momentum but I thought the response tonight off the back of Anzac Day shows that our players were able to absorb a really strong performance against a rated opponent and still apply themselves to their preparation and then come out tonight and play a really strong brand of footy... we've got a long way to go. We've got a lot of growth in us.
''
Nathan Buckley

Thursday, April 30, 2015

Round 5: The Team

Collingwood v Carlton
Friday May 1, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 7 Max 21
Chance of rain 20%: < 1mm
Wind: E 18kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.50
Carlton $2.60
B: Alan Toovey, Nathan Brown, Marley Williams
HB: Tom Langdon, Jack Frost, Tyson Goldsack
C: Paul Seedsman, Dane Swan, Jack Crisp
HF: Jamie Elliott, Jesse White, Travis Varcoe
F: Corey Gault, Travis Cloke, Jarryd Blair
Foll: Brodie Grundy, Taylor Adams, Scott Pendlebury
Int: Sam Dwyer, Jackson Ramsay, Patrick Karnezis, Adam Oxley
Emg: Jarrod Witts, Jonathon Marsh, Jordan De Goey

IN: Patrick Karnezis
OUT: Tim Broomhead (illness)

Fast Fact
It's a good thing Dane Swan's been declared fit to play. He averages 28.76 disposals in 21 games against Carlton and has not missed a game against the Navy Blues since round three, 2005.



Collingwood has made just one change ahead of Friday night’s blockbuster against Carlton, but, fortunately, it doesn’t involve Dane Swan.
Instead, Patrick Karnezis has been recalled for his second game in the Black and White, replacing Tim Broomhead who will miss with illness.
Swan has been named in the centre after passing a fitness test on his injured ankle on Thursday morning.
“I was a bit sore after last week’s game it’s all about rehab and managing my body and making sure I was right to go,” Swan told CollingwoodTV’s Team Sheet.
“I was trying to do all the right things and tick all the right boxes to prove to the coach that I could play this week and that’s what I’ve done.”
Swan has not missed a game between the two arch rivals since April 2005.
Karnezis, meanwhile, slots straight back into the senior line up after being squeezed out of the side ahead of the ANZAC Day triumph.
The 23-year-old responded well, gathering 29 disposals and taking seven marks in Sunday’s loss to Essendon in the VFL.
“Patty K impacted the game really well,” Development Coach Tarkyn Lockyer told Collingwood Media.
“He had 29 disposals and was really creative with his ball use and was really solid in the air as well.”
Karnezis replaces Broomhead who will miss with illness after featuring prominently in each of the past three senior games.
Ruckman Jarrod Witts remains in the frame for a senior return, named as an emergency for the second consecutive week.
He is joined by Jordan De Goey and the untried Jonathon Marsh as the men on standby.
A total of nine players are absent from Collingwood’s last meeting with Carlton back in round 15 last season.
The match will take on even greater significance, for it marks the occasion on which Mick Malthouse will break Jock McHale’s record for the most VFL/ AFL games coached (714).
The Magpies have not lost to the Blues since 2012.

Preview Round 5: Collingwood v Carlton

Collingwood News - David Natoli

Collingwood v Carlton
Friday May 1, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 7 Max 21
Chance of rain 20%: < 1mm
Wind: E 18kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.50
Carlton $2.60
Round five of the 2015 season kicks off on Friday night between the competition’s oldest and most traditional rivals Collingwood and Carlton.
Whilst this rivalry has never needed any extra spice to attract interest, there is no doubt that in recent years there has been an extra element of tension amongst fans given the defection of Mick Malthouse and Dale Thomas to Carlton.
Though the fans have all finally moved on, this year’s clash will again bring with it an extra layer of interest considering Malthouse will break Jock McHale’s record of coaching the most games in league history. It is a remarkable achievement and one I sincerely congratulate him on.
While the build-up will focus a lot on Malthouse’s record-breaking night, once the ball is bounced all the attention will go back onto the four points which are on offer. Both sides desperately need the win.
For the Magpies, a 3-1 start to the year has the side in third spot on the ladder. The wins are yet to come against the real powerhouses of the competition, but it has still been an impressive start to the year and many footy experts are beginning to take notice of this new look Magpie side.
The experienced players such as Scott Pendlebury, Dane Swan and Alan Toovey have all been terrific, but it has been the youthful mix in the side which would be the most pleasing element of Collingwood’s early season form.
Not many tipped the Magpies to win on ANZAC Day last weekend, but the win will count for little if the team is to lose against the lower ranked Carlton this weekend. Collingwood has the opportunity to move to four wins and one loss and really set the season up nicely.
On the other hand, Carlton’s season has reached a really defining point. After losing the opening three games, the Blues were able to notch up their first win last weekend against St Kilda in New Zealand.
The Saints remain favourites for the wooden spoon, but the win was vital nonetheless. Carlton will now be full of confidence ahead of this week’s match against its bitter rival and will sense an opportunity to pinch a second win. A win will get the season back on track and silence a lot of doubters. A loss, however, will firmly entrench the Blues in the bottom four and will leave the season hanging by a thread.
It’s a crucial match for both teams and the intensity will be high from the opening bounce. Both sides have excelled in the early parts of this year in contested footy. The Magpies are ranked first in the competition in this area, and the Blues are also ranked highly in sixth and should welcome back Chris Judd to strengthen this area further. This will undoubtedly be a key statistic again on Friday night.
In regards to weather, the forecast is looking very positive at the moment so we should see great conditions for football. The Magpies will need to adjust from the wet weather they played in last week.

Recent History
Collingwood has won the past four encounters against Carlton, and Malthouse is yet to chalk up a victory against his former protégé.
These sides last met in a scrappy affair in round 15 last season when Collingwood was victorious by 15 points. Steele Sidebottom was the standout with 33 disposals and two goals, polling the three Brownlow votes. Pendlebury continued his good form against Carlton, with 24 disposals, two goals and 11 tackles, earning him the two votes. Chris Yarran was Carlton’s standout with 23 disposals and running rampant off the half back line.

At the Selection Table
Collingwood should enjoy a relatively stable week at selection with no major injuries to the senior side from the weekend. Dane Swan has been spotted in a moonboot at training and it has since been revealed that he suffered a minor ankle injury. A final call will be made on him following Thursday training.
While the VFL side lost on the weekend, the form of Jordan De Goey, Clinton Young, Patrick Karnezis and Jarrod Witts would have impressed coach Nathan Buckley. Witts in particular may be a chance to come into the side as an extra tall option.
De Goey and Karnezis are right on the cusp of selection and will be available if Swan is left out, whilst Young will need a few more weeks at VFL level to build his fitness.
In disappointing news, Darcy Moore and Tony Armstrong sustained injuries. Moore has been the emergency for the AFL side in the last two weeks, meaning his hamstring injury is a blow. In more positive news, Matt Scharenberg looks set to return to the VFL team this week as he continues his recovery from an ACL injury. Ben Kennedy should also return from a virus.
Carlton will welcome back Chris Judd after he was rested from the St Kilda game with a minor calf complaint. Troy Menzel also should pass a fitness test and be available for selection. They are two vital selections for the Blues as they adds real x-factor to the side. Judd may give a real edge in the contested football battle as well.
Matthew Kreuzer also looks set to return to VFL level, which will give the side a boost, while Dale Thomas continues his recovery from a shoulder injury. Chris Yarran is the other who will miss this week’s game as he serves his three week suspension. His absence is a blow considering he has been Carlton’s best player against Collingwood in recent history.

Focus on Collingwood
Collingwood was extremely impressive against Essendon last week. It again won the contested footy count, and the tackling was really impressive. There are so many areas the Magpies have improved in during 2015, but I thought the biggest factor in last week’s win was their defensive structures. Over the opening four rounds, Collingwood has been a very hard team to score against. This was again the case last week with the Bombers only managing six goals.
The defensive pressure has been a real team focus. It is starting from the forwards who are making it very hard to clear the ball from Collingwood’s attacking 50. The midfield is winning contested footy which means that the backline has less inside 50s to counter.
But this is not to take anything away from Collingwood’s back six, which has been so solid. Experienced heads like Toovey, Nathan Brown and Tyson Goldsack have been influential, but youngsters like Marley Williams, Jack Frost, Jackson Ramsay, Adam Oxley and Tom Langdon are simply not losing one-on-one battles with their opponents.
I thought the key stage of last week’s game was the second quarter where Essendon really piled on the pressure. Last season, the Magpies probably would’ve fallen away and let the Bombers run over the top of them.
On this occasion, however, the young Collingwood defence weathered the storm and took the best the Bombers had to offer.
This is going to be very important against Carlton as there is no doubt that the Blues will be very emotionally driven to win for their coach and will start the game pumped up. Therefore, if the Magpies can hold this early charge, then they should be able to eventually run over the top of the Blues.

Player Focus - Collingwood
Paul Seedsman – Seedsman has constantly battled injuries and form throughout the early stages of his career, but we are all aware of the talent he has. Buckley has a lot of faith in him because also seems to slot him into the AFL side when fit. This faith was rewarded last weekend by Seedsman who had a career defining game. He had 33 disposals and kicked a crucial goal, which earned him the ANZAC Day Medal. Seedsman has played good games before, but his issue has always been consistency. He needs to back up this good game with another blinder against Carlton. His pace will play a role, so he looms as a really important player on Friday night.
Jackson Ramsay – Ramsay is forging a nice little spot for himself in Collingwood’s defence so far this year. He isn’t a huge accumulator, only averaging 15 disposals a game, but he does his job, and when he is needed he is able to take the game on. He has a big task keeping his spot given the star quality still to return to the side, along with the quality youth who are all vying for a position in the back half. But he has done more than enough to tell his coach that he can be relied upon to do a job when called upon. The next step for Ramsey is to get more involved offensively, which he is slowly starting to do the more he settles into the AFL environment.
Jamie Elliott – Some may say he has had a good run with the umpires over the past two weeks when it comes to freakish marks and goals, but to me, Elliott looks on the verge of really tearing a game apart. He has been steady in the opening month of football and has contributed a lot to the scoreboard. He has a terrific record against Carlton in particular and may be due for a really big game. The Blues have historically struggled to find the right match-up for Elliott, so it will be interesting to see how they counter him on Friday night. Elliott has been the match-winner before when these sides have met, and my money is on him to play a blinder yet again.

Focus on Carlton
The Blues obviously have a lot to play for. There is no doubt a strong desire to win for their coach on in his milestone game. There is also the incentive to win to keep the season on track. I have no doubt that a fired up Carlton is what we are going to see on Friday night.
However, the Blues can’t expect to win on passion alone. They need to take the game on and give the tall forwards plenty of one-out opportunities. With Liam Jones, Levi Casboult and Lachie Henderson up forward, there is marking power. The issue has been conversion and finding other contributors.
With the departure of players like Eddie Betts and Jeff Garlett in recent years, the Blues have at times looked slow up forward. The absence of Yarran and Thomas further adds to this problem. Carlton has been typically good from contested situations this year, but has just lacked firepower.
To beat the Magpies’ tight defence, the Blues are going to need multiple contributors outside of the usual suspects in Marc Murphy, Chris Judd and Bryce Gibbs.
Last week, it was players like Tom Bell, Andrejs Everitt and Gibbs, who were able to kick multiple goals in support of Lachie Henderson who booted five. The spread of goal kickers proved too much for the Saints and the Blues ran away convincing winners. The Blues will need this even performance from their second tier players.
The other consideration is the fact that Carlton had to travel to New Zealand last week and only had a six-day break to recover. In conjunction with the added hype of Malthouse’s coaching achievements, it will be interesting to see how the Blues recover from this big trip.

Player Focus - Carlton
Patrick Cripps – Cripps earned himself a Rising Star nomination for his terrific game against St.Kilda last week. He picked up 33 disposals, the majority of which were contested. He also led his side for tackling. Cripps is a giant for a midfielder, standing at 193cm tall. While he doesn’t possess electric speed, there is no doubt he has worked on his running ability. He is an inside midfielder who has a very bright future. It was his breakout game last week, and he’ll be looking to back that up.
Blaine Boekhorst – Boekhorst really adds something to the Carlton side in pace and x-factor. He picked up 13 disposals on debut, but showed glimpses of that breakneck speed which the Carlton fans have been screaming out for. He’ll take the game on and is a pretty good user of the football as well. He’s one to keep an eye on because he has the potential to turn games with individual pieces of brilliance. He is also a slightly older recruit so should be able to slot straight into the team quickly.
Lachie Henderson – The Blues desperately needed a big man to fire, and Henderson stepped up last week with five goals. He had an injury interrupted season in 2014, so will be looking to take the next step this year and really establish himself as a power forward of the competition. He will likely get the in form Jack Frost as an opponent this weekend, so he knows he is not going to get an easy run at it. A big game from Henderson will be vital if the Blues want to upset the Pies this weekend.

The Wrap Up
As I’ve mentioned, I’m expecting a fiery start. Carlton should come out full of vigour and really take it up to Collingwood. The Blues were able to come back from a four-goal deficit last weekend, but I don’t think they can rely on that this week considering Collingwood has been a very strong second half side this year. Carlton will need to turn the early intensity into scoreboard pressure and test this young Magpie outfit’s resolve.
On the other hand, the Magpies need to weather this early storm and wear the Blues down. The area Carlton has shown most promise this year has been contested football, so if the Magpies continue to win the contests (as they have done all season) then it is hard to see the Blues winning.
Carlton has a good list on paper and it has experience to call upon. Collingwood, though, has a bit more run off half back and on the wing. I think this will eventually win out as the game wears on.
I think it will be a close game though. Carlton has looked a much better side in the past fortnight and has a lot riding on this result.

Magpies by 15 points

Jock McHale: 38 Seasons 38 Facts

Collingwood News

Collingwood v Carlton
Friday May 1, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 7 Max 21
Chance of rain 20%: < 1mm
Wind: E 18kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.50
Carlton $2.60
One of football’s longest lasting records will change hands on Friday night when Mick Malthouse passes ‘Jock’ McHale’s 714 games as a league coach.
It’s a record that has lasted since McHale passed Jack Worrall’s tally of 279 games during the 1927 season – the same year that the Magpies started their unparalleled streak of four successive flags.
But the one record Malthouse - or anyone else for that matter - is unlikely to take off McHale is the fact that he coached for a record 38 seasons.
He started coaching Collingwood in 1912 - the year the Titanic was sunk - and coached all the way through until the end of the 1949 season.
To mark that McHale milestone that is likely to last forever, here are 38 facts out of the book, Jock, that you may not know about the man with the most famous name in the history of the Collingwood Football Club.

38 facts about the legendary Jock McHale
1. He was born James Francis McHale in Botany Rd, Alexandria, New South Wales, on December 12, 1882, and incredibly his birth certificate was incorrectly listed as James Francis ‘McKale’ (McHale).
2. His parents, John and Mary, both came from County Mayo, in Ireland, marrying in Louisburgh before coming separately to Australia in the early 1880s.
3. His father would spend several years as a police constable in Sydney, Coonabarabran and Warialda, NSW, before bringing the ever-growing McHale family - including young James - to Melbourne in the late 1880s.
4. He attended Christian Brothers’ College (CBC Parade) in Victoria Parade when he was a teenager. One of the men who would became a teammate and friend at Collingwood, Bob Rush, recalled that McHale initially struggled to get a game with the school side, but would become one of the most durable footballers from the first 25 years of the VFL.
5. Football folklore has it that McHale was first spotted by a Collingwood committeeman Jack Duncan while kicking a ball around an inner-city wood yard. It prompted an invitation to training at Victoria Park, which was to become his second home for the rest of his life.
6. McHale always credited his decision to give up cigarettes at the age of 20 as the reason behind his success in making the Collingwood senior team in 1903. On his retirement as coach almost 50 years later, The Argus wrote of him: “One of the best things he did for his football was to give up smoking at 20 in the days when cigarettes cost 3d for (a packet of) 25. He took his doctor’s advice and he hasn’t had a cigarette since.”
7. In his first five seasons with Collingwood, he missed only one night of more than 200 training sessions the club undertook.
8. To put McHale’s coaching longevity into context, the other VFL clubs (including University) had 175 different coaches during his 38 seasons, from 1912 to 1949.
9. He never had his driver’s licence. McHale used to frequently walk to training from his workplace at the Carlton Brewery in Bouverie St to Victoria Park, Abbotsford, and was a regular user of public transport.
10. McHale could never recall how he got his nickname 'Jock', though the first known reference was in Collingwood's annual report of 1912 - his first year as playing coach. It was popularised by The Herald's leading sporting and political cartoonist Sam Wells, who often drew McHale in a kilt and a Scottish hat. The irony was that McHale's family background was Irish, not Scottish.
11. He lost his first three games as coach - and there was even talk of a "reform" group calling for change at the top. Eight premierships later, Pies fans were grateful the reform group lost momentum quickly.
12. He was the first VFL footballer to reach 250 games as a player, against Fitzroy, in 1916.
13. McHale and his wife, Violet, lost two of their three children in heartbreaking fashion. His eldest son, James Francis, 'Frankie' to his parents, died of pneumonia, when he was only six, in 1919. His only daughter, Jean, died aged 17, of meningitis, in 1934.
14. Having been retired, he was forced into making a one-off playing comeback in 1920 - when he was 37 - after one of the new recruits failed to show up in time for the Round 1 clash in 1920. The Australasian said: "The veteran, who has been coaching Collingwood for years, deserves every credit for his prompt assistance in filling the gaps, though youth outpaced and outplayed him."
15. One of McHale's greatest strengths was his uncanny knack of judging his players' fitness, which he rarely faltered on. His decision to play an injured Albert Collier in the 1938 Grand Final was one such mistake, though his son, Jock Jr, would always insists the decision was forced upon his father.
16. Unlike Worrall, McHale had no issue with his players having a few beers after matches. As a cellarman and later a foreman at the Carlton Brewery, he often took his best players to the brewery for a few beers on the Saturday night after matches. He had the keys, quite literally, to the brewery. He even organised jobs for some of his players, particularly when the 1930's depression cut deep.
17. His coaching manifesto to young schoolboy players included: "don't eat more food than you can reasonably digest and be careful not to eat too quickly", "immediately after rising in the morning, and just before going to bed at night, it is advisable to drink a glass of cold water", and "take a cold bath every morning unless you are feeling unwell ... and a hot bath once a week is necessary."
18. Character was one of the most important aspects of McHale's assessment of players. He once wrote: "There is more to football than merely kicking a ball about. You will discover this as your training progresses. If played in the proper spirit, this game brings out the very best that is in a boy. It develops him morally and physically. It teaches him that to flinch spells cowardice. It teaches him, perhaps more than any other game does, the art of self-control. To be cool, with a level head, is absolutely essential. It teaches him to be unselfish and manly. All this may be summed up in the one word - character and if that is not worth developing, nothing is."
19. McHale was coach of the famous Machine, which won four consecutive premierships from 1927-30. But he did not like the moniker. He would say: "I did not set out with any specific intention of building a football 'machine. I never liked the term, because it suggested the side was a combination which worked to a rigid plan, and could not think. And if there is one quality we demand at Collingwood, it is the quick-thinking player with a dash of imagination."
20. Despite offers from other clubs, he never seriously considered leaving Collingwood. He also only wanted to be paid the same as his players, and he wanted his players to all received the same amount of money.
21. He was a believer in mid-season football trips to the country or interstate when a break in the VFL fixture allowed it. Famously, a trip to Western Australian in 1927 was the catalyst for the unity and the bond that would led the Machine to four straight flags, as did a trip to Brisbane and Sydney in 1935, which helped to set up back-to-back flags.
22. For two seasons, McHale coached Old Xaverians (at training, but not in matches) at the same time as he coached Collingwood. That was in 1928-29, and he did it as a favour to Collingwood's benefactor and his long-time friend John Wren. Wren's grandson, John, said years later: "They were close, grandfather and Jock. You would think that he would have gone to see Jock and put it this way - 'Old Xavs aren't going that well, so can you help them out?' I suppose he would have thought, let's just get the old icon down there, and things might improve."
23. He missed the crowning glory of the Machine - the 1930 Grand Final. He had pleurisy and influenza in the lead-up to the game, yet from his bedside in Brunswick he was still able to plot the tactics for the game. Bruce Andrew would say: "On the Sunday, he sent for some members of his selection committee to talk over the game ... Then, on the Tuesday, he sent for the secretary, Mr Frank Wraith. He gave Mr Wraith specific instructions that the team was not to use a ball at training on the Tuesday and Thursday nights. He said: 'I'm satisfied from what I've heard the players have had too much football and are leg weary." His insight was critical in the victory.
24. McHale co-authored one of the best skills books on football, 'the Australian Game of Football', in 1931, and also lent his name to one of the earliest football board games, the 'Jock McHale Table Football ‘game.
25. He was one of the first coaches to pioneer the importance of playing corridor football, instructing his men to get it long and direct into their great forwards - which at various stages included Dick Lee, Gordon Coventry and Ron Todd.
26. McHale's son, John, known as 'Jock Jr', would play 34 games for the Magpies during the 1940s. Jack Dyer's only suspension as a player came from striking McHale Jr. in a match at Punt Rd.
27. His tenure as coach took him through two cataclysmic wars, a Great Depression, and 12 Australian Prime Ministers, including one who was a close mate of the Magpies coach. McHale had played sport with John Curtin in Brunswick, and the pair kept in touch for many years. In Round 14, 1944, at the Collingwood-Footscray game, Prime Minster Curtin attended the game and even came into the rooms during the half-time break.
28. McHale coached during the 1910s, 1920s, 1930s and 1940s, and it was only in the 1940s that he could not take Collingwood to a premiership.
29. He credited the passion of Collingwood supporters for his longevity, saying their support had been critical. He would say: "They have been wonderful to me. I've always been a good winner and a poor loser and I know that many a time when I have been down in the dumps, the warmth and sympathy of the rank and file club supporters helped raise my spirit to look forward to something better next time.
30. The only VFL team McHale had a losing percentage against was arch-rivals, Carlton, and even then it was almost 48 per cent record.
31. For much of his life in football, McHale said that Dick Condon - who played in the 1890s and early 1900s - was the best footballer had had seen at Collingwood. As he got older, and coached Bob Rose in action, he labelled Rose as the best footballer he had seen.
32. McHale coached Collingwood for almost 14,000 days.
33. Three future VFL premiership coaches grew up by watching McHale closely - Norm Smith (who would be selected as VFL team of the century coach ahead of him), John Kennedy and Tom Hafey.
34. His 714th and last game as coach was in the 1949 first semi-final against Essendon. The Magpies lost by 82 points. He was appointed coach for the following year, but quit before the start of the season.
35. The only known recording of McHale comes from the victorious Collingwood rooms after the 1953 Grand Final. He wasn’t coach at the time, but was the patriarch of the club as well as chairman of selectors. He stood up on the seats in the change rooms, saying: “I’ve never been through a season in my life as I have this year, particularly today. It’s been the most thrilling season I’ve ever had with the Collingwood team. Although I am not coach, (I’m) only helping out, and giving a bit of guidance, (its) the most thrilling feeling I’ve had in all the premierships. I’ve never been so much worked up as I have been this year, to get into the four, and for more reason than one to win the premiership for ‘Phonsey’ Kyne and all the players connected to the Collingwood Football Club.”
36. McHale died just over a week after that 1953 Grand Final, having taken ill the day the after the game. Mick Malthouse was less than two months old when McHale passed away, aged 70.
37. He passed away while the Collingwood team was on their end of season trip to Tasmania. Such was the respect the team had for him that they marked his contribution with a minute's silence on a roadside in Tasmania.
38.  McHale never received any official recognition from the league while he was alive, and only received VFL life membership long after he died in 1977. Finally, the AFL honoured him in 2001 by naming the medal for the premiership coach after him.

Wednesday, April 29, 2015

Preview Round 5: Collingwood v Carlton

SportMatt

Collingwood v Carlton
Friday May 1, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 7 Max 21
Chance of rain 30%: < 1mm
Wind: E 18kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.50
Carlton $2.60
714 games, 467 wins, 59 finals, 16 grand finals, 8 premierships. That’s the legacy that John Francis “Jock” McHale left after 38 years as senior coach of the Collingwood Football Club. This Friday night current Carlton coach, Michael “Mick” Malthouse, will surpass one of those astounding records when he coaches his 715th senior VFL/AFL game. It’s an amazing effort from Malthouse to last this long in a coaching environment where just a few losses in a row can lead to calls for you to be sacked. Malthouse started out at the Footscray Bulldogs in 1984, before moving to the West Coast Eagles in 1990.
Straight away he lifted the dysfunctional Eagles into relevance, and eventually guided them to becoming the first interstate team to win a VFL/AFL premiership. Mick’s greatest achievement though may well have been his last premiership, the 2010 triumph with the club he faces this Friday night, the Collingwood Magpies. Malthouse spent 12 years at Collingwood, yet deep into that reign it looked as if he would go without delivering that elusive flag to the biggest club in the land. 2010 and 2011 were great years for the Pies though, as Mick guided them to back to back grand finals, with the raising of the cup in 2010 being one of the greatest moment’s in Malthouses’ long career.
Malthouse came out of semi retirement to coach Carlton at the start of 2013 and in his third year with the Blues will surpass McHales’ total games record this week. It is of course scripted to the second by the AFL that he faces Collingwood of all teams. The Carlton and Collingwood’s rivalry is already big enough yet when you add in Malthouse’s milestone this game becomes massive. Collingwood have started the season well, sitting with a 3 win and 1 loss record after 4 games. Carlton on the other hand have started it poorly, with their first win coming only last week after 3 consecutive losses to start the season. The Pies seem to have found a consistency of effort that was lacking last year while the Blues are about where everyone expected them to be, closer to the bottom of the ladder then the top.

PREVIOUS FORM
Collingwood’s form leading into their annual ANZAC day clash with Essendon was nothing spectacular, with two wins over lowly opponents St Kilda and Brisbane, and a heavy defeat against Adelaide. What was spectacular though was the way the Magpies performed on Saturday at the MCG. The Pies revelled in the wet conditions playing a tough, contested brand of footy that really suited the weather. The Magpies dominated Essendon for large periods of the game, and after half time ran away with a confidence boosting 20 point win. What was really impressive was the performance of the Pies lesser lights though, with Jack Frost, Paul Seedsman, Jack Crisp and Marley Williams all having excellent games. Seedsman walked away with the ANZAC medal which would have been a dream long held by the life long Collingwood fan.
Carlton travelled to New Zealand last Saturday on the back of three consecutive losses to start the season. Defeats to Richmond, West Coast and Essendon made the trip to Wellington against St Kilda a must win game but it didn’t start well for the Blues. They found themselves trailing the lowly Saints by 26 points in the second quarter and it looked like a disaster was about to occur for Carlton. From there though the Blues took control of the match, mainly due to captain Marc Murphy and youngster Patrick Cripps. The output from second year Cripps would have been a sight to warm all Blues fans hearts as he racked up 33 possessions and showed he has a massive future in the game. It was a much needed win for Carlton and gives them a much needed confidence boost leading into a clash with the old enemy.

COLLINGWOOD PREVIEW
For Collingwood, season 2015 was supposed to be a struggle, it was supposed to be a season here head coach Nathan Buckley would come under pressure and the Pies would fail to play finals once again. Four rounds in and many are changing their tune now, yes Collingwood aren’t a top 4 side, despite sitting there now, but they have shown that they can more then cope with many other sides in the competition. The draw has helped, getting to play St Kilda and Brisbane but the win over Essendon was nothing short of impressive. Collingwood played a brand of football against Essendon that reminded many of their manic pressure and attack on the ball carrier that made them so dangerous back in 2010 and 2011. But this side is different, it’s a side that Buckley has built on defense, and a young defense at that. The likes of Langdon, Williams, Ramsay, Oxley and Frost have improved the Magpies dramatically down back and made them a tough team to defeat. This is a Collingwood side that is showing signs of improving for the first time in several seasons.
This Friday night Collingwood will have a selection problem on their hands, but of the positive variety. Nearly all of the 22 that played in the win over Essendon can state a case for being retained, with only positional changes based on the opposition maybe forcing a change. The two who may come under the most pressure are Adam Oxley and Corey Gault, who both failed to have a large impact in the win, but in their own way are crucial to the teams current game plan. If Collingwood are to replace either they would have to replace them with a similar player, in Gault’s case that would be either Jarrod Witts or Patrick Karnezis, and in Oxley’s case Jonathan Marsh. Witts is an interesting one, he’s now played several weeks in the VFL at a consistent level and would be keen to start a long term ruck partnership with the potential star that is Brodie Grundy. Whether the Pies think this is the right time to play two genuine rucks is the question though.
No matter what the final selection is, the Pies have depth now, which for a lot of last season wasn’t readily available to them. This Collingwood team will believe it should defeat Carlton, and it really should.

OPPOSITION ANALYSIS
Carlton came into season 2015 with high internal expectations even if most outside the club thought they wouldn’t achieve too much at all. After four rounds, the internal expectations have changed, terms like “rebuild” and “long term approach” are now being thrown around and that isn’t something that fans of a club that finished 13th want to hear. Last week’s comeback against St Kilda was the first good sign for the Blues in 2015 though, and the performance of Patrick Cripps would give their fans some hope going forward. It’s going to be a long year for the Blues though, and it doesn’t get any easier up against the old enemy.
The Carlton forward line has taken a severe hit in recent seasons with just about all of their leading goal kickers leaving the club. The loss of Betts, Garlett, Waite and Fevola has left them with a skeleton forward structure made up of players who excel more in the VFL then they do at AFL level. Lachie Henderson is the obvious exception here though, he seems to have improved yet again and was very impressive last week in that win over the Saints. The Blues rely heavily on goals from their strong midfield brigade and this week come up against a Pies defense that hasn’t conceded 100 points in a game yet this season. Carlton will have to get more insider 50’s then the Pies to put the score on the board, that’s clear to see really.
The Blues have one area of strength and that is the midfield. After 4 rounds the Blues lead the league for centre clearances and are fourth overall for total clearances from stoppages. It’s no shock that they rank so high in those categories, with names like Judd, Simpson, Murphy, Gibbs, Armfield and Carrazzo in their midfield grouping. Against Essendon two weeks ago the Blues won the clearance count by 23, a staggering amount, yet accuracy at goal cost them any chance of winning. Carlton’s ruck stocks aren’t strong due to the absence of number one choice Matthew Kreuzer. Cameron Wood has filled in manfully but will face a test against the best young ruckman in the AFL, Brodie Grundy, this week. On Friday Carlton’s midfield runs into a Pies central core missing two crucial components, Steele Sidebottom and Levi Greenwood. In their place though others have stepped up, although you would assume Carlton will win the midfield battle which should give them some chance in this game.
Carlton’s defense has been a problem for the Blues for a while now. Last season it ranked 14th for total points conceded and at the moment it’s not fairing much better in 2015. They only have the one class key position defender and he is Michael Jamison, who you’d think would get first crack at Travis Cloke. Carlton rely on Sam Rowe and their medium defenders to assist Jamison and most weeks it simply doesn’t work. They do have decent enough rebound out of defense with Zach Tuohy, one of the best Irishmen to play the game, improving every season and leading the way. Carlton also have to worry about the Pies ace in the pack, Jamie Elliott, who is fast becoming one of the best small forwards in the league. Who matches up on him, and their effectiveness in doing so, may well determine if Carlton have any chance of winning this game at all.
The Blues have looked capable in patches so far this season but haven’t been able to put it together for a full game yet. If they let their guard down for even a small period this Friday night they will be punished by an in form Magpies line up. The return of Chris Judd and probable return of Troy Menzel will help their cause a fair bit but Judd isn’t the player he once was so reliance on him isn’t prudent any more. Carlton will have to dominate the midfield battle to win this game, and the problem that exists there is two fold, Scott Pendlebury and Dane Swan. If they can restrict those two then the Blues may push the Magpies to the limit indeed.

TIP
Carlton and Collingwood may sit far apart on the ladder after four rounds, and the expectations of both teams may be a lot different now, but I can still see Carlton being competitive in this game. Their last trip to the MCG resulted in their best performance of the season, as they closed late to just miss out on an upset win over Essendon. Carlton will prefer the forecast dry conditions on Friday night and the extra motivation of Mick Malthouse’s record breaking game will see them up and about. Collingwood have to be careful not to let their guard down after such an impressive win over the Bombers last Saturday. That performance was as good as anything this Magpies outfit has put out in 12 months so they will be hoping to repeat it, if not improve.
Ultimately I think it comes down to personnel and talent as to who wins this game and Collingwood come out on top in just about every area. Even in Carlton’s strength area, the midfield, the Pies have been performing at a top level in recent weeks. The difference in this game will be defense though, and that’s where Collingwood will have a large advantage and prove too good for a Blues outfit in transition.

MAGPIES BY 19 POINTS.

Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Preview Round 5: Collingwood v Carlton

AFL

SUMMARY
Collingwood v Carlton
Friday May 1, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 7 Max 21
Chance of rain 20%: < 1mm
Wind: NNE 19kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.48
Carlton $2.65
The hype around Friday night's contest will be about Mick Malthouse's remarkable longevity in the game and the Blues would love to upset their fierce rival to mark his milestone. But the odds are against Malthouse scoring his first victory over the Magpies as Carlton coach. Collingwood was superb in the wet on Anzac Day, upsetting the Bombers with relentless pressure and tackling. The Magpies' defence led by Paul Seedsman, Nathan Brown and Jack Frost stood firm and restricted the dangerous Essendon forwards. The Blues opened their account in 2015 with a 40-point victory over the Saints in New Zealand and should be boosted by the return of champion midfielder Chris Judd and promising forward Troy Menzel.

LAST FIVE TIMES
  1. R15, 2014, Collingwood 13.13 (91) d Carlton 11.10 (76) at the MCG
  2. R7, 2014, Collingwood 14.20 (104) d Carlton 10.10 (70) at the MCG
  3. R15, 2013, Collingwood 17.16 (118) d Carlton 12.5 (77) at the MCG
  4. R2, 2013, Collingwood 17.15 (117) d Carlton 15.10 (100) at the MCG
  5. R15, 2012, Carlton 12.13 (85) d Collingwood 8.14 (62) at the MCG
THE SIX POINTS
  1. In the Magpies' win over Carlton in round seven last year their small forwards did the damage, with Dayne Beams kicking four goals and Jamie Elliott three. In round 15 Steele Sidebottom starred with 33 disposals and two goals.
  2. Collingwood has won the most contested possessions of any team this season, averaging 164.5 a game. Carlton is ranked sixth with 143.2.
  3. Collingwood has dominated Carlton recently, winning the past four contests and nine of 11 since late in 2009.
  4. The Magpies are second this season for taking the ball inside 50, with 242 at 60.5 a game. The Blues have struggled with 199 at 49.7.
  5. Carlton's final score against St Kilda last Saturday was the first time the Blues had kicked triple figures this season. Their average score is 86 a game while Collingwood averages 89.
  6. After kicking four second-half goals to help turn the match in Carlton's favour against the Saints, Tom Bell rose 30 places in the Official AFL Player Ratings, from No. 311 overall to 281.
IT'S A BIG WEEK FOR …
Mick Malthouse. He becomes the AFL/VFL record-holder when he coaches his 715th game to surpass legendary Collingwood coach Jock McHale and would like nothing better than to record a win over his former club.

PREDICTION: Collingwood by five points.

Injury List

Injury Update Tuesday, April 28
Collingwood v Carlton
Friday May 1, 7.50pm
MCG
7mate / Fox Footy 7.30pm

Weather:
Min 7 Max 21
Chance of rain 20%: < 1mm
Wind: NNE 17kph

Betting:
Collingwood $1.48
Carlton $2.65
Player
Injury
Status
Tony Armstrong Knee TBC
Levi Greenwood* Fractured ankle 4-6 weeks
Darcy Moore Hamstring TBC
Brent Macaffer* Knee 5-7 weeks
Ben Reid Quad 1-2 weeks
Matt Scharenberg Knee Available
Steele Sidebottom Broken thumb 1-3 weeks
Ben Sinclair Hamstring 5-6 weeks
*Placed on the club's long-term injury list

Collingwood News


Star midfielder Steele Sidebottom could return from a broken thumb in a matter of weeks.
Sidebottom was left nursing his hand after sustaining the injury during the final quarter of Collingwood’s round one victory over Brisbane in round one.
But less than a month later, Collingwood's Director of Football Neil Balme has declared the midfielder could return within a fortnight.
“Steele Sidebottom is going really well,” Balme told CollingwoodTV’s Blackmores Injury Update.
“He’ll more than likely get an x-ray on that thumb just to see how it’s going.
"If we get the good news, he won’t be that far away – probably a week or two.”
A return of Sidebottom in the coming weeks would leave Collingwood with arguably its strongest midfield group of the year.
Balme also noted that the sight of Dane Swan in a moonboot on Monday was merely precautionary as the midfielder attempted to take unnecessary weight off his ankle.
“We’re very confident that he’ll be fine for this week." Balme said.
"Moonboots aren’t always the disaster that they look like they are."
The news wasn’t as good for Darcy Moore and Tony Armstrong after the defenders sustained injuries in Collingwood’s VFL loss to Essendon on Sunday.
Armstrong left the game in the first quarter with a knee complaint while Moore pulled up sore and felt for his hamstring in the fourth quarter.
“When he did it, it looked like he might be out forever. Fortunately, after another look at it, it’s not quite as bad,” Balme said of Moore.
“We haven’t got the results of the scans yet. He’ll certainly miss this week, but hopefully not too much more.”
The duo will most likely be replaced in Collingwood’s VFL side by Matthew Scharenberg and Ben Kennedy after Balme cleared both fit to play on the weekend, though Balme was uncertain on whether Ben Reid would join them.
“We’ll train him pretty hard this week and we’ll see. Whether he plays on the weekend is just a matter of where it fits into his program,” Balme said.
Meanwhile, Levi Greenwood is off crutches and is expected to start running again this week as he overcomes a fractured ankle.

Monday, April 27, 2015

The Magpie

'Out Of The Darkness' taken by Charles Davis and published in the Gang-gang column of The Canberra Times.

The Collingwood Bugle is a wholly owned subsidiary of Madame Fifi's House of Earthly Pleasures, Smith Street, Collingwood